Personal Statement Resources 2012

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Minnerbelle

Full Member
Moderator Emeritus
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2009
Messages
5,904
Reaction score
5,374
Now that everyone's revving up for this app cycle, and we have a ton of PS readers set up, I thought it might be nice to consolidate old threads that had great advice about PS's and maybe get new contributions.

So to start, a few links. If you go down a couple posts on the first one, TT linked a ton of others too, so def look into that. And feel free to add to the list!

Help with Personal Statement (2009) <--- READ THIS ONE
What should a personal statement contain (2010)
VMCAS Personal Statement (2011)

Anytime I read a PS for someone, I end up saying the same thing to pretty much everyone, so I figured I should just post it. I'm sure there are others in the same boat, so it might be nice to compile these comments for applicants to read before they struggle through a draft and have it hacked apart. So my personal opinions on the PS (which may or may not mean much):

*The 2 main missions to accomplish in writing the PS is to 1, answer the freaking prompt and 2, make you "likeable." It's actually amazing how many people don't actually answer the prompt!

*A part of making you "likeable" is writing a PS that's easily readable. The overly flowy sentences with adverbs/adjectives for every verb/noun was cute in 5th grade, but it's reeaaallly taxing to the reader. I totally understand the urge to put in as much information in that little bitty space they give you, but try to think about what the reader wants to read, not what YOU want them to hear. If the reader can breeze through your PS and have positive thoughts about you, you're golden. That's much more important than spending 200 words describing what the cyanotic dog looked like when it died. It's really not pertinent to your becoming a veterinarian, and you're lucky if the reader even actually cared to read each word (that you spent hours constructing). Best advice I've ever gotten in writing was to go through and cross out EVERY word that is not absolutely necessary to get your point across. It's a painful process, so if you don't have the balls for it, ask someone else to do it. Then you can add back in a couple that you would just die without.

*Another part of being "likeable" is to stand out in some way. But I think some people take that a little too literally. Standing out doesn't HAVE to involve the most ground breaking idea or anecdote, or some edgy writing style if that's not your thing. What's really horrible is when you take something that's NOT super special and make it out to be that way. There's really no reason to make a blood draw sound like open heart surgery, no matter how proud of it you are. Standing out can be as simple as showing that you have a mature and composed view of the profession that applies to you. Just keep it real, and have the reader like you for who you are.

*Have a ton of people read and comment about your PS, and more importantly, be smart about how you take those comments. Everyone will have opinions and there's no one PS that's going to make EVERYONE happy. So you have to decide in the end what to dump/leave. Make sure you get some opinions from people who are in the veterinary field and/or have read many vet school PS's. Even if you write a touching PS that your English professor or your mom thinks is a work of art, they don't know what's cliche or appropriate for this profession. Remember that in your life, you are probably THE "vet/animal person" and any story you have about animals is very intriguing to those around you. But when you send your PS in, you are just one of hundreds/thousands of animal lovers who have gone out and spent time in a vet's office. This again goes back to the standing out thing. Hundreds of PS's starts out with a story about a childhood pet, a sad euthanasia, or a pet being rushed in on emergency (or even worse, the no money pet that gets treated free out of the kindness of the veterinarian's heart). There's nothing wrong with using one of those stories. But don't count on it being the thing that will set you apart. And just really really keep in mind your audience. Again, it's about what they want to read, not what you want them to hear.

*Do not make your PS a resume regurgitator. You're wasting space! This is also not the place to brag about your job description. I've seen several PS's where it seemed like all the writer wanted to do was talk about what a great (vet/lab) technician they were. Just remember that your PS is about why you should become a veterinarian, not why you should win the technician of the year award.

*You can talk about how adversity makes you who you are or whatever if it's pertinent to what you're saying in your PS. But there's no reason to draw unnecessary attention to your flaws in your PS. You might think that you have one giant blemish on your application that is hindering your ability to get an acceptance, and the PS is a tempting place to talk about it. But that's what the explanation statement is for. People might have differing opinions about this, but there are so many positive things you can say about yourself. The PS is your chance to sell yourself. You don't want to waste space talking about your negatives, unless it's one of those negatives that turns into a positive ya kno?

*If you do send your PS out to PS readers on this forum, be appreciative of their time. Even if you don't like what they have to say, acknowledge that some random stranger took time out of their day (and sometimes seriously hours of their day) to help you out asking for nothing in return. Do not throw an embarrassing tantrum about what they have to say. You can ask for clarification, but don't get all bitter and tell them off. Like I said before, you are the captain of your PS ship. You make the decisions about what advice to take/not to take, and you certainly don't have to incorporate every suggestion.

That's about all I got for now. Let's get some more on here!
 
Thank you, Minnerbelle!!
 
Oh my gosh, thank you!!! Getting my PS organized (and written) has so far been torturous!
 
I recently had somebody read my personal statement through the pre-med department at my school. They said they felt it was a great piece of creative writing, but wasn't sure if that is what the admissions people would be looking for. Almost everything I have read has said something about making it unique or creative to stand out from the crowd, etc.

Basically I opened with a story, tied it into some other experiences/how those experiences influenced my career choice, and came back to the first story at the end.

Are they looking for something more straight forward? I know it's difficult to provide input without reading it, but what are your thoughts on creativity in personal statements?
 
I recently had somebody read my personal statement through the pre-med department at my school. They said they felt it was a great piece of creative writing, but wasn't sure if that is what the admissions people would be looking for. Almost everything I have read has said something about making it unique or creative to stand out from the crowd, etc.

Basically I opened with a story, tied it into some other experiences/how those experiences influenced my career choice, and came back to the first story at the end.

Are they looking for something more straight forward? I know it's difficult to provide input without reading it, but what are your thoughts on creativity in personal statements?

I think schools value creativity as long as you answer their questions. ie. why do you want to be a vet, what do you know about the profession, what are your career goals, and who are you?

You don't want to be too artsy that it's distracting from your main points. From my research on Personal Statements, I think some creativity is okay. You don't want to sound boring.

I agree the Personal Statement is SOO hard to write. I wrote one and then wanted to change it and now I have the WORST writers block on it for the past few weeks now 🙁
 
I soo sorry if this has been answered or if it's a bit on the idiot side, but how do I submit my PS to any one of these wonderful people willing to donate their time and effort into helping me submit the best I can? 😕
 
I soo sorry if this has been answered or if it's a bit on the idiot side, but how do I submit my PS to any one of these wonderful people willing to donate their time and effort into helping me submit the best I can? 😕

Just send them a PM asking if they can still help out, they will most likely give you their email address to send your file to.
 
PS question: is it safe to assume the people reading the PS are DVMs (or at least have a good medical vocabulary), or should the PS be written so that anyone could understand any medical content?
 
PS question: is it safe to assume the people reading the PS are DVMs (or at least have a good medical vocabulary), or should the PS be written so that anyone could understand any medical content?

Absolutely the latter; you cannot assume they are all DVMs, or even people with a heavy background in science. And if it were heavy on the medical content, I'd be slightly concerned that the writer was missing the point of the PS.
 
Absolutely the latter; you cannot assume they are all DVMs, or even people with a heavy background in science. And if it were heavy on the medical content, I'd be slightly concerned that the writer was missing the point of the PS.

Thank you for the response.

I do understand the point of the PS. I'm using a case as a springboard/way to tie everything together. It's more space efficient to use the relevant words like "cystotomy" and "urolith," but if I shouldn't use those words I'll find a different way to get the point across. Thanks again!
 
Thank you for the response.

I do understand the point of the PS. I'm using a case as a springboard/way to tie everything together. It's more space efficient to use the relevant words like "cystotomy" and "urolith," but if I shouldn't use those words I'll find a different way to get the point across. Thanks again!

Oh, I believe you do, but that's because I've read other posts from you. My point was that if I were on the applications committee reading a PS and it was one long essay chock full of medical-ese ... I'd wonder. 🙂

I think you're ok with a limited number of words like that, where the reader can look it up if they don't know it. I more meant that it shouldn't be extensive descriptions of technical science concepts - the kind of thing where a non-science reader would just glaze over reading it. Ya know?
 
Oh, I believe you do, but that's because I've read other posts from you. My point was that if I were on the applications committee reading a PS and it was one long essay chock full of medical-ese ... I'd wonder. 🙂

I think you're ok with a limited number of words like that, where the reader can look it up if they don't know it. I more meant that it shouldn't be extensive descriptions of technical science concepts - the kind of thing where a non-science reader would just glaze over reading it. Ya know?

That makes sense. I'm definitely not aiming for super technical or dense!
 
Okay, so I've been getting mixed reviews about the first sentence on my PS.

Right now it says
"Walls of books towered around me as I flipped through the pages to fill my curiosity.
... Growing up with books sparked my love of science, showed me the value of education, and motivated me to explore the world."

My high school English teacher (who is now a professional writer) thinks that the first sentence is not enough to 'grab' the attention of the reader. It is a little passive.
My boyfriend who is an engineer and a friend of mine agree. My vet student friend loves it.

My English teacher suggested a more dramatic opener (like a specific story about my study abroad experience that I talked about, saving a patient's life, etc) might be better. He said that specific examples are usually more convincing.

The only problem is that I'm trying to avoid the 'cookie cutter' personal statement openers and trying to make something more unique. Because everyone works with animals to save their lives.

I might reword it to "Walls of books towered as I flipped through the pages, trying to find answers to my questions." ... Growing up with books sparked my love of science, showed me the value of education, and motivated me to explore the world.

Any thoughts? Should I keep the sentence or change it around completely to something else? I'm a little concerned since everyone has been commenting on that. I know might be hard to read without reading the whole thing. Thank you 🙂
 
I think the phrase "flipped through the pages" is very casual. "Scoured the pages" or "searched through the pages" or something like that might convey more interest. To me, "flipped through the pages" sounds like something I'd do if I was bored and looking at a magazine to pass the time.
That's just my opinion, though, and I'm neither an English major nor a current vet student.
 
I think the phrase "flipped through the pages" is very casual. "Scoured the pages" or "searched through the pages" or something like that might convey more interest. To me, "flipped through the pages" sounds like something I'd do if I was bored and looking at a magazine to pass the time.
That's just my opinion, though, and I'm neither an English major nor a current vet student.

Yeah I agree the word "flipped" does sound casual and passive. Thank you for your suggestions. 🙂
 
I like your second option, better. That said, I am honestly trying to figure out if it matters. I have spoken to two people who are on the application review committee, recently. One person told me it was important to be creative and use something to really grab the reader. The other told me not to write creatively and to refrain from anecdotal stories and just get right to the point. Obviously both people have the potential to read my Personal statement, so who should I play to? Has anyone else gotten feedback from committee members, like this? I find it so confusing and frustrating. its not like there isn't enough pressure, already!
I am not a real creative writer, myself, so I am hoping that whoever the poor soul is that reads mine wont fall asleep before they finish it. (I went with the get to the point strategy).
 
I like your second option, better. That said, I am honestly trying to figure out if it matters. I have spoken to two people who are on the application review committee, recently. One person told me it was important to be creative and use something to really grab the reader. The other told me not to write creatively and to refrain from anecdotal stories and just get right to the point. Obviously both people have the potential to read my Personal statement, so who should I play to? Has anyone else gotten feedback from committee members, like this? I find it so confusing and frustrating. its not like there isn't enough pressure, already!
I am not a real creative writer, myself, so I am hoping that whoever the poor soul is that reads mine wont fall asleep before they finish it. (I went with the get to the point strategy).

I've heard get right to the point from friends who have gone through the process before, after all, we only get so much space and they will only spend a couple min reading each one.

You want to get right to the point but I've also heard to make sure you "show" the reader what you are talking about rather than "tell". So maybe talk about what you learned about the profession through your experiences. Include a few experiences that stand out and ones that you've really learned from.

The Dean of Admissions at my IS vet school said that one thing they REALLY look for when you are writing your personal statement is when did you make your ADULT decision to become a vet. They don't want to hear the whole "i've wanted to be a vet ever since I was 6 and we had to euthanize our dog."

Maybe, also try to give them a picture of who you are and what kind of doctor you will become. I think when they said that they don't want creative is that they don't want something that is written in flowery, story line language that doesn't tell them much about YOU. Remember to make it Personal about YOU. Hope this helps. I agree that writing this is confusing and challenging too.
 
Just want to bump this guy up for this year's applicants. There are some great resources here for PS writing.
 
In the event I don't get in this year (for class of 2017), I am hoping to get my application started as much as possible before May. I graduate then and won't have access to school resources after that.

I'm not sure how much I want to mess with my personal statement? I was really happy with it. And I got 3/4 interviews and at least two waitlists with a 3.39 GPA and <250 hours of veterinary experience, so I'm thinking my evaluations and PS were pretty solid. My leadership, past experiences, awards, and animal experience were solid also. Obviously, I'm going to do file reviews and take whatever suggestions I get, but does anyone have any words against using the same PS if it seemed to work?
 
In the event I don't get in this year (for class of 2017), I am hoping to get my application started as much as possible before May. I graduate then and won't have access to school resources after that.

I'm not sure how much I want to mess with my personal statement? I was really happy with it. And I got 3/4 interviews and at least two waitlists with a 3.39 GPA and <250 hours of veterinary experience, so I'm thinking my evaluations and PS were pretty solid. My leadership, past experiences, awards, and animal experience were solid also. Obviously, I'm going to do file reviews and take whatever suggestions I get, but does anyone have any words against using the same PS if it seemed to work?

Don't do it. It's tempting, but just don't. If they recognize it as the same, it looks lazy. See the Wisconsin 2017 thread.

You don't have to change what you choose to write about, but rewrite the PS. You may find you write a better one, or decide to write about something else entirely. My PS was very different from one year to the next, and it made a big difference, I believe.
 
Don't do it. It's tempting, but just don't. If they recognize it as the same, it looks lazy. See the Wisconsin 2017 thread.

You don't have to change what you choose to write about, but rewrite the PS. You may find you write a better one, or decide to write about something else entirely. My PS was very different from one year to the next, and it made a big difference, I believe.

And yet I only made slight changes between my second and third personal statement and did much better the third year applying... schools that rejected me the year prior, interviewed and waitlisted me... I think it really just depends on the school.... I wouldn't submit the exact same thing but I don't think you always have to make drastic changes.... small changes can make a huge difference.
 
And yet I only made slight changes between my second and third personal statement and did much better the third year applying... schools that rejected me the year prior, interviewed and waitlisted me... I think it really just depends on the school.... I wouldn't submit the exact same thing but I don't think you always have to make drastic changes.... small changes can make a huge difference.

That's kind of what I was thinking.... I planned to have addional people read it and rework it a little, but I don't know how many ways to change writing about what inspired me to this path. And as I said, I had weak stats otherwise that I plan to improve, and feel like my PS was one of the major strengths of my application that got me the attention I got. So I don't want to screw that up by abandoning entirely! I always find some sentence later that sounds silly to me, but I want to keep the main ideas.
 
I really wish I had known about all this before my first cycle this year!!! Its so helpful.... Oh well, I will spread the word to my prevet friends that are reapplying, this thread is great!!
 
Great post. Also, great advice, Minnerbelle! Those are the couple of things I made myself hammer out during my writing process: answer the prompt, don't tell a sob story, don't be a hero.
I started VMCAS the day it opened and for months I was blocked on my PS. I did NOT want to start off with a colorful anecdote leading to a spiritual epiphany. The more I brainstormed, the more I kept recalling one very tough night I had that I felt was indicative of my best qualities.
So, I typed it out as long-winded and detail-saturated and flowery as I pleased, and I dove off from that point and banged out my entire essay in an hour. Then, I cut the story out and pasted it into a separate doc. What I had left was gold.
I spent the next couple of weeks adding an intro and a closing, finessing, polishing, and spit-shining. Everyone I asked wanted me to keep the story in, but it's not my angle. The rest of my PS embodied the tone of the story, and thats all I wanted.
What I had left over was a description of how I set my sights on the career goals that I have, where I picture myself as a vet, and how I love working with the people I meet through the field. I explained that I have always loved being part of a field that is always evolving.
I also want to back the piece of advice from the beginning: print it out and just start crossing out words. I am incredibly wordy myself (half of this post can be safely deleted), and its HARD, but necessary. I'd also recommend reading it aloud. If you have to hesitate to keep reading a sentence, it needs to be streamlined.
 
*bump*

For those of you starting on your personal statement this is helpful advice!
 
I wish I had known about this prior to my first cycle last year!! 😕 New applicants, take advantage of this!! 👍
 
*bump*

For those of you starting on your personal statement this is helpful advice!

Thanks for bumping this!!

Question for you guys...and pardon me if this is a stupid one, but does the VMCAS PS question change yearly? I'm waiting to go ahead and start mine, and I've looked at their sample app, but I'm afraid if I start writing now, that I'll get something I really like going, then realize it doesn't relate to the question 🙄
 
Thanks for bumping this!!

Question for you guys...and pardon me if this is a stupid one, but does the VMCAS PS question change yearly? I'm waiting to go ahead and start mine, and I've looked at their sample app, but I'm afraid if I start writing now, that I'll get something I really like going, then realize it doesn't relate to the question 🙄
Even if they do change it, you will need to answer ALL of those questions that make up the old PS prompt, during any potential interviews you might receive. So, it wouldn't be a waste, just early prep for interviews.
 
Does anyone have updated links? A couple in the original post aren't working. 🙁
 
Top