Does anyone else think that getting "too much" help on the personal statement is a little unethical?
...
Having someone read it for any glaring issues is one thing
...
what's important for me for the statements is for the adcoms to know the person behind the resume. If someone else wrote it or worked on it very extensively, then that's not really "me" or my story...
Three disjointed comments... I agree with the first thing I quoted, but only because I'm a good writer and I'm jealous of that advantage - the opposite side's argument would be if you're a really cool person and would be a spectacular vet but are a crappy writer and just can't get your coolness across in words very well, it's somewhat unfair that you lose your chance to be a vet, which in the end requires very little creative writing as a job skill.
As for the second, for me having other people read stuff like this is a necessary check on my tendency to push the envelope too far. I hate personal statements, they're always crap. Especially after reading the example that Boxsterluv posted... stuff like that makes me gag. The trouble is, I can play the game. I can write a perfect "what they want to hear" essay, and I always hate myself for doing it. I am *so* going to start my statement with "I can tell all the requisite cute childhood stories, but quite honestly those experiences deserve no direct credit for my decision to become a veterinarian." Now, I know I shouldn't do that. It's too much. But usually I need a rational person to look at my statement and say "wow, that sounds really harsh, maybe you should... you know, tone it down a bit." In that sense, other people govern my content a lot. But, I always write the words. Stealing literal chunks of someone else's writing, that's shady.
And on the third point, and relating to the first as well... Abilities to communicate in writing and in conversation are very well correlated, in my experience. If you're a truly crappy writer but you get someone else to write your essay, you'll get invited for an interview and your ability to speak off the cuff will not match the level of your essay. I think the astute adcom member would notice something like that, and realize that interactive communication is a much more important part of a veterinarian's day, and that person would not get in. At least, I hope they're looking for stuff like that.
Gosh, I sound really bitter and angry. <sigh> Did I mention how much I hate personal statements...?