MD Poor Evaluations during 3rd year

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

pillowsnice

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
May 25, 2015
Messages
283
Reaction score
161
Currently on ob/gyn right now and I honestly believe that most of the attendings hate me. They don't want to teach, they ignore me, and only answer me by nodding their head or one word answers. Obviously I am worried about what the evals will say as I feel like it can't be that great. Where I am, students essentially shadow for the whole clerkship and are not expected to see any patients on their own. So, I think that the eval is based upon how much they liked you. I am generally a more introverted, laid back person, so my personality doesn't match well with most of the attendings. I honestly don't know what I should do or how this will effect my future. I just hope they don't write negative things that end up on my MSPE and tank my application.
 
Unfortunately, you'll find that there are a lot of attendings/residents who act in the way you describe. It's not that they hate you, it's more likely that they are just not interested in teaching. Evaluations suck, and clerkship grades as a whole are part of a broken, subjective system, but keep your chin up and do your best. Your evaluations will most likely not have anything so negative that they'll impact your future. Good luck!
 
Don't sweat it. It'd be more of a problem if this were a recurring theme across rotations.
 
Standard experience of students on OBGYN clerkship. You'll be fine. Would be more worried if it were any other clerkship.

Wasn’t mine. But absolutely what it is on surgery.
 
Unfortunately, you'll find that there are a lot of attendings/residents who act in the way you describe. It's not that they hate you, it's more likely that they are just not interested in teaching. Evaluations suck, and clerkship grades as a whole are part of a broken, subjective system, but keep your chin up and do your best. Your evaluations will most likely not have anything so negative that they'll impact your future. Good luck!

Is there anything that would be negative enough to impact my future? I feel like they might write that I was quiet and so seemed uninterested.
 
Is there anything that would be negative enough to impact my future? I feel like they might write that I was quiet and so seemed uninterested.
Idt thats a big deal unless its a consistent theme
 
Is there anything that would be negative enough to impact my future? I feel like they might write that I was quiet and so seemed uninterested.

I find it hard to believe that a comment like that, alone, would affect your chances of matching at residency. Again, consistency is the key here. If all your evals say that (or more than 1-2), then yes, it'll play a role. One won't hurt you.
 
A couple of thoughts from both sides of the aisle.

As a resident, it's important to appreciate that we are, often, overwhelmed with clinical work and struggle to stay on top of the things that we need to get done on a regular basis, much less side aside dedicated time for teaching. That doesn't excuse what you perceive to be as being ignored altogether, but nevertheless it's important to understand this and take it into account. Residents are often tired, stressed, and just trying to make it through the day. Try and cut them some slack if you can. That being said, the "best" medical students tend to 1) figure out a way to make themselves an asset (i.e., being helpful to the team) rather than a liability (i.e., increasing the work of residents/attendings); 2) are pleasant to be around (this doesn't necessarily mean that you need to be "liked," but yes, it helps); 3) appear to be interested in what's going on on their service (one of the quickest ways for me to lose interest in trying to teach you is if you make it abundantly clear that you're not interested in the rotation or the service); 4) be reliable and do things successfully when asked.

As an application reviewer, in general most clerkship comments include the same general tone and content of student reviews. It is rare for comments to be exceptionally helpful or harmful, and generally you need to do something particularly outstanding or particularly egregious to earn these comments. I wouldn't worry too much about it. Further, part of the job of your clerkship director and dean's office is to distill the comments down to something digestible that accurately represents the themes present in your clerkship evaluations which are ultimately included on your MSPE. One person saying that you were "quiet" is unlikely to make it into your MSPE, and even if it does, it's unlikely to be harmful to you. All things considered, that's a pretty benign comment.
 
Keep your head up! I would not be surprised that they treat a lot of people this way. Just continue to do your job in the best way you know how, and things are apt to turn out fine.
 
Hey dear,
Same thing has happened to me during my third year clinical rotations. I was sick of going to the clinicals even. Then what i did was I started to stdy things as cases. For an example, I get a history from an asthmatic patient and first study the pathological part and then the mx of asthma. Likewise i could finish most of the common clinical presentations at the end of 3rd yr. I saw a huge improvement and now i love this profession. Work hard. You can do it.
Good luck!
 
Top