Psy.D vs. M.D.

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

aikem

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2012
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
I'm a senior at the University of Michigan and I am about to graduate with a B.S. in "Biopsychology, Cognition, and Neuroscience". I've spent the past summer working on my AMCAS, as well as my secondaries and I'm starting to doubt my career path in to becoming a psychiatrist.

I've spent most of my time in research, about two years, within the social sciences as a research assistant, administering experiments and inputting data. I've also started to work at the university's Department of Psychiatry, where I've been able to learn about treatments and interventions for those with substance use disorders. My position here could POSSIBLY become a full-time paying position in the upcoming Spring, if the study can receive enough funding.

In terms of leadership experience, I am very active within the Asian American community on campus, holding multiple leadership positions and educating others of pertinent Asian-American issues (like not wanting to seek therapy due to cultural pressures). Having done these things has provided me the extra reason of wanting to go in to treating those with mental illnesses.

For academics, I have a 3.3 in my major and 3.4 in sciences. I got a 35 on my MCATs. I am expecting pretty good recommendation letters from a doctor in pediatric cardiology, my physical chemistry professor, and my supervisor at the Department of Psychiatry.

My ultimate goal is to help children and adolescents with anxiety, mood, and eating disorders, especially within the Asian American community. I realize that there are multiple paths to take with this, but if I do not get in to medical school, I won't have a clearly defined path for me to take.

Questions: What chances do I have of making it in to medical school? What paths are there if I don't get in to medical school? Will working as a research assistant for a year help with reapplying to medical school if I don't get in? If my position doesn't receive funding, what could I do to strengthen my application for medical school, while earning money to keep myself afloat?

Sorry this was a long post, but I figured I should put as much info as I can to help find answers for my questions
 
This looks like it would better be posed on the medical board. Just a note about the Psy.D. The debt/income disparagy for Psy.D.'s is probably much higher than that of MD's.
 
MD is a better option than PsyD in pretty much every instance that i can think of other than if you just can't handle going to medical school. a psyd is an easy way to buy a doctorate. not a competitive environment in many cases. debt to income ratios strongly favor the md option. And, with your stats, you can definitely get into medical school. Now, a PhD in clinical psych is another option. the debt to income ratio is better for this option than the psyd option. The income though is highly variable and your mileage may vary. I still think in terms of job availability, money, and easy of career trajectory that the MD option is the best bet. JMHO.
 
a psyd is an easy way to buy a doctorate.

Oh, come on Jon Snow. Really. Have a bias against a PsyD, fine, but don't say this--perhaps it is expensive, perhaps it is easy to get in to *some* PsyD programs, but it's not just an easy purchase of a degree. That's just snobbery.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top