Relative Weight of Stats

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

What is the order of importance?

  • GPA, MCAT, EC's.

    Votes: 15 23.1%
  • MCAT, GPA, EC's.

    Votes: 19 29.2%
  • EC's are the most important, followed by the other two.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • LOR is most important, followed by the other three.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • GPA and MCAT are equally important, followed by everything else.

    Votes: 24 36.9%
  • It depends.

    Votes: 7 10.8%

  • Total voters
    65

Falconclaw

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2013
Messages
260
Reaction score
75
Hey, I have a feeling that this question won't be very popular, but I was wondering how you'd rank the following three things, in terms of importance: MCAT, GPA, EC's, and LOR.

I guess I can make this into a poll too.
 
MCAT
GPA
LOR's
EC's

You can't weigh them against each other really since something like a negative LOR can sink an otherwise outstanding app. Example, at Harvard, my faculty interviewer told me about an applicant that he interviewed with awesome numbers but very troubling letters -- he said with a smirk, "that student will not be here next year".
 
Disclaimer: I'm a rising sophomore in college, so this is hardly an expert opinion.


I would think that the MCAT would be slightly more important than GPA because it is standardized.

I voted MCAT, GPA, and then EC's

Additionally, although the MCAT is a difficult test that demands serious attention, I feel that raising your MCAT score is a bit more straightforward than raising your GPA; at the very least, you could theoretically do it in a matter of months, whereas depending on how bad your GPA is, you might be in serious trouble.
 
MCAT
GPA
LOR's
EC's

You can't weigh them against each other really since something like a negative LOR can sink an otherwise outstanding app. Example, at Harvard, my faculty interviewer told me about an applicant that he interviewed with awesome numbers but very troubling letters -- he said with a smirk, "that student will not be here next year".

Hmmm, I would hope that if I asked someone for a letter, and they didn't have a high opinion of me, they would just refuse to write it, rather than writing a bad one.

In terms of EC's, what if all someone had was a summer of volunteering at a hospital, and say 10 hours of shadowing physicians?
 
This is useful, thanks. I've seen a similar ranking for the match, but I'm not sure how much you can draw from this since they all fall into a very narrow range of the scale.

They do fall into a narrow range, but it's compiled from a lot of adcoms.
At any rate, I found it more intriguing that they care more about sGPA than cGPA. Lucky me!
 
It's okay. Things like "Completion of Pre-Medical Requirements" is placed toward the bottom, when in reality if you don't have that, you'll NEVER get an interview.

Not true...if you haven't completed ANY, sure, no interview. But if you're missing one or two and you can take them before matriculation? You can get in. Quite a few students apply while taking their last prereqs (missing from transcript) and some apply with the intent of taking the last course *at some point* before becoming a med student.

I'm personally going for a GPA repair, so I'm going to try and pack in as many 3-credit courses as I can before applying and then sneak the 2 labs I'm missing in as/after the app is completed.
 
I think it depends. For GPA, MCAT, ECs, LORS, etc, there can be variations. For example, a 3.5 with a strong upward trend (say, 4.0's the last two years) is not the same as a consistent 3.5, or a 3.5 with a downward trend. For MCAT, a 10/10/10 is not the same as a 14/10/6. Within ECs, someone could have consistently volunteered 3-4 hours a week at a free clinic for 4 years and gotten 400 hours of clinical experience, or someone could've volunteered full-time in a busy ED the summer before applying and also gotten 400 hours. And similar arguments can be made for all of the other components of an application. So at the end of the day, you need to convince adcoms that you have the 1. ability and 2. desire/passion to go into medicine. How you choose to do that is up to you, and whether or not your application is convincing is up to them.
 
It's okay. Things like "Completion of Pre-Medical Requirements" is placed toward the bottom, when in reality if you don't have that, you'll NEVER get an interview.

this is just flat out wrong. you only need to complete the requirements before matriculation. they will want to see strong performance in the prereqs that you haven taken up to that point though
 
GPA first because it shows that you can perform at a high academic level over the course of years. Then the MCAT second because it shows that you can study and do well on a standardized test with the added bonus of giving adcoms a method for comparing applicants with different majors at different institutions. LORs come next because people want to know that you are the kind of person that they would send their family to as their doctor. Then ECs to show that you are someone who actually cares about others and can manage to have a life outside of school.
 
Since the AAMC has actually published articles on this topic, I'm not really sure why this thread exists, but I'll bite:

It depends....

  • Schools vary individually (e.g., to WashU MCAT + GPA >>>> everything else; most other schools are far more balanced in their approach; my own Dean of Admissions has stated they give points for uniqueness and outstanding accomplishments -- e.g., being an Olympian -- can make up for a solid 5-7 points on the MCAT)
  • Different criteria are considered or weighted differently at various points in the process

A common scheme would be:

Pre-Secondary -- MCAT/GPA +++, PS/ECs +, LORs +
Pre-Interview -- MCAT/GPA +++, Secondary Essays ++, PS/ECs +, LORs +
Post-Interview -- Interview ++++, Secondary +++, LORS ++, PS/ECs +, MCAT/GPA +/0
 
this is just flat out wrong. you only need to complete the requirements before matriculation. they will want to see strong performance in the prereqs that you haven taken up to that point though

Yeah, this is true, I stand corrected. It's hard to take the MCAT without taking the pre-reqs, though. The only pre-req that I have to take that may not help me with the MCAT is orgo lab.
 
Top