Reputability of public school post-bacs

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Where did you/are you doing your post bacc?

  • private university

    Votes: 1 33.3%
  • public college or uni with graduate programs and research labs

    Votes: 2 66.7%
  • public 4-year college with no research/labs

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • community college

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    3

daivimarga

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2016
Messages
83
Reaction score
42
Question, which I think is typical, regarding the choice of where to do post-bac -

Like many of you, I'm taking my prerequisites at local public institutions. Perhaps my situation might parallel yours in your city/state-

I'm in the NY system and our city has two reputable, established post-bac curricula, one at Hunter, one at City College. Hunter actually has a 95% acceptance rate for its formal program, I recently found out, which is really impressive! However, I've started taking my classes at a less prestigious school (not cc, but city college system) which is a four year college - it's smaller, I've already matriculated, it's not hard to get into classes, and is likely less rigorous than Hunter/City. I was planning to transfer after the summer, because I've been advised that med schools are not going to look fondly upon the school I'm at.

TL;DR: I'm wondering if it is necessary to switch to one of the "better" city schools, because I see a number of non-trads are taking courses at community colleges -- is it really going to have a negative impact if I complete most of my coursework here, at a less reputable school?

considerations:
-med schools in the area, particularly state schools that would offer me lower tuition, might be more familiar with these programs
-I'm the only premed I have met thus far (lots of PA, PT, pharm students)
-no committee letter
-professors are passionate and teach here because they want to give back to the community & they love me because I am actually interested and motivated --> great LORs
-workload/exams and general expectations for performance are very doable. Lots of opportunities for extra credit and I could maintain a 4.0 or close to it. They don't "weed out" students like other schools.
-will have to invest more time & energy studying for MCAT on my own
-no solid support/advisement but the advisors I met at other city colleges are very amenable to offer assistance so can likely take advantage of this when application time comes
-unlike other city colleges, though, they don't have med schools come for fairs/recruitment events or even talks...it's pretty bare bones.
-advisors at other schools might have connections that would prove valuable?

okay- thanks much and hope all are well, safe & healthy 🙂 oh and I made a poll. Because I've never done that.
 
You can always get a committee letter from your alma mater instead.
 
Thanks, yeah I've heard of this, but I don't think my university does this for alums - besides what would those committees say?
 
Thanks, yeah I've heard of this, but I don't think my university does this for alums - besides what would those committees say?
Some schools do letter packages. You can just forward all the recommendation letters you collect to the premed committee and they will generate a letter package committee letter.
Ask your school whether they offer the service to alumni or not.
If you cannot obtain a committee letter from your alma mater, attending a postbacc program that offers one can be helpful.
 
Some schools do letter packages. You can just forward all the recommendation letters you collect to the premed committee and they will generate a letter package committee letter.
Ask your school whether they offer the service to alumni or not.
If you cannot obtain a committee letter from your alma mater, attending a postbacc program that offers one can be helpful.

In New York, his options are NYU or Columbia for formal postbacs. Both of which are going to charge around 100k.

A letter isn't that big of a deal, and isn't going to be worth anywhere near 100k.
 
In New York, his options are NYU or Columbia for formal postbacs. Both of which are going to charge around 100k.

A letter isn't that big of a deal, and isn't going to be worth anywhere near 100k.
He said he is considering two CUNYs that offer formal postbacc programs, Hunter or City College. Both are really cheap.
 
Last edited:
Unless you are gunning for a top ivy league med school like Harvard or some such most med schools don't usually care significantly about the overall reputation of the particular premed school, unless it's really really bad.
 
Top