Requested Critique of Personal Statement

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

granitebaybrad

Junior Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2003
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Since I saw some great comments on a previous thread, I hope to receive similar feedback for my personal statement. Please note any portions of the essay that you think are awkward or grammatically unsound. I have about 5150 characters in this essay.

Thanks


Essay

Columbia's point is well taken. I would rather lose the benefit of forum feedback than risk someone actually taking portions of the essay and claiming authorship. MeoMix, please delete my essay from your post, leaving only the comments since they are helpful. I am quite worried about plagiarism now and hope to see this essay removed ASAP. Thanks to all posters for their comments. They were very helpful and encouraging.
 
I relished opportunities to practice First Aid skills, and as a Boy Scouts, I assisted with many ?trail? bumps and blisters.

Just reading it real quickly, this was the most apparent error I caught. It should be "Boy Scout" (singular).

good luck.
 
Here's some feedback. Take what you like, leave the rest.

In general, there is some very good stuff in here, and some good personal details. You do a good job of explaining the outcome of your experiences and how they have contributed to your career choice.

There are grammatical problems in places, and the writing sounds a little stiff and wordy at times. If that's the way you usually speak, then leave it in there; if not, I have some suggestions. The suggested wording changes are not necessarily the best choices; they just mark places where I think the wording is awkward or incorrect.

Also, "inner-city" is often better described as "urban" or "at-risk" (youth, for example), or with some other more descriptive adjectives.

Good luck!

**This first para is not to my taste; too much of the Courageous Hero theme in the way it's written. I'm sure others will disagree and tell you it's fine, so please disregard if you like it.**

*beware using words such as "counsel" (as a noun) etc. that you would not normally use in everyday speech**

...role models **have been** physicians and health professionals whose example and counsel **have** imprinted
*remove first part, and this sentence doesn't really fit with what comes next...* I have witnessed...

...occupation **, such as** long work hours and grateful patients...
...*j*ournals for clinical photos*, and by* discussing *X*-rays and jaw models prepared for his patient*s'*...
...science*,* with its...
...high*-*school (hyphenate because it is a compound adjective modifying dissection) and college dissections...
...processes that *allow* animals to exist...
**how do we make the jump from high school to research? this is an odd transition and I don't see the connection**
* you don't really finish the theme of dad as role model - need some closure on that*

*now we are back to high school again - need some transition here*
Upon entering...
*did it happen upon entering, or while you worked as a lifeguard*
...empowering*,* and...
...as a Boy *Scout*, I *helped treat* many ?trail? (take out the quotes) bumps...

...backpacking duties *what are backpacking duties? isn't everyone backpacking on these trips?*
...compliance. *this is odd - if you are fostering independence and self-reliance in your scouts, why would you carry a kid's gear? Sounds as if you did it so he wouldn't complain or argue? I'd rework this to make more clear. Also, the next sentence is very wordy and unclear; rewrite in simple language.*

*Does this para go HS-college again (and then back to HS in next para? Once again, the jumping back and forth gets confusing*
...tried to be a constructive distraction...I'd find a more positive way to say this - you weren't just a distraction - you provided a positive, alternative focus for their energies
*how do you help a friend through alcoholism? what are you trying to tell us here?*

*In my opinion, a little too dramatic on the appendix-death connection. You already told us that you thought medicine was meaningful and fascinating; if this was really significant, it belongs earlier, before watching your father.*

* A little too strong on the courageous suffering patient theme. Putting it into more direct, simple language would help reinforce the message that you really care about people instead of viewing them as an observer. What did you learn about what medicine does for someone with ALS? How did you deal with the awareness of those limitations? How do you feel when you cannot aid in someone's recovery?*
...woman to *the radiology department*, I marveled *at* how she maintained her sense of humor *even though she was facing * months of chemotherapy.
...who shared *my* goals and expectations*for what?*.

*I'd rewrite this para to tie together your essay. For example, first sentence sounds too dispassionate, like an observer. You want to understand, but you don't say you want to address or help or make things better. Also, I'd suggest removing the word "noble" and never allowing it back in to your essay.
 
who would be so dumb as to post their PS on here???????
 
Great PS. I really agree with some of the critique of Meowmix. Also, I do like use of the words "wane" and quench" in your first paragraph. People tend not to use enough visceral verbs in their PS's, and generally use trite/cliche phrases like, "challenged", "impassioned with very noble goals", "augmented my desire to become" and "broadened my perspective".

Don't say it, show it. Give some specific, concrete, corporeal examples of interactions you've had with patients/people, and let us conclude how "this has augmented your desire to become a caring physician etc.". Make it personal.

just as an example, here is a great (modestly said 😉 ) essay:


----------
As I drove to Doernbecher, I wondered what kind of evening I would have.

If I've learned anything in three years of volunteering, it's that the evening would be totally unpredictable ? which is the sort of challenge I love. I might spend time playing, doing art or craft projects, playing video games, reading, playing cards or chess, holding an infant, comforting a child in pain, listening to a frightened parent, or any or all of the above. You have to be on your toes and ready for dozens of possible needs ? also what I love. I wondered, too, if any of the kids or families I?ve come to know as a volunteer might be there and how they were coping.

?10-North,? where I volunteer, is also called ?Hem-Onc,? short for Hematology-Oncology, which means it?s a floor for kids with various kinds of leukemia or cancer. Visibly to me, the kids? health seems to range from perfectly healthy to very ill. Some are in for routine chemo, some actively battling the disease or drug side effects, and, unfortunately, a few receiving comfort care.

I usually start my shift by quickly cruising the floor to see how many of the sixteen rooms are occupied, who has family or friends with them, who?s sleeping, etc. As I rounded the corner I was spotted by little Natalie who came running to me with a big smile, and arms outstretched. Natalie and I had spent many hours together playing and riding bikes. Natalie is three years old and stays in the hospital with her Mom and Dad when little brother Isaac is an inpatient. After a big hug, Natalie and I went to the playroom to paint with watercolors. Several other patients and siblings wandered in and soon there were six of us painting. It can get a little interesting when they all want help and attention but the chaos is enjoyable. As paintings are declared ?done? they are quickly taken to show Mom. After fifteen minutes, only Natalie and I are left so ?we? decide to ride bikes around the floor. Usually we race, she pedaling and me walking fast.After a bit, I escort Natalie back to her mother?s care and I start visiting patient rooms.

Pancho is in for his last chemo treatment. He?s eight years old and he?s been learning to play chess over his last four or five stays at the hospital. We play two games. Pancho is a bundle of concentration as he ponders his moves. He sings, whistles, and fidgets when I?m pondering my moves. Strategy. I win both games. Kids can tell if you give them the game so I never do. I leave Pancho with congratulations on the last chemo treatment and a smiling directive that as much as I like him, I don?t want to see him back there again.

I visit a room full of new faces. Derek is in bed watching TV. Mom and Dad look like the deer caught in headlights. Derek was diagnosed with leukemia yesterday and they rushed to Doernbecher this morning. I can only imagine the fear a parent must go through when their child is diagnosed with an often-fatal disease. Derek doesn?t feel good, is uncomfortable with his new IV, and is a bit overwhelmed by the stream of doctors, nurses, and other staff people coming in to see him. One of a volunteer?s jobs is to be a warm and friendly face and a positive distraction from all the "hubbub." I quickly find out Derek likes trucks and get some from the playroom for him. Soon we?re making truck noises and crashing on the bed. Mom?s on the phone calling friends and relatives and appreciates me being there. She said so. I make fresh coffee and get a cup for Dad.

As I leave the room, a nurse asks if I can sit with Zack while his Mom takes a break. Zack is three months old and this is his third stay. He starts fussing two minutes after Mom leaves, which means I get to hold him. One of life?s most underrated pleasures is holding a little baby.

Several more room visits. Movies for Aaron, cup of Sprite for Jaylen, coffee for grandpa. Time to say goodnight to the nurses, drive home, and think about the evening.

Oh, I forgot to mention it before but when I arrived and signed into the computer, there was a message that an old friend, a twelve-year-old girl, died peacefully at home surrounded by family. We did a lot of art together. And once when she was really sick, I held her hand and read to her. I feel really sad thinking about her.

Sometimes my friends ask how I can volunteer like this and say that it must be really depressing. It can certainly be sad but never depressing. I can look back on all the kids I?ve spent time with, the parents I?ve talked with, the nurses I?ve helped. I know I?ve made a difference. The vast majority of my stories are happy. There are a few sad ones. All of them are tremendously rewarding.
----------

Now, see what I mean by, make it personal? Do it! 😀
 
I have a question for you essay experts...


Over the past five or so years, I've worked a lot (work-study and summer jobs) with children, and this has served as a focal point (if you will) of my interest in medicine. In other words, I can explain everything that draws me into medicine in terms of anecdotes from these jobs and from my own childhood.
But I don't want to come accross as being decided on pediatrics, since I may want to pursue other areas instead.

Is it a bad idea to use almost all examples dealing with my experience with children in support of my interest in ALL of medicine? Or should I sacrifice (a little bit of) quality for variety?

I feel pretty comfortable with what I have so far and may just roll with it, but would really like some opinions or suggestions on the matter.

Thanks
 
Originally posted by granitebaybrad
Since I saw some great comments on a previous thread, I hope to receive similar feedback for my personal statement. Please note any portions of the essay that you think are awkward or grammatically unsound. I have about 5150 characters in this essay.

Thanks


Essay

Columbia's point is well taken. I would rather lose the benefit of forum feedback than risk someone actually taking portions of the essay and claiming authorship. MeoMix, please delete my essay from your post, leaving only the comments since they are helpful. I am quite worried about plagiarism now and hope to see this essay removed ASAP. Thanks to all posters for their comments. They were very helpful and encouraging.

Umm, delete the stupid thread if you don't want people to read it. And to believe that before reading this thread I thought ******s didn't know how to post messages!
 
Imperator,

This thread was created for me, since people are only commenting on my essay. If I still find the thread useful, then that is reason enough to not delete it. As I stated in the first, now edited post, some people provided good advice that I plan to follow that would be lost by deleting the entire thread. Thus, the thread will not be deleted, and I hope no one else posts here so it may pass from the front page.
 
Top