Rest and Digest?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

NYYk9005

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2010
Messages
114
Reaction score
3
I keep hearing 'rest and digest' from science and pre-med classes...
Yet, I also hear that walking or even a run helps you digest from common people talk...

Which is right?
 
from what i know (what my cross country coaches have told me in high school) running on a full stomach, or in my case running with any amount of food will cause stomach distress and cramps. From this i could deduce that it doesn't help in digestion, but that it is simply an 'aposteriori' with no empirical evidence.

so i am not sure.
 
I have no idea what your question is. Are you talking about digestion of "people talk" or food?
 
I keep hearing 'rest and digest' from science and pre-med classes...
Yet, I also hear that walking or even a run helps you digest from common people talk...

Which is right?

Rest and digest is thrown around as the opposite of fight or flight. The latter is governed by the sympathetic nervous system, the former is governed by the parasympathetic.
 
The Sympathetic Nervous System (SNS) and Parasympathetic Nervous System (PSNS) are both part of the autonomic nervous system. Their functions are opposites of each other. Basically, SNS activates systems that you'll need if you ever need to run away from a bear (muscle, bronchodilation, pupillary dilation, increase HR, etc) and shuts down PSNS systems. PSNS activates systems that are primarily associated when you're eating and not doing anything (increase GI motility, secretion, pupillarry constriction, etc) and shuts down SNS.

So, now that's been established you should see why after you eat (PSNS) and then you run (SNS) you're going to shut down the GI and food ends up just sitting in your stomach. Essentially you end up getting cramps as stomach wants to digest but lacks adequate blood flow to do it as most being shunted to active muscles.

Just going by the physiology, you shouldn't run after you eat but walking should be fine. I mean how can you function if you have to do nothing for an hour or so after every meal? Highly inefficient.
 
you do realize we're not doctors?

The Sympathetic Nervous System (SNS) and Parasympathetic Nervous System (PSNS) are both part of the autonomic nervous system. Their functions are opposites of each other. Basically, SNS activates systems that you'll need if you ever need to run away from a bear (muscle, bronchodilation, pupillary dilation, increase HR, etc) and shuts down PSNS systems. PSNS activates systems that are primarily associated when you're eating and not doing anything (increase GI motility, secretion, pupillarry constriction, etc) and shuts down SNS.

So, now that's been established you should see why after you eat (PSNS) and then you run (SNS) you're going to shut down the GI and food ends up just sitting in your stomach. Essentially you end up getting cramps as stomach wants to digest but lacks adequate blood flow to do it as most being shunted to active muscles.

Just going by the physiology, you shouldn't run after you eat but walking should be fine. I mean how can you function if you have to do nothing for an hour or so after every meal? Highly inefficient.


But apperantly some of us know just as much as doctors! :laugh:
 
Bedrest=constipation. Everytime.

The single best thing to get my patients to poop (which many had to do before they could go home) was to walk.

That said, when you eat a big fat meal (you know, the kind where you gotta loosen your belt) the last thing you want to do is go run a few laps.

If I had to make an educated guess, I would say that when you first eat, it would be beneficial to let your stomach do its thing unhindered (rest) but once bowel movements (peristalsis) especially in the lower bowel kicks in, moving around usually helps.
 
I work out bout 30 mins after i eat ha... for track stuff though never ever ever on a full stomach...
 
"Rest and digest" is not advice. The phrase does not mean that you should rest so that you can digest food.

It is just a phrase that says what the PNS does. The PNS is active in/in charge of resting and digesting.
 
I try to think prehistoric.
If I'm gathering/eating plants, I'm picking, eating, and walking. Therefore, eat plants before/while working out.

If I'm hunting/eating meat, I am probably going to be working pretty hard on an empty stomach, killing my fat/protein, carrying it home, then sitting down and eating with my buddies. Maybe I'll even share some with a lady and get a little something. Good thing my parasympathetics are in high gear for that too!
 
Top