I know very little about Fordham, but I have friends who've went to Rutgers and have heard mixed things about the school:
Obviously its a large state university with a great deal of resources, and many of the professors are actively involved in research. Whether or not you'll have an easy time working in one of their labs as an undergrad I don't know (research experience is very important for any kind of PhD).
I've also heard, from many sources, that while you're generally going to get a good education the university's policies and bureaucracy are very inefficient and infuriating for students:
-Class sizes get very large
-The campus is difficult to navigate, and if you live on campus you'll still be taking a bus most places (forget trying to park)
-Registration for classes is a major pain