SCO, Midwestern, NOVA; Clinical Experience?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Should I care about the Clinical Experience I will get from school, or the Externship site more?

  • They are both equally important.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Neither are as important as you make them out to be.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    4
  • Poll closed .

JosephDaniel82

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2014
Messages
13
Reaction score
0
I am faced with the daunting task of trying to choose the Optometry that is perfect for me and my desire to become an excellent clinician of Optometry. Feel free to add your own input or advice.


I just wanted to start by saying the things I am looking for in an Optometry school are: Clinical Experience, Cost, Safety (at the school and in the city in which I will be living), availability of externship sites, and lastly fun outdoor nature activities to do!

With that being said, I was accepted into Midwestern and SCO, while still awaiting an interview at NOVA on the 19th of December.

My heart tells me to go to SCO, it seems like the best clinical experience around because their students see so many patients, many with diabetes or ARMD etc. Also, Memphis is a really cheap area to live in. Of course it can never be that easy though - my brain is telling me to stray away from Memphis. I know for a fact Memphis has got a good heart to it with genuinely polite people, but to be brutally honest I did not feel safe at the school! It was like a mugging waiting to happen outside of those doors, good thing they've got a security guard at the school. Still though, that leaves me to wonder about things like: would I feel comfortable if my girlfriend went out in Memphis by herself - things of that nature. Great school, great clinic all around, but yikes I don't know about living in Memphis!

Arizona seems really nice. Although they are a newer school, I was really impressed with their clinic and campus in general. After speaking to a few of their students however, I am not so convinced. The students told me (both 3rd years) that they are sometimes "unhappy with patient encounters". They said that (sometimes) they feel like they do not get to see enough patients per week. In other words, these students felt like the school hadn't been giving them the proper patient numbers (with and or without disease) that they had wished to see. Scary because they are a newer school, might not provide as enhanced of a clinical setting when compared to SCO -who has been around for decades and everybody in Memphis knows about the Eye Center.

Florida is still undecided on my end. I haven't been to the interview yet and I only can go by what I have heard from other people. I have heard that it is a great school by some, while I have heard otherwise from some too. A few students at SCO have told me that their 4th year friends had externships with some NOVA students, and the NOVA students were really underprepared when it came to clinical skills. They said it seemed like everyday SCO students were training the NOVA students on what to do and how to do it. I have even heard that NOVA was unaccredited just a few years back - which really scares me! The thought of investing all that money and not even being clinically adept seems....like a waste of time to me. But then again, these were SCO students talking about NOVA students - could be a little rivalry going on here.


I basically told all of the information above to my mentor Optometrist. She told me to not worry about the clinical side as much, because thats what the externship sites are for. She said that no matter what I'd be a good doctor wherever I chose to go, and that the most important things were cost, and whether or not they have good externship sites to further your understanding in a real-world setting. Does everyone else agree with her, or do you guys think that you should really put an emphasis on the school who will train you the best clinically?

Members don't see this ad.
 
I just had an interview at NOVA the other day and I absolutely loved their clinic and everything about the school! I have heard both bad and good things about NOVA as well but all of the equipment is top notch and I think that there is a lot of patients with diseases that come in. I spoke with first and third years and everyone seemed very happy with their decision to go to NOVA. I think that you should wait until your interview to see what your experience there is though!

Also,
SCO has told me that I should be on the lookout for an interview invitation this week and I have still not received one but I am definitely thinking of SCO as one of my top choices (if given the choice) but did you really feel that unsafe even on campus?
 
I just had an interview at NOVA the other day and I absolutely loved their clinic and everything about the school! I have heard both bad and good things about NOVA as well but all of the equipment is top notch and I think that there is a lot of patients with diseases that come in. I spoke with first and third years and everyone seemed very happy with their decision to go to NOVA. I think that you should wait until your interview to see what your experience there is though!

Also,
SCO has told me that I should be on the lookout for an interview invitation this week and I have still not received one but I am definitely thinking of SCO as one of my top choices (if given the choice) but did you really feel that unsafe even on campus?
From a girl's perspective, it definitely didn't seem like the safest place to be. It seemed like you would need to go everywhere in a group, which I didn't like. The safety was the main reason I took SCO off my list of possible schools after interviewing there.
 
Last edited:
Members don't see this ad :)
I've lived in Memphis for 15 years and I'm a 25yo female. My thoughts are this: not many women will want to walk around Memphis by themselves, and although I've lived in the suburbs for these 16 years, I've been downtown and in midtown often and don't feel comfortable walking around by myself. But, there's never been a time when I've needed/wanted to. Rarely does someone walk around downtown alone, except walking to a parking garage or so. I'm hoping to go to SCO, and I'm not too concerned. There's a not-so-great part of town almost everywhere you go. There's some great housing options in the Harbor Town area, as well as some really neat houses in the Midtown area. At SCO, you're rarely walking around outside, and much of the housing is in great parts of town. I encourage you to look into the Cooper-Young area (Midtown). I have many friends living there and there's a lot of REALLY great restaurants within walking distance (good part of town), and they're very affordable. The clinical experience at SCO seems, to me, to be one of THE best. One of my favorite things about SCO and memphis, is the amount of community outreach they do. The community in some areas really does need help, and SCO really does reach out to help. I admire the school for what they do outside of the school. And yes, you will see a lot of diabetes and other disease. Just wanted to encourage you to not pass it up!
 
Okay great!!!! Yeah there's a bad part of every place so I am trying to get that out of my head. I'm originally from new york and I just want change so bad. And memphis is a good school I hope to go interview there soon
 
Top