Should I consider doing an SMP?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Topizungochico

Full Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2019
Messages
28
Reaction score
10
Points
871
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
stats :

27 yo M ORM
  1. GPA: 3.34 cGPA, 3.16 sGPA total, 3.28/3.02 in undergrad; 4.0 over 20 credits in DIY postbacc at local Uni
  2. MCAT: 518 taken 4/26/25
  3. US resident in Minnesota
  4. Ethnicity: South Asian
  5. Undergrad institution: University of Minnesota
  6. Clinical experience:
    1. Scribed with ScribeAmerica in an outpatient oncology clinic 30-32 hrs/week for 6 months 2019- Jan 2020, about 500 hours
    2. Scribed in an orthopedic urgent care full time from Feb 2020 - Sept of 2021, with a brief monthlong furlough due to COVID 19, roughly 1300hours
    3. Worked part time in the same role when I came back to school for September 2021- May-2022 (6-8 hours a week, roughly 200 hours)
    4. Since (June 2022 - Today) have worked full time as a clinical assistant in a different, busier orthopedic urgent care. Very hands on with tons of patient and provider interaction. Learned to cast, splint, do lots of DME fittings, take care of post-surgical wounds/sutures/stitches with guidance from surgical team, etc. Still working here and absolutely love working with patients every day and learning day by day. Roughly 4500+ hours.
    5. Summary: Around 2300 hours scribing, 4500 working hands on with patients as a clinical assistant in urgent care since 2019. Total 7000 hours.
  7. Research experience and productivity
    1. Worked wet lab, processing infant stool samples for a study on the infant microbiome in 2017, about 40 hours.
    2. Was able to work my way up to helping with computational analyses on this study in 2018. Became proficient in using R and Python and helped with data processing and several key visualizations for a published manuscript in Cell. Was able to gain authorship on this publication (only pub). Roughly 150-160 hours
    3. When I returned to school in 2021, I helped a new postdoc to the lab with their research, primarily working with raw data processing and statistical testing between groups. Did not gain a publication for my work here, but learned quite a bit of hands on information relating to data analysis in R and python. About 120 hours here.
    4. Net 300-320 hours, 1 publication, LOR from lab PI
  8. Shadowing experience and specialties represented
    1. Primary care: 10 hours
    2. Primary care, sports medicine: 24 hours
    3. Orthopedic surgery: 10 hours
    4. Neurosurgery: 12 hours
    5. Net 56 hours shadowing
  9. Non-clinical volunteering
    1. ESL tutor for adults in 2017: about 35 hours
    2. Reading partner for elementary aged students struggling with reading, 2022-2025, about 110 hours
    3. Tax volunteer (decided to try something very different hahah— learned to help those under the poverty line do taxes for free with an IRS certified organization): 60 hours, 2023-2024
    4. Free furniture delivery volunteer, 2023 - 2025, about 40 hours.
    5. Volunteering at a local shelter, 2026, about 30 hours.
  10. Leadership: Served on the School of Biological Science’s student board from 2017-2019. Helped advocate for student concerns in the college, and I primarily focused on working with the college to make accessibility to food pantries easier especially during stressful times in the semester. I also served as the student senator for the college of biological sciences in 2018, and continued work on dealing with food insecurity within our college/accessibility to food resources among other projects during my time. Was a part of the student government for 2 years as well.
  11. Teaching: served as a teaching assistant for the introduction to computational biology lab for 3 semesters. Currently working as a volunteer Microbiology TA at the university I did my DIY postbacc at.
I applied this last cycle, still waiting back to hear from 2 schools but other than that have received rejections. Wasn’t the most strategic with the cycle though as I lacked science faculty LORs since I’d been out of school for so long (have some lined up for this coming cycle though due to my postbacc)

Do you think there’s benefit to me doing an SMP? I’m worried that my SGPA is too low to be really considered for MD schools without one. I’m considering a couple of SMPs with interview linkage. I feel that I’m ready for that challenge and would be entering as a completely different student than the one in undergrad, as my study habits and approach to life in general have changed a lot. Im also open to DO schools so I will add this as well but prefer MD schools. Thoughts on an SMP? I’ll obviously might be applying this coming cycle as is but wondering if I should start one in anticipation of if this cycle doesn’t work
 
Last edited:
Previously

I applied this last cycle, still waiting back to hear from 2 schools but other than that have received rejections.

Did you get interviews?
 
Previously



Did you get interviews?
No unfortunately
 
Does Minnesota offer advice to reapplicants? Have you talked with any postbac program directors?
Minnesota unfortunately does not. I’ve talked to the advisor at my DIY and they seem to think I have a good shot this coming cycle with my 20 credits of 4.0 this past year, but if I don’t get in this cycle I want to be able to set up to move forward academically for the one after, which I have a feeling requires continued reinvention throughout the rest of the coming year

I suppose I don’t mind doing on some debt with the SMP since I have very little from UG thankfully. But at the same time, I know it’s a risky decision. All I know is that I can give it my best, but don’t know still if it’s the best move going forward. The two I’m heavily considering are UCinci (good interview linkage, cheaper cost) and U Vermont (interview linkage, low-mid cost, have family in /like the area)
 
Last edited:
@Goro @Faha pinging yall because I’ve read some of your other advice on the matter, but still feel so lost! My other option I was considering was to maybe keep taking a few DIY classes, another 10-20 credits, and then working as an EMT to pay the bills, while stacking more volunteering. Could get closer to a 3.3 sgpa that way. I’m just lost and don’t know what option is best
 
@Goro @Faha pinging yall because I’ve read some of your other advice on the matter, but still feel so lost! My other option I was considering was to maybe keep taking a few DIY classes, another 10-20 credits, and then working as an EMT to pay the bills, while stacking more volunteering. Could get closer to a 3.3 sgpa that way. I’m just lost and don’t know what option is best
I suggest taking another 10 credits or so. No need for an SMP.

And you will need DO schools on your list next cycle. Beggars can't be choosy.
 
I suggest taking another 10 credits or so. No need for an SMP.

And you will need DO schools on your list next cycle. Beggars can't be choosy.
Thanks for the advice! Would you advise holding off on applying this coming cycle then, until I can get 10 more credits?
 
What would be different by applying in this upcoming cycle????
It would reflect an added 20 credits of As from my DIY and a wider potential school list since I now have science faculty willing to write strong letters/access to a committee letter
 
Last edited:
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
It would reflect an added 20 credits of As from my DIY and a wider potential school list since I now have science faculty willing to write strong letters/access to a committee letter
An added 20 credits to The Numbers you posted above? Or do you only have 20 credits of post back hours?
 
An added 20 credits to The Numbers you posted above? Or do you only have 20 credits of post back hours?
Very sorry I left out some context, i actually dropped out of UG back in 2019 after fall of my senior year. 2021-2022 I came back to finish my degree, took 27 credits, and got a 3.68 GPA, so my UG education over last 27 credits have an upward trend.

Now, I’m 20 credits into a DIY postbacc at another small local university and my advisor at this university advised me to apply since I was able to get a 4.0 in those credits as well. Apologies for the confusion.

So now, I’m unclear on if I should apply this coming cycle, or continue taking postbacc courses or even an SMP. What complicates matters is that one of the SMPs I got into with a guaranteed interview (with 510 MCAT and 3.6 in program) has a summer start, so it would be the last time such a program would offer protected grad plus loans for the entire Cost of Attendance (in wake of the big “beautiful” bill). But I’m not sure if I need to do all that or if I should apply, or take an additional 10 credits like you said earlier
 
Very sorry I left out some context, i actually dropped out of UG back in 2019 after fall of my senior year. 2021-2022 I came back to finish my degree, took 27 credits, and got a 3.68 GPA, so my UG education over last 27 credits have an upward trend.

Now, I’m 20 credits into a DIY postbacc at another small local university and my advisor at this university advised me to apply since I was able to get a 4.0 in those credits as well. Apologies for the confusion.

So now, I’m unclear on if I should apply this coming cycle, or continue taking postbacc courses or even an SMP. What complicates matters is that one of the SMPs I got into with a guaranteed interview (with 510 MCAT and 3.6 in program) has a summer start, so it would be the last time such a program would offer protected grad plus loans for the entire Cost of Attendance (in wake of the big “beautiful” bill). But I’m not sure if I need to do all that or if I should apply, or take an additional 10 credits like you said earlier
In this case, I don't think that you need the SMP, and are OK to apply again.

Continue to engage in aiding people who are less fortunate than you. No more tutoring, though.
Many of the schools on my list are service-loving

You will need a strategic list, so here you go:
U MN
Columbia (maybe)
Vanderbilt (maybe)
Hofstra
Netter
Tufts
BU
Gtown
Loyola
UCSF
Rosy Franklin
NovaMD
TCU
Wayne State
Oakland B
U Cincy
Drexel
Albany
Jefferson
EVMS
Wake
U Miami
Western MI
Roseman
Belmont (reported to have financial issues)
Any DO program. Start list with CCOM (but watch tuition), MSUCOM, DMU and MUCOM.
I can't recommend LMU, SOMA, RVU, BCOM, ICOM and LUCOM, for different reasons. Avoid those new schools that haven't graduated a class yet, if at all possible.
 
In this case, I don't think that you need the SMP, and are OK to apply again.

Continue to engage in aiding people who are less fortunate than you. No more tutoring, though.
Many of the schools on my list are service-loving

You will need a strategic list, so here you go:
U MN
Columbia (maybe)
Vanderbilt (maybe)
Hofstra
Netter
Tufts
BU
Gtown
Loyola
UCSF
Rosy Franklin
NovaMD
TCU
Wayne State
Oakland B
U Cincy
Drexel
Albany
Jefferson
EVMS
Wake
U Miami
Western MI
Roseman
Belmont (reported to have financial issues)
Any DO program. Start list with CCOM (but watch tuition), MSUCOM, DMU and MUCOM.
I can't recommend LMU, SOMA, RVU, BCOM, ICOM and LUCOM, for different reasons. Avoid those new schools that haven't graduated a class yet, if at all possible.
Thank you so much!!
 
In this case, I don't think that you need the SMP, and are OK to apply again.

Continue to engage in aiding people who are less fortunate than you. No more tutoring, though.
Many of the schools on my list are service-loving

You will need a strategic list, so here you go:
U MN
Columbia (maybe)
Vanderbilt (maybe)
Hofstra
Netter
Tufts
BU
Gtown
Loyola
UCSF
Rosy Franklin
NovaMD
TCU
Wayne State
Oakland B
U Cincy
Drexel
Albany
Jefferson
EVMS
Wake
U Miami
Western MI
Roseman
Belmont (reported to have financial issues)
Any DO program. Start list with CCOM (but watch tuition), MSUCOM, DMU and MUCOM.
I can't recommend LMU, SOMA, RVU, BCOM, ICOM and LUCOM, for different reasons. Avoid those new schools that haven't graduated a class yet, if at all possible.
One last question for you, do you think when I apply I should find a way to emphasize the upward trend in my undergrad? Since my senior year was discontinuous due to my drop out, it’s average on AMCAS appears as a 3.3 even though my last 27 credits are at 3.68. Would it be worth trying to communicate that in my applications, from your perspective? Thanks so much again for your time, I so truly appreciate your help <3
 
One last question for you, do you think when I apply I should find a way to emphasize the upward trend in my undergrad? Since my senior year was discontinuous due to my drop out, it’s average on AMCAS appears as a 3.3 even though my last 27 credits are at 3.68. Would it be worth trying to communicate that in my applications, from your perspective? Thanks so much again for your time, I so truly appreciate your help <3
Did you ask the schools on your list? Many secondary applications give you a chance to explain any context with your academic preparation.
 
One last question for you, do you think when I apply I should find a way to emphasize the upward trend in my undergrad? Since my senior year was discontinuous due to my drop out, it’s average on AMCAS appears as a 3.3 even though my last 27 credits are at 3.68. Would it be worth trying to communicate that in my applications, from your perspective? Thanks so much again for your time, I so truly appreciate your help <3
It's worth a sentence, and nothing more in your personal statement about how the you of now is not the U of then.
 
Top Bottom