Smartphone Vs. Tablet for Residency

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

socrtees7

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2011
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
I was hoping to get some current residents' opinions on which would be more useful during residency, a smartphone or a tablet? I will be starting my intern year in IM soon and am one of the many people still in the "dark ages" who don't own either one of these two gadgets. For graduation my entire family has pitched in and said I could get either one (obviously I'll be paying for the phone's data package after a few months, but they'll help for a while).

My main issue is that I have an ipod that connects via wifi at my hospital, so I really don't need the phone to connect to the internet while at work. Also, my hospital uses Epic, which can be placed onto a tablet, so I would never need to find a computer to put in orders, etc. However, so many people I've talked to say that their smartphones are invaluable.

That's probably too much information for most of you, so I'd just love to hear your opinions. Thanks!
 
I was hoping to get some current residents' opinions on which would be more useful during residency, a smartphone or a tablet? I will be starting my intern year in IM soon and am one of the many people still in the "dark ages" who don't own either one of these two gadgets. For graduation my entire family has pitched in and said I could get either one (obviously I'll be paying for the phone's data package after a few months, but they'll help for a while).

My main issue is that I have an ipod that connects via wifi at my hospital, so I really don't need the phone to connect to the internet while at work. Also, my hospital uses Epic, which can be placed onto a tablet, so I would never need to find a computer to put in orders, etc. However, so many people I've talked to say that their smartphones are invaluable.

That's probably too much information for most of you, so I'd just love to hear your opinions. Thanks!


Problem with the iPad on the wards is you can't fit it in your pocket, which means it's going to walk off eventually, as soon as you leave it outside of a contact precaution room etc. Go with The smartphone for work. For home, library, coffee shop, the iPad is great.
 
Problem with the iPad on the wards is you can't fit it in your pocket, which means it's going to walk off eventually, as soon as you leave it outside of a contact precaution room etc. Go with The smartphone for work. For home, library, coffee shop, the iPad is great.

We are forced to use an iPad and it is a huge pain-in-the-ass, for the reasons above. It's annoying to constantly be looking for a place to put it down, and then worrying about it walking off. It's isn't any more convenient than the computers on the floor, anyway. It's also not mine, so I'm paranoid about it getting lost or injured. I'd go with a smartphone. (I'll save the Apple vs Droid argument for another thread. 😉 )
 
Just got an iPad earlier.

This thing is so freaking overrated. Get Flash already, Steve Jobs probably won't care.

Let's see if this is going to increase my reading productivity. Will update in a couple weeks

Oh, iPhones are a must, fun and convenient
 
I was hoping to get some current residents' opinions on which would be more useful during residency, a smartphone or a tablet? I will be starting my intern year in IM soon and am one of the many people still in the "dark ages" who don't own either one of these two gadgets. For graduation my entire family has pitched in and said I could get either one (obviously I'll be paying for the phone's data package after a few months, but they'll help for a while).

My main issue is that I have an ipod that connects via wifi at my hospital, so I really don't need the phone to connect to the internet while at work. Also, my hospital uses Epic, which can be placed onto a tablet, so I would never need to find a computer to put in orders, etc. However, so many people I've talked to say that their smartphones are invaluable.

That's probably too much information for most of you, so I'd just love to hear your opinions. Thanks!

Get the phone, for the reasons given by the other posters above.

My $0.02 to add - save your phone bills... they are deductible on your taxes as a business/residency expense. You need the data package to access stuff online, and if you take home call, presto!

Might not do much for your taxes now, but every dollar counts when trying to keep Uncle Sam outta your pocket.

-d

Sent from my DROID BIONIC using Tapatalk
 
Just got an iPad earlier.

This thing is so freaking overrated. Get Flash already, Steve Jobs probably won't care.

Let's see if this is going to increase my reading productivity. Will update in a couple weeks

Oh, iPhones are a must, fun and convenient

I don't think it's overrated, it's awesome. However it's not something I would carry on the wards.
 
Just got an iPad earlier.

This thing is so freaking overrated. Get Flash already, Steve Jobs probably won't care.

Let's see if this is going to increase my reading productivity. Will update in a couple weeks

Oh, iPhones are a must, fun and convenient

I don't think Steve Jobs is making many decisions at apple nowadays.....
And yeah get an iphone. iPads are really big with clinical pharmacists because they never *have* to go into the patient's room at a moment's notice the way an intern does. Your iphone can be nice and happy in your pocket, under your gown, not getting covered with c diff spores.
 
Thanks so much for everyone's input! Sounds like the phone will be the way to go. I really appreciate it!
 
Yep, iPhone. I use PEPID and Epocrates non stop during just about every shift. I'm surprised I haven't gouged thumb prints in the glass by now. Lots of medical apps and iPhone interface vastly easier and faster to use than anything else on a day to day basis.
 
Thanks so much for everyone's input! Sounds like the phone will be the way to go. I really appreciate it!
I'll be the one naysayer. I rotated at a hospital that used Epic, and a few attendings and residents had iPads with the Epic app. It seemed INCREDIBLY useful. They were pulling up labs, vitals, x-rays and everything else as we walked around and did rounds. They aren't that big, and the little covers that flip over the top make them seem pretty durable.

Until you mentioned you had Epic, I would have said to use the smartphone, but if you can access Epic via the iPad, I'd get that.
 
I'll be the one naysayer. I rotated at a hospital that used Epic, and a few attendings and residents had iPads with the Epic app. It seemed INCREDIBLY useful. They were pulling up labs, vitals, x-rays and everything else as we walked around and did rounds. They aren't that big, and the little covers that flip over the top make them seem pretty durable.

Until you mentioned you had Epic, I would have said to use the smartphone, but if you can access Epic via the iPad, I'd get that.

This was my thought too, except for the whole "having to ditch your iPad at the door while you go into an isolation room" thing. Epic makes a phone app called "Haiku" that can be used to look up anything in Epic. You can't use it to write notes or put in orders, but for quick access to a lab result or VS, it works great.

If the hospital is providing the iPad, go nuts. If not, just rock the smartphone (I'll leave the iPhone/Android debate for others).
 
Speaking of EPIC; one of the hospitals I have privileges at is going from paper charting to EPIC.

Physicians have to do something like a ridiculous 15 hours of training. Is it really that difficult or are they assuming we are a bunch of drooling idiots who've never used an EMR before?
 
When we converted to EPIC in residency, they tried to get residents an 8 hour day of training. After 3 hours, we (meaning the surgery residents who had mostly been surfing the internet while they bored us enough to e-page each other out of the session) left. On conversion, we figured it out (and were able to ask EPIC people floating around about the stuff we couldnt figure out intuitively). Often times, another surgery resident could figure it out before the designated people could figure out what we were asking. There are quirks, but odds are, you're not going to remember those until you've used the system for real. This was in-patient only, so I can't speak for outpatient EPIC.

My current hospital is preparing for a conversion to a different system. In general, they seem to assume we can't figure anything out on our own. I'm sure there are some people who can't figure out the basics; but they really do assume a pretty low-level of ability compared to what most people are able to do, IMO. If you are completely comfortable with a computer, they will probably teach "below" your level.

Yes, they will assume you've never used an EMR before.
 
Speaking of EPIC; one of the hospitals I have privileges at is going from paper charting to EPIC.

Physicians have to do something like a ridiculous 15 hours of training. Is it really that difficult or are they assuming we are a bunch of drooling idiots who've never used an EMR before?

It is not that complicated, but if that hospital is full of ancient docs who get the nurses to look up lab results in the current computer system, prepare for a painful experience. The training tends to be geared to the lowest common denominator.

I think our training was 10 or 12 hours (at least on paper). 5 or 6 hours a day on two days. One day for inpatient, one for outpatient.

We then had a 3rd day of training in my fellowship to learn how to use the chemo ordering system which was a new thing they built specifically for our hospital. That was even easier than the first two sessions, however they put everybody in the same class...nurses, pharmacists and physicians. It took about 45 minutes to learn how to order chemo and to write your own chemo protocol and 4 hours to teach the nurses how to document that they gave the chemo. That was more painful that 2 full days of the regular training.
 
Most places customize Epic a bit, so it's going to be worth your while to at least learn some of the big quirks. Otherwise no, it's not that hard. It does take some time getting used to, but the teaching sessions probably won't help.
 
We had a hospital just convert to epic May 1. It was painful. The training was horrible. specialists were telling their patients not to go to the hospital because they didn't want to deal with epic, and now an entire cardiology group has pulled out of the hospital. It gets better: they didn't even give some of the staff a username/password the day it went live (including the entire academic team admitting that day on a no-doc day!) And last night it went down for 3 hours. Awesome.

I haven't been at the hospital since EPIC went live there ... I start cross-covering tonight. Heaven help me.

But OP, I would go with smartphone first. Ipad has been very very nice to get into systems at home, look up stuff on rounds, etc., but smartphone is much easier to handle day to day.
 
We use Cerner and there's an iPad app for that too, but the hopsitals that use it are also very well stocked with compters and there is almost always a CoW (compter on wheels) to make the med stdent drag around with us. As far as training, we had something obscene too like 10 hours of online video training with online tests like making a patient list with the software. Not exactly rocket science, bt did pick up some good tips to be more efficient. If you know the system well enogh you can have yor notes written in under an hour (real notes not surgery notes)
 
Speaking of EPIC; one of the hospitals I have privileges at is going from paper charting to EPIC.

Physicians have to do something like a ridiculous 15 hours of training. Is it really that difficult or are they assuming we are a bunch of drooling idiots who've never used an EMR before?

That is ridiculous. I was banging my head into the wall after our 10 hours of training. That was awhile ago now though. Since then I've assisted with the rollout for physicians at three different hospitals and I've done many hours of work supporting physician groups with go-lives and templates. If you need help with this sort of thing let me know. The first few days/weeks might be painful, so you'll probably have a lot of help around if it's anything like our hospital system. I don't know if you use paper charts or dictate now. If you do use paper (or Dragon or another voice recognition software), my biggest advice is to make sure your templates get built for your practice before you start in the live environment. A good template builder or just enough time playing around with it can get you notes that are slick and include a lot of pre-filled information as long as your support staff is updating the charts.

I will say surgeons and other physicians who frequently do procedures and clinic visits on inpatients and outpatients and move patients between those environments (i.e. admissions, from floor to surgery to ICU, etc...) have the hardest time on EPIC. You likely need the highest amount of training for this reason. Everything is context dependent with the different navigators, orders, and order sets, so it is hardest on you guys. In other words, your screen will look a bit different if you're treating someone as outpatient, inpatient, or even in the PACU or other hospital based areas.

Of course you have an advantage because you're comfortable with a computer already. The older guys have a really hard time. Part of this is because it enforces things like JCAHO requirements onto procedural based groups which can impact revenue (things groups like cardiologists should have been doing but never did like med recs), and part of it is because the screen really is fairly complicated for someone who is not tech saavy. If you can't type well and there's not dictation services... Oh boy.

Level 5 new patient / consult notes / thorough admission notes should not take anywhere near an hour once you get used to it and you have the right template. What I do is have a pre-filled normal ROS and physical exam and I just edit it to reflect the things that are abnormal. The histories, labs, and imaging studies pull in automatically. This just leaves you typing (or dictating with Dragon) an HPI and assessment and plan.

gutonc: for chemo were you guys using BEACON? At least I think it's called BEACON. I didn't get training in it, but what you're describing sounds a lot like what they gave us for chemo here.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, but building that old information like histories into the patients chart is painful. At our rollout now it is the admitting provider who puts all that in the system. So it takes a long time to put that crap in there at first. And the order sets and names for orders are very dependent on who puts them in. Today I spent an hour trying to find out what the heck the idiots name an order for humidified oxygen via venti mask. Five phone calls, three people with me including the RT, and we finally found it. How stupid is that?? And ordering a blood transfusion actually takes something like 15 different orders. Really?

There are some significant issues with going to the new system, but truly I think the pain now will be worth it in the end.
 
Yeah, but building that old information like histories into the patients chart is painful. At our rollout now it is the admitting provider who puts all that in the system. So it takes a long time to put that crap in there at first.

Yeah that sucks. Here we nurses and MAs doing most of that, but I could see how residents could be used as cheap scut labor for this. It's super sweet when you have a frequent flier or bounceback admission though because your note is mostly done for you. Give it a year or two and just about everyone will be like that, especially if you admit clinic patients. Unfortunately, it's the teams in the future who really benefit from this.

And the order sets and names for orders are very dependent on who puts them in. Today I spent an hour trying to find out what the heck the idiots name an order for humidified oxygen via venti mask. Five phone calls, three people with me including the RT, and we finally found it. How stupid is that??

Maybe I lose out on some of the pain because of the support staff here. The nurses can search the names for orders if you need them to. It gets a little screwy with wound care orders, RT orders, and other small device orders because at times you can't figure out what they're called. Sometimes at least here they really are just communication orders. So I'll just put in a communication order and call for it and hope that works. Nurses can put in the orders later as verbals if they find them with RT.

And ordering a blood transfusion actually takes something like 15 different orders. Really?

We use an order set for it. It's not that bad. Maybe they need a similar order set or the order set they're using isn't set up well. A lot of issues at first come down to poor design of order sets and as they improve, things improve. Plus you can customize the default settings on your own order sets for extra speed.
 
Yeah, I found the favorites list. That did speed things up after I put stuff in there for orders. I know it will be ok, but the beginning is painful. Even more painful when you are getting calls that say "we have three in the ED for you" and you are on alone. Truly sucks for now.

Sigh. I know it will all be good, but the build out hasn't been very good at all at this point.
 
I hope it isn't as painful as you two describe.

My office has an EMR (always have). Its mostly templated, so I dictate very little anymore. For other hospital notes, I rarely dictate because I have prefabbed notes and I type fast, thus requiring little changes - more of a pain really to dictate, and then log back in the next day, make changes and sign off.

The hospital which is transitioning to EPIC is paper based right now. My office FAXes over my H & P and they have pre-printed orders for my post-op patients. Scripts are done electronically through my office (except for Scheduled drugs which need to be printed out).

I have no idea if they'll have support staff to enter in the data; after all, these are community hospitals without employed physicians (i.e., they aren't my staff and they aren't requiring my office staff to do the training). But I'll be damned if I'm going to spend an hour (or anything more than 5 minutes) entering in another H & P for admission when I have a lengthy one from my office EMR. After all, the vast vast majority of my surgical patients stay less than 48 hours, more like 24 hours. Right now (at other hospitals with EMRs), I simply sign a pre-fab note which stays "no changes to H & P".

My plan is to stock my training sessions with my surgeon buddies so perhaps the average learning curve will be a little higher.
 
I hope it isn't as painful as you two describe.

Frankly, it's painful for the first few patients, then gets easier. What makes it most painful is when things are not set up for you or your group. We have had an extensive infrastructure for helping our groups and independent groups working within our hospital system migrate to EPIC, but some attendings frankly hated EPIC and have been resistant every step of the way. That makes it painful because they refuse any attempt to help set up EPIC for them before rollout or to customize it to optimize their workflow. Then after the EPIC roll out, things start to break because the training was blown off and the practice did not do what they needed to do. Then attending temper tantrums start to happen. It's my job to clean those messes up. But, as long as you get things organized during training with your support structure and don't blow off the training, this should not be that painful.

My office has an EMR (always have). Its mostly templated, so I dictate very little anymore. For other hospital notes, I rarely dictate because I have prefabbed notes and I type fast, thus requiring little changes - more of a pain really to dictate, and then log back in the next day, make changes and sign off.

Good. Make sure these same notes are created in EPIC for you. Or maybe that's part of your training to work on building them with help. See my next paragraph about whether you'll actually need to have these notes or not depending on your practice arrangement with that hospital. I recommend having an H&P/consult note, post-op note, daily progress note, and discharge note made for you. You may not need customized notes if you are happy with the generic notes. You may not need them on every patient, but it's good to know which notes you'll need when the situations come up.

The hospital which is transitioning to EPIC is paper based right now. My office FAXes over my H & P and they have pre-printed orders for my post-op patients. Scripts are done electronically through my office (except for Scheduled drugs which need to be printed out).

After all, the vast vast majority of my surgical patients stay less than 48 hours, more like 24 hours. Right now (at other hospitals with EMRs), I simply sign a pre-fab note which stays "no changes to H & P".

You can still fax over the H&P. As part of the pre-op navigator, you will just have to do a "interval note" with the no changes bit. That is as simple as typing out the equivalent of "Patient seen and examined. No changes since history and physical performed in my office which has been sent for scanning into EPIC." You can make a dotphrase for it so you just type ".nochanges" or something like that.

As for the orders, someone will have to enter these orders electronically. This might be you, it might be your PA/NP if you have one, or it might be a supporting RN. What needs to happen is that your pre-printed orders can be created as an "order set". You need a pre-op order set that can be created based on your paper orders. Unlike the notes which you can build yourself, you will likely need someone from your EPIC roll out team to build this for you. Also, you will want a at least one post-op order set built for you as well (I imagine you have paper orders for this as well?), and you may want more than one depending on your preferences and depending on how different your orders are for post-op to home, post-op to floor, and post-op to ICU (though to ICU may not apply to your practice). You will also have post-op instructions that you can build for yourself into a dotphrase so you stick it in for the patient quickly.

I know this sounds like a lot, but it really isn't once it's set up and once you get used to it. The EPIC screens (navigators) are set up to make this flow logically. You will have to reconcile the patient's medications on admission and discharge as a part of the navigators (I understand this to be a JCAHO requirement), but this is quick once you're used to doing it. Post-op it is also a JCAHO requirement to either immediately do a brief post-op note and then dictate or do the full post-op note later. Or you can do the full post-op note immediately. I mention this because I'm not sure everyone understands this point. Regardless, what many high volume proceduralists hate about EPIC is that it forces them or their support staff to satisfy JCAHO requirements that they often weren't fulfilling. Hospital administration loves this, physicians don't.

As for scripts, you don't *need* to use EPIC to generate them for you, but be warned that other physicians in that hospital system may look in EPIC to see what prescriptions that patient is on if they return to that hospital. They may not be aware of what prescriptions you have given them unless they look closely into your notes. There is a way to enter them yourself or have support staff enter them into EPIC without a new script being generated, but it's an extra step.

I have no idea if they'll have support staff to enter in the data; after all, these are community hospitals without employed physicians (i.e., they aren't my staff and they aren't requiring my office staff to do the training). But I'll be damned if I'm going to spend an hour (or anything more than 5 minutes) entering in another H & P for admission when I have a lengthy one from my office EMR.

You won't need to write another H&P in the case you're describing. The only case where you will need to do another H&P is if you are admitting a patient to that hospital for which you do not have a H&P from your clinic. You could still conceivably do the note in your office's EMR and fax it over, but this is rather clumsy. I don't know if you have to admit patients to that hospital outside of elective surgeries. If you ever do, I'd be ready with a standard admission note within EPIC and an admission order set that you're familiar with.
 
Last edited:
We just switched to Epic, hospital wide. I'm only half a month into it but our department spent a good deal of time making sure the interface and flow was customized properly for the ED. I think the transition really depends on how much time you put into making Epic customize all the requisite changes. They can make quite a few changes to the system and interface to help improve work flow. However, it's still been a work in process and we still have more than a few bugs to work out. It's been a painful transition but at this point I can see the potential. However, I noticed that it's department specific. When I do med-tox consults on the floor, it's like I have none of the customized bells and whistles like I do in the ED. It's basically just a blank consult note with that reminds me of windows notepad that I guess works if you build a bunch of pre-set smartphrases, etc..

I love the smartphrases and smartPE macros though... Definitely saves time.

I talked with the Epic guys about the iPad app and my understanding is that it's a work in process but primarily will be aimed at querying and displaying Epic lab/diagnostic, etc.. results and displaying patient data, not as a tool to enter orders and take the place of the computer interface. So, from that aspect, it probably benefits those of you doing rounds on the floor. I can definitely see the usefulness there, but it doesn't really help us down in the ED.
 
I talked with the Epic guys about the iPad app and my understanding is that it's a work in process but primarily will be aimed at querying and displaying Epic lab/diagnostic, etc.. results and displaying patient data, not as a tool to enter orders and take the place of the computer interface. So, from that aspect, it probably benefits those of you doing rounds on the floor. I can definitely see the usefulness there, but it doesn't really help us down in the ED.

The app (Haiku/Canto) is just an information retrieval tool (and is still pretty rough IMHO). But you can also run Epic itself on an iPad which gives you the full monty.
 
The app (Haiku/Canto) is just an information retrieval tool (and is still pretty rough IMHO). But you can also run Epic itself on an iPad which gives you the full monty.

Gut, I haven't tried it but my understanding is that to run the full thing, it's more of a RDS type functionality where you are remoting to a virtualized desktop environment such as Citrix, etc.. for access to the full application. I can't imagine trying to use Epic on the tiny iPad screen with my finger and no mouse...
 
Gut, I haven't tried it but my understanding is that to run the full thing, it's more of a RDS type functionality where you are remoting to a virtualized desktop environment such as Citrix, etc.. for access to the full application. I can't imagine trying to use Epic on the tiny iPad screen with my finger and no mouse...

That's exactly what it is, remote access, just like doing it from home. I don't think I'd want to write notes on the iPad or anything, but using it to place orders wouldn't be bad at all.
 
We had I think 1.5 days of epic training before internship, which was way overkill. It's pretty self explanatory once you get going. Personally I like epic, but I don't have experience with tons of different EMR systems. I feel like I can get my charting and orders done a lot faster in epic than I can in CPRS, which might be me, and it might be the system. I'll say I've spent about equal time with both systems, though.

As for the original question, I'd go with an iphone.
 
That's exactly what it is, remote access, just like doing it from home. I don't think I'd want to write notes on the iPad or anything, but using it to place orders wouldn't be bad at all.

You know after reading this... I used my iPhone with citrix receiver to log into Epic and was actually, and surprisingly able to enter in a few orders with the small iPhone interface. I did it from home, but think I might test it out when I'm at work next in the ED. I'm not sure if it would improve efficiency, but if I could at least get orders entered while I'm in the patient room, it would definitely help.
 
Get a large screened Android. It's much easier to carry than an iPad and much bigger screen than an iPhone.

HTC One X is currently the best choice. 4.65" screen, super high resolution (ballpark of iPhone 4S), and just a little bigger than the iPhone 4S. It looks amazing and feels great in your hand. It supports flash. If you're going to use EPIC, the screen is much more pleasing.

Samsung Galaxy S3 is coming out too which is another great choice. High res AMOLED screen, also 4.7"ish screen, just as fast as the One X (both are way faster than the iPhone 4S), swappable battery, removable storage, etc. You may have to wait a little though as it may not be launched until early next month in the States.
 
Top