One our our surgeons is encouraging us to use spect/ct as a diagnostic tool for patients with axial pain to identify specific facet joints as the pain generator as well as to help identify patients with vertebrogenic vs facet mediated pain. Anyone incorporate this in their practice and find it of value?
-
CycleTrack and SDN are teaming up to make medical school admissions more transparent and accessible! Read the announcement to learn how we’re supporting the future of CycleTrack’s free application-tracking tools .
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
SPECT/CT
Started by Dr. Ice
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
It's not wrong but MRI is more SOC in the states. I think someone was saying in Canada they use NM Bone Scans as a poor man's MRI to rule in arthritis. I use it rarely in patients that can't get an MRI or where I can't reasonably order that many regions of the body to be scanned. The CT SPECT findings should correlate with MRI findings but may be easier to interpret for bone pathology if you aren't using to looking at your own films or the radiologists ignore things.One our our surgeons is encouraging us to use spect/ct as a diagnostic tool for patients with axial pain to identify specific facet joints as the pain generator as well as to help identify patients with vertebrogenic vs facet mediated pain. Anyone incorporate this in their practice and find it of value?
Last edited:
We used to have a surgeon that would order them. They type that would dictate a 3 page note talking himself into and out of surgery, plans to order all imaging, and consult all other services (psych, pcp, cardiology, endo, pulmonary). And he wouldn’t ever do any surgeries.
Surgeons love their radiation.. imho mri w stir is more useful as a pain physician. Must fix bone! lol
Is your surgeon old ? Typically these are ordered only by geezer surgeons.One our our surgeons is encouraging us to use spect/ct as a diagnostic tool for patients with axial pain to identify specific facet joints as the pain generator as well as to help identify patients with vertebrogenic vs facet mediated pain. Anyone incorporate this in their practice and find it of value?
There is no reason to do spect unless you are truly stumped and can’t figure out the affected level. I’ve ordered this exactly once in the past 5 years.
It shouldn’t be used 99% of the time. Lots of unnecessary radiation and MBB are more accurate than SPECT.
It’s always L4-L5 and L5-S1. Unless the first MBB doesnt work. Then perhaps it is L2-L3 L3-L4.
He’s young actually which is why I was wondering if it’s something worth looking into. I see many people with anterior posterior column pain, modic changes, facet disease and disc disease all at once presenting all axial and no radicular pain. Just wondering if in those patients worth it to try to help narrow down and streamline treatment
That's surprising he's that young. Maybe influenced from his fellowship attendings?He’s young actually which is why I was wondering if it’s something worth looking into. I see many people with anterior posterior column pain, modic changes, facet disease and disc disease all at once presenting all axial and no radicular pain. Just wondering if in those patients worth it to try to help narrow down and streamline treatment
The thing about our field is that there are not that many interventional choices you need to consider for 90% of patients.
If you've excluded infection/cancer/autoimmune/fracture/SIJ pain, it's going to be disc or facet 99% of time. If despite a good exam and history, you aren't sure how much is anterior vs posterior, you could start with an epidural, and if doesn't do much, then it's facet and the patient is simultaneously more psychologically ready for the lengthy process of MBB/RFA because the quick easy "shot" wasn't enough.
And patients are definitely pissed if they go through MBB/RFA only to be told later that they could have just had a 5 minute ESI. That said, for patients who are obvious facet, you should start with MBB/RFA.
Last edited:
Maybe I’m just ignorant of the modality but what does SPECT show you that the STIR sequence of an MRI doesn’t?
Also far less cost and radiation from 2 MBBs and well over half the time that’s sufficient.
Also far less cost and radiation from 2 MBBs and well over half the time that’s sufficient.
If they already have one I'll look at it to see if some facets are hotter than others. If facets are ice cold and something like SIJ lights up, makes me take a second look. It's a lot of radiation as others have mentioned.
Interesting paper out recently about this: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42741405/
Interesting paper out recently about this: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42741405/
He’s young actually which is why I was wondering if it’s something worth looking into. I see many people with anterior posterior column pain, modic changes, facet disease and disc disease all at once presenting all axial and no radicular pain. Just wondering if in those patients worth it to try to help narrow down and streamline treatment
Did he train at Mayo? When I was there some of the spine and radiology guys were writing papers on utilizing SPECT/CT over MRI. I think MRI w/ STIR is plenty fine though. Out in the boonies we don't have access to SPECT anyway.
Did he train at Mayo? When I was there some of the spine and radiology guys were writing papers on utilizing SPECT/CT over MRI. I think MRI w/ STIR is plenty fine though. Out in the boonies we don't have access to SPECT anyway.
Sometimes spect CT can identify a hot facet. So? Not worth the radiation
I'm completely against SPECT for 99% of cases. Ironically though, the cuts in RF levels compared with 5 years ago now make SPECT more useful.Maybe I’m just ignorant of the modality but what does SPECT show you that the STIR sequence of an MRI doesn’t?
Also far less cost and radiation from 2 MBBs and well over half the time that’s sufficient.
Sounds like government.
They decrease the cost of procedure by a slight amount by limiting us to 2 levels instead of 3, and so now some patients need to under expensive procedures with lots of radiation, instead of medicare just paying the doc $160 to do the 3rd level RFA.
This is why I don't vote for more government
ASM proposed and formalized by Trump admin…I'm completely against SPECT for 99% of cases. Ironically though, the cuts in RF levels compared with 5 years ago now make SPECT more useful.
Sounds like government.
They decrease the cost of procedure by a slight amount by limiting us to 2 levels instead of 3, and so now some patients need to under expensive procedures with lots of radiation, instead of medicare just paying the doc $160 to do the 3rd level RFA.
This is why I don't vote for more government