The UC self-pity thread

Med School Insiders
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
ZedsDed

ZedsDed

You know what really grinds my gears?
10+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2014
Messages
9,272
Reaction score
11,011
Last edited:
.
 
Last edited:
ZedsDed said:
Ask and you shall receive.

Share your woes here fam. Consider this thread our collective pillow to cry into.

@gyngyn Why can't you people just love us?!
Click to expand...
I love you (mostly).
 
first-world-problem-woman-meme.jpg
 
I always throw this out there to CA people: my old roomate was a CA resident who applied to MD schools 2 years ago and didnt get a single interview. He moves across country and becomes a resident of West Virginia working in a research lab in Morgantown. Applies with a very similar resume as before and this time gets into WVU and Marshall by Nov of that app cycle. His 3.55/30 goes from not even getting noticed to having both of his new state schools wanting him. Hell Marshall guarantees a interview for anybody with over a 3.5/26. Food for thought for all those in the CA region wholl do anything to do what they can to get into an MD school. Create your own luck.
 
GrapesofRath said:
I always throw this out there to CA people: my old roomate was a CA resident who applied to MD schools 2 years ago and didnt get a single interview. He moves across country and becomes a resident of West Virginia working in a research lab in Morgantown. Applies with a very similar resume as before and this time gets into WVU and Marshall by Nov of that app cycle. His 3.55/30 goes from not even getting noticed to having both of his new state schools wanting him. Hell Marshall guarantees a interview for anybody with over a 3.5/26. Food for thought for all those in the CA region wholl do anything to do what they can to get into an MD school. Create your own luck.
Click to expand...
But they don't want to ever leave sunny California!
 
Cyberdyne 101 said:
Texas has plenty of sun!! And it's an awesome state for med school applicants!!
Click to expand...

Texas is not comparable to Cali lol. There is sun but in the hellfire and brimstone kind of way, not in the "woah let's go catch some waves bro after our Yelp-for-dogs (Dgly (TM)) valuation meeting bro".
In Northern California many places didn't have air conditioning. In Texas if you don't have air conditioning you will be faced with certain death either from the heat or from insanity which drives you to run naked into traffic.

Also the state government is certifiably insane, especially if you are an ObGyn or PCP here. Texas is great overall but I can't wait to leave honestly
 
Lucca said:
Texas is not comparable to Cali lol. There is sun but in the hellfire and brimstone kind of way, not in the "woah let's go catch some waves bro after our Yelp-for-dogs (Dgly (TM)) valuation meeting bro".
In Northern California many places didn't have air conditioning. In Texas if you don't have air conditioning you will be faced with certain death either from the heat or from insanity which drives you to run naked into traffic.

Also the state government is certifiably insane, especially if you are an ObGyn or PCP here. Texas is great overall but I can't wait to leave honestly
Click to expand...
I was being facetious about the sun lol. Also, I think it's difficult to establish Texas residency for the purpose of med school admission.

That said, it's still one of the best states for med school applicants.
 
Cyberdyne 101 said:
I was being facetious about the sun lol. Also, I think it's difficult to establish Texas residency for the purpose of med school admission.

That said, it's still one of the best states for med school applicants.
Click to expand...

It definitely is. I still hold to the fact that it must be like twice as easy here than other places because I know many, many borderline stats people who get into an MD school in state on their first try as trad applicants with fairly cookie-cutter apps.

Austin is the best city in Texas though. Houston is aight but just because of the TMC and the fine arts scene (or the jobs if you work in energy). Houston might be better than Austin if you are rich though. Dallas is meh. The rest of Texas is written off as a Total Loss.
 
Lucca said:
It definitely is. I still hold to the fact that it must be like twice as easy here than other places because I know many, many borderline stats people who get into an MD school in state on their first try as trad applicants with fairly cookie-cutter apps.

Austin is the best city in Texas though. Houston is aight but just because of the TMC and the fine arts scene (or the jobs if you work in energy). Houston might be better than Austin if you are rich though. Dallas is meh. The rest of Texas is written off as a Total Loss.
Click to expand...

Hey, San Antonio is one of the fastest growing cities in the US and a huge tourist destination. It's definitely not a loss! (Might have some home city bias)
 
So do we think that Kaiser Med and CalMed will be gamechangers? Or is it too little too late?
 
p0gono said:
So do we think that Kaiser Med and CalMed will be gamechangers? Or is it too little too late?
Click to expand...
Right now 4,082 CA applicants get in nowhere. 1,528 have to leave the state. Two schools won't put much of a dent in either of these figures.
 
Cyberdyne 101 said:
Texas has plenty of sun!! And it's an awesome state for med school applicants!!
Click to expand...
And @Lucca

Texas is not that great for med applicants. Sure they have 7 more schools to choose from which have lower tuition, but the average GPA and MCAT is the same as national averages and the acceptance rate is actually a little lower.
 
piii said:
Texas is not that great for med applicants. Sure they have 7 more schools to choose from which have lower tuition, but the average GPA and MCAT is the same as national averages and the acceptance rate is actually a little lower.
Click to expand...
And they are much less likely to be viewed as viable candidates for OOS schools.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
gyngyn said:
And they are much less likely to be viewed as viable candidates for OOS schools.
Click to expand...

That dirt cheap tuition you get from so many of the state schools is a huge factor though. If you get into med school and are from Texas odds are you arent paying much to attend. That has to be part of the discussion for how "lucky" a state is.
 
gyngyn said:
And they are much less likely to be viewed as viable candidates for OOS schools.
Click to expand...

That's true. It's not as big a downside for 99% of competitive applicants though since all of our in-state options are twice as cheap as any OOS option. My friends with stats/ECs in the stratosphere have not had any issues at the top 10 schools OOS though.
 
GrapesofRath said:
That dirt cheap tuition you get from so many of the state schools is a huge factor though. If you get into med school and are from Texas odds are you arent paying much to attend.
Click to expand...
Yes, we know that they are not going to matriculate OOS (without a big incentive).
 
Lucca said:
My friends with stats/ECs in the stratosphere have not had any issues at the top 10 schools OOS though.
Click to expand...
All 215 of them! That's why we don't interview them without these accomplishments/qualities.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
gyngyn said:
Yes, we know that they are not going to matriculate OOS (without a big incentive).
Click to expand...

Well the national acceptance rate is 43% and for Texas its 38%. It's a trade off; not having OOS schools as a viable option makes things a bit harder but for those who do get in the tuition benefits are enormous. I personally dont consider it a bad trade off but that's in the eye of the beholder. The only people who might struggle in particular are the low GPA/higher MCAT types due to Texas's GPA emphasis.

In general though overall acceptance rates where you combine IS and OOS data for a state are bad predictors of how "lucky" they are. Really unlucky states like Maryland, Massachusetts, Rhode Island etc have well above average overall acceptance rates. Lucky states like Nebraska, Louisana, Mississippi etc have pretty low overall acceptance rates combining IS and OOS apps.
 
Last edited:
gyngyn said:
All 215 of them! That why we don't interview them without these accomplishments.
Click to expand...

It's funny because 9/10 pre-meds applying I know want to leave Texas lol. The problem is, nobody can justify it. This is the Texas curse. It's the same story for undergrad too.

Thankfully, I'm a massive nerd and want to play around in a lab for four years before graduating from medical school so maybe I'll get to one of the coasts one day *stares dreamily into the distance*.
 
Cyberdyne 101 said:
Texas has plenty of sun!! And it's an awesome state for med school applicants!!
Click to expand...

Floridas 9 med schools (soon to be 11) are always happy to be a sunny but much more humid home to transplanted Californians lol...

The dean of USF actually tours UC schools recruiting their students to apply!
 
I'm curious, how do y'all UC SDN'ers feel about your undergrads? At least here everyone has high opinions of all of the UCs. Curious to know what y'all think of them since I only have friends at Berkeley, UCLA and Stanford in Cali.
 
Lucca said:
I'm curious, how do y'all UC SDN'ers feel about your undergrads? At least here everyone has high opinions of all of the UCs. Curious to know what y'all think of them since I only have friends at Berkeley, UCLA and Stanford in Cali.
Click to expand...
There isn't a bad one in the bunch. They are the best bang for your public education dollar in the country.
 
The Knife & Gun Club said:
Floridas 9 med schools (soon to be 11) are always happy to be a sunny but much more humid home to transplanted Californians lol...

The dean of USF actually tours UC schools recruiting their students to apply!
Click to expand...

It's funny for how many med schools FL has how low the acceptance rate for the state is. 20% IS matriculation rate is well below average. Just way way too many pre-meds in Fl applying and many of the FL schools are actually pretty small.

Fl is kind of like the UCs you bring up; everybody wants to stay their and go to med school there but only 1/5 people actually get to.

https://www.aamc.org/download/321466/data/factstablea5.pdf
 
Last edited:
Lucca said:
I'm curious, how do y'all UC SDN'ers feel about your undergrads? At least here everyone has high opinions of all of the UCs. Curious to know what y'all think of them since I only have friends at Berkeley, UCLA and Stanford in Cali.
Click to expand...
I liked UC Davis a lot, and I felt like a got a good education there. I imagine it would have been similar at most of the other UCs. I also attended at a time when they were much more affordable. I believe they produce a good product for the price. What's funny is now that I am in AZ, people here view the UCs in much higher regard (which is a good thing I think). People here actually know more of the UCs and respect them highly.

That being said, I did my post-bacc at a CSU, and my classes were no more than 25 people. At UCD, my science lectures were 300-500 people. I learned, a little too late, that I do better in smaller classes with more professor interaction. The UCs are massive, and it just didn't work with my learning style. It works well for many though.
 
TheaterOfTheme said:
Boy...So is it worse for Cali or Texas as an OOS?


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

As OOS California applicant you will probably be viewed like any other OOS applicant. If you are an OOS from Texas evidence shows that you are much less likely to receive an II. If you want to leave Cali, you have the better deal as a Cali applicant. If you want to stay in Texas then you have the better deal overall as a Texan. If you want to stay in Cali or leave Texas you are going to have a hard time.
 
Lucca said:
Texas is not comparable to Cali lol. There is sun but in the hellfire and brimstone kind of way, not in the "woah let's go catch some waves bro after our Yelp-for-dogs (Dgly (TM)) valuation meeting bro".
In Northern California many places didn't have air conditioning. In Texas if you don't have air conditioning you will be faced with certain death either from the heat or from insanity which drives you to run naked into traffic.

Also the state government is certifiably insane, especially if you are an ObGyn or PCP here. Texas is great overall but I can't wait to leave honestly
Click to expand...
I just knew when I saw the title to this thread that there would be some vitriol for Texas. Don't hate because you ain't!
 
Lucca said:
But I definitely am and I still hate lol
Click to expand...
Hahahaha didn't read the last part of your comment... Maybe one day we will overthrow the hateful tea baggers who have hijacked the place and we can both bask in the awesomeness.
 
TheaterOfTheme said:
Boy...So is it worse for Cali or Texas as an OOS?


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Click to expand...
If you are trying to get into CA or TX, you can look at OOS matriculation at the schools that consider them. If you add the OOS matriculants from all the non-mission based CA schools that consider them (exclude LL,UCR, UCD), there are 202 OOS matriculants/844 available seats or 24%. By law, TX publics can only seat 10% or less. In TX, 167 OOSers matriculated over 1585 total spots or 10.5%.

Sampling the number of OOS applicants for private vs public in the two states: Stanford got 4420 OOS applicants for 90 seats, UCSF got 3730 OOS applicants for 165 spots; Baylor got 5128 OOS applicants for 185 total seats (of which it could legally fill 37 with OOS) but UTSW only got 1147 OOS applicants for 23 total OOS seats.
Baylor actually filled 38 seats with OOSers! I guess they will cut back next year!
UTSW seated 33/232 OOSers or 14% which leads me to suspect that the 10% rule may apply to the UT system as a whole and not to a given school. Or maybe they let the school consider total enrollment...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I liked going to school at UC Santa Cruz but in retrospect I wish I'd applied to Berkeley. Actually I wish I just hadn't gone to college until I knew what I wanted to do, altho lord knows I *cherish* my degree in poetry, and world famous banana slug affiliation.

That said, none of the UC med schools are in the kinds of locations that made California lovable (to me). Aesthetically, the cities are starting to feel more and more like endless Whole Foods parking lots.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
GrapesofRath said:
I always throw this out there to CA people: my old roomate was a CA resident who applied to MD schools 2 years ago and didnt get a single interview. He moves across country and becomes a resident of West Virginia working in a research lab in Morgantown. Applies with a very similar resume as before and this time gets into WVU and Marshall by Nov of that app cycle. His 3.55/30 goes from not even getting noticed to having both of his new state schools wanting him. Hell Marshall guarantees a interview for anybody with over a 3.5/26. Food for thought for all those in the CA region wholl do anything to do what they can to get into an MD school. Create your own luck.
Click to expand...

Great advice! I'm not from CA, but the state I grew up in has one of the lowest acceptance rates for in-state applicants. I have below-average stats, and was rejected from my state schools the first time around. Before re-applying, I moved to a state with better results for in-state applicants, changed my residency, and was accepted to an in-state school on my first try here. Definitely a strategy worth considering for those with below average stats or those in highly competitive states!
 
Just curious, why do so many people bash CNU when they don't go there? The people who endlessly criticize the school for reasons like "for-profit" and "no federal financial aid" don't go to the school, so how would you all know the quality of the faculty, the curriculum, the clinical skills etc? I believe only students there can adequately critique the school.

I don't love or hate CNU, I have no opinion on the school. I just think all the hate is a bit unfounded.
 
Cinclus said:
Galveston beaches are gross, but Padre Island National Seashore/Corpus Christi area beaches are pretty darn nice.
Click to expand...
As someone who was born in Galveston and knows those beaches pretty well, I can attest to their Gulfy grossness. Never went to any of the nicer beaches.
 
Lucca said:
I'm curious, how do y'all UC SDN'ers feel about your undergrads? At least here everyone has high opinions of all of the UCs. Curious to know what y'all think of them since I only have friends at Berkeley, UCLA and Stanford in Cali.
Click to expand...
I haven't noticed much of a difference between them outside of the competitiveness for grades. They all seem to have similar access to resources and qualities of education. For example, Irvine uses the same physics book for their "physics for bio majors" course that Cal uses for their "physics for scientists" course.
 
Last edited:
pageantry said:
Aesthetically, the cities are starting to feel more and more like endless Whole Foods parking lots.
Click to expand...
You say that like it's a bad thing.
 
sharkbyte said:
Just curious, why do so many people bash CNU when they don't go there? The people who endlessly criticize the school for reasons like "for-profit" and "no federal financial aid" don't go to the school, so how would you all know the quality of the faculty, the curriculum, the clinical skills etc?
Click to expand...
I've never met the faculty at SGU either.
 
sharkbyte said:
Just curious, why do so many people bash CNU when they don't go there? The people who endlessly criticize the school for reasons like "for-profit" and "no federal financial aid" don't go to the school, so how would you all know the quality of the faculty, the curriculum, the clinical skills etc? I believe only students there can adequately critique the school.

I don't love or hate CNU, I have no opinion on the school. I just think all the hate is a bit unfounded.
Click to expand...
The distaste is not directed at the students.
 
Mad Jack said:
As someone who was born in Galveston and knows those beaches pretty well, I can attest to their Gulfy grossness. Never went to any of the nicer beaches.
Click to expand...
Do you like NE more than Texas? Or has it been a while since you've lived in the Lone Star State?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

S
  • Locked
What counts as the end of the 2-week deadline?
Replies
4
Views
712
ganm
ganm
S
  • Locked
The UC Marginalized Group question is good in theory, poor in practice
Replies
20
Views
2K
chilly_md
chilly_md
M
  • Locked
Thank you for your help - deleting all my posts and locking thread
Replies
4
Views
882
LizzyM
LizzyM
FuturePediatricNeurosurge
Interviews/Essays: Walking the line between savior complex and genuine desire to serve the underserved
Replies
12
Views
2K
FuturePediatricNeurosurge
FuturePediatricNeurosurge
M
Shadowing Physicians at the NIH
Replies
2
Views
553
mimixx
M
Top