Agree with half this statement -- don't make it really poor. That looks bad.
But, as far as I'm aware, no one has ever been ranked highly on the basis of their Pulitzer-prize-winning personal statement. Our dean of students (who is also a program director for a highly competitive surgical residency) has a motto: "don't make it personal, don't make it a statement, and don't put in any scary s***". If you have some kind of absurdly interesting life experiences, I assume they'll find their way into the "experiences" section of ERAS and not need to stand alone in the PS.
Granted, your results may vary if you're going into family medicine, psych, or another field that actually cares about things like personal experiences and physician narratives...
In other news, I've always been told "one page or die" for the PS, and I can't help but notice after copy/pasting into ERAS ... there's no page indicator.
Am I safe if it's one page in Word, 12 pt font, single space, 1 inch margins? Currently about 4000 characters.
For those looking for PS help: I found this on google a while back. Personally, I think it's mediocre, but it gives you at least an idea for the flavor, structure, and length... :
http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/abo...sidency/writing-your-personal-statement.shtml