Case is a great school and it would be an awesome choice. However, you know what i'm going to say. Go to the cheapest school.
I think both schools are comparable and the only difference is location and price. Newark isnt great either but at least its close to home and you can save a ton of money.
I haven't seen case but i was extremely impressed with umdnj. It's so close to the city so whenever you have some time off you're in manhattan in no time at all. the facilities were awesome! so many windows!! I went thinking it was one of my bottom choices but left and am now definitely considering it! I liked it better than stony brook in a lot of aspects. good luck! i didn't vote because i haven't seen case yet