Ultimately a lot depends on you and how hard you're willing to work, and your goals as a Neurologist.
For what it's worth, I think that Miami is a really great program.
-Competition in Chicago is tough with other strong programs like Rush and NU. Rush is very strong at Movement. NU is very strong at neurorehab. UIC is good at stroke. U of C as far as I know hasn't really carved out a niche of it's own. With another couple centers in the mix they might not be the best choice for a Chicago program. Also, U of C didn't have all the subspecialties as fellowships a few years ago either. Some of that might have changed.
-Our program director, Dr. Isaacson, takes a great deal of time to know your application through and through, which is perhaps why some people are startled by his questions. He's involved in the program and very 'relatable,' with genuine intentions.
-We have EMR at every hospital by the way.
Good luck!