Uptick in bipolar diagnoses

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

vpsych

Full Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2021
Messages
13
Reaction score
15
I work in private practice and have found myself diagnosing bipolar disorder more than ever this last few weeks. Granted I've only been practicing for about 5 months.. I’m curious if this might be due to winter season.

Has anyone else noted a similar trend?
 
<I'm not a doctor>

Out of curiosity, is this on the basis of hypomania/mania or bipolar depression? And which hemisphere are you? I have heard of depressive symptoms manifesting more in darker months and manic manifesting more in sunnier months.
 
That's a very short timeframe to draw a trend. Also depends on what proportion of patients you're diagnosing as bipolar and in what sort of setting. If you're at a CMHC or inpatient unit and seeing people with true, obvious, hit you in the face (literally) mania then maybe the seasonal change is related (although a bit late for that.) If you're doing cash outpatient and 50% of your patients describe having "mood swings" or commonly described by these patients as "lots of manias and depressions all the time" then that's a different discussion...

FWIW my outpatient insurance based practice setting sees a full spectrum of psychiatric diagnoses. Very serious/persistent mental illness is the main/only exception, most of those patients being on govt insurance and cared for in the CMHC system. I have very few patients who I think actually have bipolar disorder. I ran a report and about 60 out of my 600 patients have had "bipolar disorder" entered in their chart by someone at some time. That report captures many of the patients I have undiagnosed as bipolar. I'd guess about 5-10 have definitive bipolar (I've seen them manic or they've been hospitalized for clear mania in the past 3 years) and another 10-15 have reasonable suspicion for bipolar but poor historical data makes it unclear along with lower severity "manic" episodes.
 
Last edited:
I see an uptick of needing to spend more time on people already diagnosed bipolar by their former ARNPs and needing to undo that diagnosis and get them off the zyprexa...

Yeah I don't understand why Zyprexa seems to be such a go to as well outside of "running around naked thinking I'm god staying awake for 5 days straight so I got put in the hospital" mania. People get thrown on this for (maybe) hypomanic episodes not infrequently in my experience too.
 
Yeah I don't understand why Zyprexa seems to be such a go to as well outside of "running around naked thinking I'm god staying awake for 5 days straight so I got put in the hospital" mania. People get thrown on this for (maybe) hypomanic episodes not infrequently in my experience too.
Pretty much agreed. I tend to use it for people who are clearly manic by other symptoms and sleeping <2 hours a night and really starting to get themselves in trouble. After/as they stabilize I work on switching to something else (usually abilify.)
 
Yeah I don't understand why Zyprexa seems to be such a go to as well outside of "running around naked thinking I'm god staying awake for 5 days straight so I got put in the hospital" mania. People get thrown on this for (maybe) hypomanic episodes not infrequently in my experience too.
I blame Symbiax

for what its worth ive had some good results with prozac/zyprexa combo in the borderline personality disorder crowd who have severe emotional dysregulation
 
Pretty much agreed. I tend to use it for people who are clearly manic by other symptoms and sleeping <2 hours a night and really starting to get themselves in trouble. After/as they stabilize I work on switching to something else (usually abilify.)
Still don't see the rationale compared to Seroquel which has so much evidence for being a great medication in bipolar disorder and is also very good at getting patients to sleep.
 
Still don't see the rationale compared to Seroquel which has so much evidence for being a great medication in bipolar disorder and is also very good at getting patients to sleep.
I agree for the outpatient bipolar 2 crowd, who present with depression and insomnia, and hx of hypomania. For acute mania, you can start Zyprexa 10 hs and quickly up to 20 if needed, where Seroquel you've gotta titrate a little slower and probably need to get up to the 400mg or more range to put the brakes on manic/hypomanic symptoms.
 
Still don't see the rationale compared to Seroquel which has so much evidence for being a great medication in bipolar disorder and is also very good at getting patients to sleep.
I don't find that people tolerate being put on antipsychotic doses of quetiapine all at once very well although tbh don't have a lot of experience doing so since my practice has not been to go to quetiapine for much of anything first line. If I have someone acutely manic I want them getting something potent that I know will have some effect at reasonably tolerated mania starting doses. I see little advantage to quetiapine over olanzapine long-term, they're both pretty bad as far as adverse effect profile, especially metabolic and sedation.
 
I don't find that people tolerate being put on antipsychotic doses of quetiapine all at once very well although tbh don't have a lot of experience doing so since my practice has not been to go to quetiapine for much of anything first line. If I have someone acutely manic I want them getting something potent that I know will have some effect at reasonably tolerated mania starting doses. I see little advantage to quetiapine over olanzapine long-term, they're both pretty bad as far as adverse effect profile, especially metabolic and sedation.

Adverse effect profile of seroquel seems to be better than olanzapine in meta-analyses in terms of weight gain/metabolic syndrome. Olanzapine is one of the worst weight gain/metabolic offenders. The thing that tends in my experience to lead to discontinuation for seroquel is the sedation and orthostatic hypotension sometimes. Just for an example:



gr3.jpg
 
I agree for the outpatient bipolar 2 crowd, who present with depression and insomnia, and hx of hypomania. For acute mania, you can start Zyprexa 10 hs and quickly up to 20 if needed, where Seroquel you've gotta titrate a little slower and probably need to get up to the 400mg or more range to put the brakes on manic/hypomanic symptoms.

Agree I feel that's the big advantage of zyprexa. Lots of evidence of efficacy but significant side effect burden which can actually be helpful in acute real mania to knock someone down a bit, and you get up to a real dopamine blocking dose quickly (unlike seroquel). So inpatient it's very logical to use.
 
Adverse effect profile of seroquel seems to be better than olanzapine in meta-analyses in terms of weight gain/metabolic syndrome. Olanzapine is one of the worst weight gain/metabolic offenders. The thing that tends in my experience to lead to discontinuation for seroquel is the sedation and orthostatic hypotension sometimes. Just for an example:



gr3.jpg
Correct. They both cause more weight gain than basically every other relevant maintenance option. I'm still going to try to switch someone to a med that won't make them (as) fat if they're stabilized on quetiapine, same as if they were stabilized on olanzapine.
 
Last edited:
Correct. They both cause more weight gain than basically every other relevant maintenance option. I'm still going to try to switch someone to a med that won't make them (as) fat if they're stabilized on quetiapine, same as if they were stabilized on olanzapine.

Sure but if I'm picking between Seroquel vs Olanzapine/Fluoxetine for bipolar depression...I'm probably going to Seroquel first.
 
Sure but if I'm picking between Seroquel vs Olanzapine/Fluoxetine for bipolar depression...I'm probably going to Seroquel first.
That wasn't really the context of what I was discussing but I see why you were arguing for quetiapine being slightly better than olanzapine in terms of weight gain because I mentioned "long term."

I still hold they are both similarly unappealing options and so you'd be choosing between them only after failing a bunch of other options for bipolar depression, as well. The first not even being an antipsychotic.
 
That wasn't really the context of what I was discussing but I see why you were arguing for quetiapine being slightly better than olanzapine in terms of weight gain because I mentioned "long term."

I still hold they are both similarly unappealing options and so you'd be choosing between them only after failing a bunch of other options for bipolar depression, as well. The first not even being an antipsychotic.

Why would that be? Seroquel is considered a first line option for bipolar depression, seeing that it's one of the few meds with actual proven efficacy for the depressive episodes.
 
That wasn't really the context of what I was discussing but I see why you were arguing for quetiapine being slightly better than olanzapine in terms of weight gain because I mentioned "long term."

I still hold they are both similarly unappealing options and so you'd be choosing between them only after failing a bunch of other options for bipolar depression, as well. The first not even being an antipsychotic.

I also tend to be somewhat less trigger-happy with antipsychotics than some of y'all but I will say Seroquel as an early option for bipolar depression has the major advantage of cementing buy-in from the sorts of patients who are coming to treatment because they want help rather than being pressured by employers/family etc. but are very ambivalent about the whole thing. to the extent sleep is an issue they notice big gains fast and while I would never use it primarily as a sleep aid demonstrating that actually what you are prescribing might be a positive thing sometimes. This is less true of many other options.
 
Why would that be? Seroquel is considered a first line option for bipolar depression, seeing that it's one of the few meds with actual proven efficacy for the depressive episodes.
It depends on what you're optimizing for. If people are super severely depressed and need a response then I agree you want something with robust proven effectiveness. But in terms of maintenance regimen for average outpatient with bipolar, especially if they do not have super severe episodes, I'm giving them a shot at lamotrigine, lurasidone, or lithium first. The effect size/quality of evidence may be weaker but the effect size doesn't matter if your patients stop taking the med because they're getting fat/feel super sedated all the time. (I'm not ignoring that the latter two still have some weight gain associated as well)
 
It depends on what you're optimizing for. If people are super severely depressed and need a response then I agree you want something with robust proven effectiveness. But in terms of maintenance regimen for average outpatient with bipolar, especially if they do not have super severe episodes, I'm giving them a shot at lamotrigine, lurasidone, or lithium first. The effect size/quality of evidence may be weaker but the effect size doesn't matter if your patients stop taking the med because they're getting fat/feel super sedated all the time. (I'm not ignoring that the latter two still have some weight gain associated as well)

Idk I feel like tolerability wise I haven't had much more success with lithium as opposed to seroquel. Lithium also has the pretty significant downside of the theraputic vs toxic levels being so close that seroquel doesn't have (ex. someone decides to go spend a couple days working outside gets dehydrated and now has lithium toxicity).

I wish I could use Latuda more first line but most insurance companies want people to have failed lithium/seroquel/lamictal before they'll even think about it.
 
Around here the big insurers won't even consider paying for it unless you document a trial of at least two of risperidone, olanzapine, and quetiapine, so....
Latuda is also a tough medication for some people due to needing to take it with food. Hard to give a sedating med that needs 350 calories at dinner as some people zonk out after. If you need to split to BID dosing then you have AM sedation to deal with. Honestly real adherence for Geodon and Latuda is probably dramatically under 50%.

That said I really like Latuda as a medication for highly motivated people who can take it regularly with food, SE profile and effects in bipolar disorder are good. Easy choice in adolescent psychiatry.
 
Yeah I don't understand why Zyprexa seems to be such a go to as well outside of "running around naked thinking I'm god staying awake for 5 days straight so I got put in the hospital" mania. People get thrown on this for (maybe) hypomanic episodes not infrequently in my experience too.
I just can't get over how many NPs are putting people on Zyprexa for "sleep". I mean its bad enough when they use Seroquel as first line for that, but I've been seeing all these patients on 2.5-5 mg Zyprexa for sleep per the patient, in many cases when they're already on another low to moderate dose SGA. I just don't get where they get these regimens from.
 
I see an uptick of needing to spend more time on people already diagnosed bipolar by their former ARNPs and needing to undo that diagnosis and get them off the zyprexa...
Or getting them off Zoloft 200 and Wellbutrin with a bipolar 2 diagnosis, whose also being prescribed adderall and Klonopin
 
ive been lucky in the sense that its very easy to get people on medications like vraylar due to good coordination with drug rep/pt support programs/people doing PAs, which causes minimal weight gain/SE besides potentially akathisia. It works good for a decent number of people.

I know symbyax is hated by a lot of people, but in fairness if you go off the NICE guidelines, its a first line over in the UK for bipolar depression.

When i worked in a commercial clinic, seroquel wasnt a bad option for bipolar depression and i used it a decent amount. In my current setting, I use it a lot less.

At my facility a while back, there was a patient who presented with manic sx. Turns out he had cut little holes in the effexor capsules and tried to snort them.
 
No...I definitely have not. Bipolar is a diagnosis of exclusion for me. I always start with a careful trauma history and rule out Cluster B personality pathology first. Impulsivity and mood lability are not limited to or even primarily found in bipolar disorder.
 
Pretty much agreed. I tend to use it for people who are clearly manic by other symptoms and sleeping <2 hours a night and really starting to get themselves in trouble. After/as they stabilize I work on switching to something else (usually abilify.)
In my limited experience no one with bipolar 1 , schizoaffective or schizophrenia stays stable for very long on Abilify. Seen much better outcomes with zyprexa, risperdal, clozaril. I know that's probably not everyone's experience. If anyone else has had this experience with Abilify I'd be interested to know.
 
Latuda is also a tough medication for some people due to needing to take it with food. Hard to give a sedating med that needs 350 calories at dinner as some people zonk out after. If you need to split to BID dosing then you have AM sedation to deal with. Honestly real adherence for Geodon and Latuda is probably dramatically under 50%.

That said I really like Latuda as a medication for highly motivated people who can take it regularly with food, SE profile and effects in bipolar disorder are good. Easy choice in adolescent psychiatry.
Oooh and the akathisia with latuda. Every patient I've put on latuda gets akathisia
 
Oooh and the akathisia with latuda. Every patient I've put on latuda gets akathisia
Subjectively, and I believe the data supports this, there is less akathesia in adolescents (and markedly more weight gain) with the atypical class. It clearly still happens and Abilify is very commonly used so its extremely important to pickup.
 
Oooh and the akathisia with latuda. Every patient I've put on latuda gets akathisia

I have had two people independently develop this in the past week, but previously it had not been a major theme in what I heard complaints about. Both folks with bipolar I w/ past psychosis. For both of them the restlessness hit about 45 minutes to an hour after taking it and predictably lasted 2-3 hours. Neither of them especially prone to fixating on side effects in general (one only very reluctantly tried to transition off olanzapine, which they adored, because they had hit 50 extra lbs but now wants to go back to it with more aggressive metformin/weight management strategies).

The only primary psychotic d/o success stories I have with Abilify are people from whom it was the only LAI they would accept and were never going to achieve particularly good adherence to anything otherwise.
 
There is "Bipolar disorder" and then there is real bipolar disorder. If you are taking on a new outpatient and they come in and say that they are here to have "my bipolar disorder treated", they are unlikely to have it. If you have a new outpatient who comes in and says they don't have bipolar disorder, the odds they have bipolar disorder just doubled. 25 years ago everyone suddenly came down with bipolar disorder and the incidence didn't change that much. This is extremely over diagnosed. "I was manic last week". (doctor) How long did that last? "about 2 hours"......
 
There is "Bipolar disorder" and then there is real bipolar disorder. If you are taking on a new outpatient and they come in and say that they are here to have "my bipolar disorder treated", they are unlikely to have it. If you have a new outpatient who comes in and says they don't have bipolar disorder, the odds they have bipolar disorder just doubled. 25 years ago everyone suddenly came down with bipolar disorder and the incidence didn't change that much. This is extremely over diagnosed. "I was manic last week". (doctor) How long did that last? "about 2 hours"......
And then you take some time to explain the time requirements and ask the same question. They insist that they had mania that lasted two hours last night and again last week.

Then they say it's rapid cycling. Repeat the same process. Hear the same answer.
 
I have had two people independently develop this in the past week, but previously it had not been a major theme in what I heard complaints about. Both folks with bipolar I w/ past psychosis. For both of them the restlessness hit about 45 minutes to an hour after taking it and predictably lasted 2-3 hours. Neither of them especially prone to fixating on side effects in general (one only very reluctantly tried to transition off olanzapine, which they adored, because they had hit 50 extra lbs but now wants to go back to it with more aggressive metformin/weight management strategies).

The only primary psychotic d/o success stories I have with Abilify are people from whom it was the only LAI they would accept and were never going to achieve particularly good adherence to anything otherwise.
Same experience. The only people actually controlled on monotherapy I have had were on Maintena. Not even the handful I've had on Aristada have done particularly well on it alone.
 
Top