US Healthcare is approaching a new low...what are they thinking?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

orthomodel

Full Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
May 17, 2006
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
Interesting read on a start-up that developing a credit scoring system for medical bills. I like to read the comments at the bottom to see how informed people are on the fact that MD's really don't have as much say in how they do their job as they used to. http://redtape.msnbc.com/2008/01/the-doctor-wi-1.html#posts


Does anyone else feel like they would like to have some involvement in medical policy-making to stop mess like this from even starting?
 
Does anyone else feel like they would like to have some involvement in medical policy-making to stop mess like this from even starting?

It's like running for President. Anyone with the abilities to actually do some good would never accept such a terrible job.
 
.. why would they need a credit score? what's this going to do for the patient?

do you change your treatment plan based on their revolving debt?
 
Supposedly it's just a way for hospitals to better predict how much money they'll be making and possibly create new ways to help people who they know will have problems paying but of course like anything else, there will always be some business that will take it as an opportunity to bleed people dry. It's just such an obviously ridiculous thing to consider let alone invest in. Do any of these bone-head execs have a soul at all?

I also worry that some MD's might use this as a way to deny people treatment. They might tell their office staff to tell people with bad medical credit that they are completely booked while offering appointments to people with good medical credit.
 
What I find most disconcerting about this article (besides the concept of MedFICO in the first place) are many of the comments below. Apparently, many people seem to believe that doctors should bear the responsibility of solving our health care crisis by providing free care, since it is believed that they swear an oath to "provide services to everyone, regardless of their ability to pay." Some comments of note:

"The Dr. has given as oath to help epople [sic] regardless of their financial abilities."

"Hospitals are full of Doctors. Doctors that take an oath to put the patient first. I for one would never go to a doctor that turned a patient away because of their inability to pay."

"The physicians of this country aren't helping our people by raping all of our pocketbooks and this next development is just another slap in the face to the citizenry of this country that deserves the health care systems provided to our allied countries. When are we all going to stop giving them the other cheek to slap? They are loving that philosophy all the way to their big fat ridiculous bank accounts!"

"Wait a minute! This is not what medicine is about. It's about treating people and caring for them regardless of their ability to pay. This is the most ridiculous crap I've ever heard of."

Yet the same commenters who call doctors "greedy" also tout this great country's "EQUAL OPPORTUNITY FOR ALL OF THOSE WHO WANTS TO WORKS HARD AND ATTAIN THE GOOD LIFE." Why should this not also apply to physicians? If I work hard, why shouldn't I have a shot at the "good life," too? When did I swear an oath to work and not get reimbursed? Young doctors should not be expected to martyr themselves upon the altar of universal care. Of course I chose to go into medicine because I like working with and helping people. But, most importantly, I am becoming a doctor because it is a career, and a way to earn an income. Why is that such a terrible thing? Why should I be expected to work for free?
 
An oath to work for free? I love the ignorance of many in the public that think doctors are wrong to expect payment for the work they do. Yes, we all said we wanted to help people in our personal statements. Show of hands for all those that said they intended to do it for free more times than they get paid? Not very many. I certainly intend to devote some of my time in the future to "charity medicine," but you're crazy if you don't think I'm out there to make a living.

This isn't that different from doctors only allowing 3-4 Medicaid patients per month b/c of the loss of money to treat each patient. "Oh, you have medicaid? I'll see you in 4 months when I have an open slot"
 
.
 
Last edited:
Interesting read on a start-up that developing a credit scoring system for medical bills. I like to read the comments at the bottom to see how informed people are on the fact that MD's really don't have as much say in how they do their job as they used to. http://redtape.msnbc.com/2008/01/the-doctor-wi-1.html#posts


Does anyone else feel like they would like to have some involvement in medical policy-making to stop mess like this from even starting?

What if these credit scores are used by hospitals not to filter admits but to secure social services for patients who truly cannot afford to pay, and to secure collecting agencies to pursue those who can? That's not a new low, that's a really good idea.
 
Top