Wow MeddyMe, I'm shocked they didn't like your application. So just to be clear you were not admitted to USF? I actually was placed on the waitlist and taken off on May 12, several days before the May 15 deadline. So I guess I was pretty high on the waitlist, which actually surprised me....
I got a 22R on the MCAT the first time around (I was really sick that day) and a 29R the 2nd time last August. I had a 3.6GPA and got a BA in Bio from Brandeis University. So, my scores are "solid but not stellar" either

. My only major extracurricular, like I said before, was directing an afterschool mentoring program from middle school students. However, my writing skills are good (I guess that R means I wrote something half-decent for that MCAT section
😛 ) so my secondary essay was probably fine. I do, however, think that the thing that made it for me were my interviews.
The first was with a 4th year. It wasn't a hard interview by any means, more of a fact-finding mission on his part. He just asked about things I like doing, blah blah blah. Pretty easy. The second was much the opposite - Dr. Ledford is on the admissions committee and he is also the head of that committee. He grilled me on why I think I know what I'm doing and why I think I know what the medical profession is
really like. Also, he asked what I think is the most pressing issue in medicine today, and I proceded to discuss our healthcare system problems (he said most people answer that last question with "malpractice" and agrees that our healthcare system is seriously flawed - just in case someone gets him for an interview in the future!). So I guess the interviews really
are important.
I guess, now thinking about it, they really did value community service and volunteering last year when they accepted/rejected applicants. Otherwise, I don't think my application would have looked nearly as good to them!