I'm actually starting at UT in the fall and my roommate is going to WSU in the fall... so i dunno if what i say will help...
i think it depends on personal preference. The education is going to be very similar. From what i hear from other pre-meds the only knock on UT is its location. However, I have yet to see a med student from UT that was unhappy. They all seem to love the school.. I don't really know much about the WSU students, but i do know that there are several who chose WSU over "better" schools..
I would choose where you feel you would be most comfortable and could save the most money... I used to live in the dayton area and beavercreek/fairborn is a very safe and nice place to live. I like the suburban feel it has.. If you like a more urban city than you might want to choose Toledo... The price is pretty close... thats all i have.. sorry if its not helpful.. i was just writing as i thought of stuff..
here is a link to info on toledo
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/show...4&postcount=10
I also PMed a moderator for some questions and this is what he said about UT ( he goes to UT)
I'd have to say that the hands-down best part of going to school here is the supportive atmosphere. We have a great student body, a great faculty and a great administration that really cares about the students well-being. If I am having trouble (academic, personal, etc) I know I have the support of the school and they will help me get through it. I have hit a few bumps already (knee surgery during M1, I'm still fighting with insurance companies... the dean of students personally set me up with a servicing agent to help). This is probably the most uniformly supportive environment I've ever been in
sorry if its not helpful.. i was just writing as i thought of stuff..