iron said:
Having recently finished residency (June 2004), I find myself Chair of a Residency Selection Committe.
Very cool, very cool.
What do applicants like/dislike on interview days?
Personally, I like the following in an interview day:
-reasonable start time- (i.e. no earlier than 8:00 am) Consider that we have to get there, possibly not knowing our way around the city, and usually have to check out of our hotels in the morning, deal with rush hour traffic, etc.
-written schedule/agenda- Not only does this help with writing thank you notes later, it takes away some of the anxiety to know what is coming up during the course of the day. One school printed the schedule on the back of our name tags - brilliant!
-breaks between interviews - It's nice to have a break, on the order of 5-10 minutes, to regroup, allow for some interviews to take too much time, go to the bathroom, get some water.
Please don't
start the interview with "So, do you have any questions for me?" I personally like to be asked weird questions ("What kind of cell are you?") and questions about my application. I don't like to be asked what other programs I'm considering because it makes me feel like I have to justify having applied to places other than the place I'm interviewing that day.
What do you like to see on the tour?
It depends on how the hospital is laid out. If things are compact, I like to see everything (cafeteria, outpatient clinic, PACU, holding area, call rooms, resident lounge). Schlepping, however, is not fun, especially in suits and dress shoes (even if they are "comfortable" dress shoes). Operating rooms are optional for me. If you have pictures of the OR during the orientation talk, and offer an optional OR tour at the end of the day, I think that would suffice. (No more bunny suits!)
Who do you like to meet? Necessary to meet chair, PD, lots of residents?
Short answer: As many people as possible.
Long answer: I like to see the chair and the PD because it gives the impression that they care about the new residents coming into the program. I like to see female and minority faculty and residents because it makes me think the program is diverse and is interested in staying that way. I like to see residents because it implies that residents are relieved for what the program considers to be important activities. I also observe on the tour how the residents interact with staff (smiles? frowns?) which gives me some idea of how they are received in the office.
Pimping is low on the list, I know.
Not necessarily, as long as it's not done with malice. It's kind of cool to learn something during your interview. And I think it's entirely reasonable to be pimped about something related to your application. I do not, however, think that pimping has a role in short interviews (<20 minutes), when it seems that the interviewer is more interested in weeding you out than in getting to know you.
And a free hotel and airfare would be nice but unrealistic given our budget.
If you can consider at least partial reimbursement, that would help a lot. One program I applied to only offered a hotel stay to people >50 miles away, and no one I applied to offered airfare.
I'm trying to improve our interview days and feel we've made real strides:
tours with a resident guide (not the PD)
lunch/lecture with residents
dinner with residents
Lunch and dinner with the residents is super helpful, and can help applicants answer questions about the nuts and bolts of the program or about living in the area. People involved in admissions/selection should not go to these events, however.
Good luck, and thanks for asking!