What made you choose medicine over the other health professions?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

ms2209

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2004
Messages
524
Reaction score
3
For me, I think it was the fact that the MD leaves you with so many options in terms of choosing what you want to pursue. You can do research, you can practice, you can combine different interests...the possibilities seem endless. I guess this appears to be a random thread, but I'm in the process of filling out secondaries, so I've been thinking about this a great deal lately! 😀

Members don't see this ad.
 
If i have the choice of taking orders or giving orders, I'd choose the latter.
 
prestige. all other health professionals are seen as inferior to a lot of people and are cop outs for a "real" doctor.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
It sounds like you're fishing for ideas because you're running out of things to talk about in your secondaries. :laugh:

That said...I agree with you. I think doctors have the broadest options as to what sort of career they want to have.
 
ut_stephen said:
It sounds like you're fishing for ideas because you're running out of things to talk about in your secondaries. :laugh:

Ha! Yeah, I thought it sounded like an interview question, myself.
 
i appreciate being able to make the decisions.
 
I'm an athletic training student. I chose med school instead of grad school in athletic training because I never felt like I had control over my patients care and couldn't make major decisions. We have to constantly refer, and the level of care we can provide is dependent on what state you're in. The practice acts are all over the board: some states you can't do anything and and some you can do everything we were trained to do and more, with checking in with a doc every now and then. There are huge battles going on with PT's too. I've always been interested in becoming a physician but when I was young and naive, I didn't want to go to school that long. But my athletic training experience and watching the team docs has opened my eyes to what I really want. Plus I'm really interested in the surgery aspect. And I'm not gonna lie, I wanted a secure future.

I love athletic training, but I want to do more.

I hope that makes sense. I'm bad at articulating stuff. English is by FAR my worst subject.
 
im becoming a doctor cause i want to be involved in healthcare. why an md over other fields? because i can.

of course, im sure ill come up with something more creative to say at interviews.
 
ut_stephen said:
It sounds like you're fishing for ideas because you're running out of things to talk about in your secondaries. :laugh:

That said...I agree with you. I think doctors have the broadest options as to what sort of career they want to have.

:laugh: Actually, none of my secondaries have posed this question in particular. The reason I've been thinking about this is the whole process I've been going through, with applications and everything. I'm keeping my goals in mind, and I thought it might be interesting to see what others felt as they were going through this application cycle.
 
I think it is honorable to enter most health care professions. Nurses, PTs, medical technicians, etc., are the foot-soldiers of medicine and do the dirty work that keep health care running, and people (especially future physicians) ought to see them as that, rather than people who settled for an easy job because they couldnt be doctors. That said, I will be a physician because I believe they are in the position to make a real difference in the lives of their patients. Not to mention, the pay isnt bad, and I plan on being my own boss.
Now as for chiropractors? God-damn witch doctors. Same with naturalists. Sorry buddy, but St. Johns Wort is not going to cure schizophrenia.
 
SanDiegoSOD said:
Now as for chiropractors? God-damn witch doctors. Same with naturalists. Sorry buddy, but St. Johns Wort is not going to cure schizophrenia.

:laugh: :laugh:

How about dentists?
 
ut_stephen said:
It sounds like you're fishing for ideas because you're running out of things to talk about in your secondaries. :laugh:

That said...I agree with you. I think doctors have the broadest options as to what sort of career they want to have.

However, once you're specialized you are effectively locked in unless you want to endure several more years of training and new board certifications.
This is not so in other fields like nursing, PT, PA, NP, ATC, etc. As a PT, I have worked in every single area of my hospital.

That said, I agree with the giving/taking orders comments. That's why I'm going back. 🙂
 
For me it was the combination of 4 things. The first is the autonomy . . . I would like to not be operating under someone elses license (like PA's and most med techs that I know of). Second, is my enjoyment of science and scientific reasoning . . . nurses have a fair amount of autonomy (trust me my fiancee is an RN) and have their own licenses and can attain additional autonomy by getting an advanced degree but the nursing proffession emphasizes building an efficient system (which is also important) and medicine emphasizes scientific reasoning. Third, I feel of all the medical profesions that medicine is the only one that pays what it is worth (I think that nurses and med techs are some of the most underpaid people in the world along with teachers). Finally, I want a lot of contact with patients which is why I did not want to be a scientist (PhD) or a Pharmacist . . . both of those professions have the other things I want but both lack the patient exposure that I desire. Anyhow, I am sure everyone has their own reasons but those are mine.
 
ms2209 said:
:laugh: :laugh:

How about dentists?

I have respect for dentists, but I dont want to be one. They offer a necessary service that people pay for in cash - no b.s. with HMOs or other 3rd party payers. Also, they only have 3 years of grad school, graduate with a degree they can use right away, work reasonable hours, and get paid a boat load of money ($200,000 is a lot for someone who repairs teeth). BUT - they have few options (can only work in the mouth), and have the highest suicide rate as a proffesion in the U.S. I consider dentistry from time to time, only to shoot the idea down.
 
Money. Power. Prestige.
 
I take it you're not considering Veterinary Medicine as a health profession but that was what I thought I wanted to do for a long time. I chose Medicine for several reasons, but just in terms of comparing the professions, working in Veterinary Medicine can be very disheartening. The law offers very little protection for animals. When a pediatrician suspects that a patient is being abused or neglected, he or she is legally required to report it, and a social worker comes in to evaluate the child and talk to the parents. When veterinarians see signs of abuse or neglect, they usually keep quiet because they know that the courts will do nothing and they will lose this client and many others. As a consequence, you spend a lot of time taking care of animals that have been obviously mistreated, and when you send them home you know that it's not going to get any better and there's nothing you can do about it. Also, veterinary medicine is controlled much more by economics. As a person, if you go to an ER, the staff is required to treat you, whether or not you can pay for it. If parents cannot afford simple, necessary treatment for a child, there is always a way for the child to be treated. However, if you can't pay or don't want to pay $100 for IV's to rehydrate your sick puppy, you can always pay the vet $15 to euthanize him instead. Finally, there's so much you can't do for your patients if you're a vet. The technology is moving forward, but it's not available or practical for the majority of pet owners. So many pet owners are forced to give up on their pets because of conditions that would be treatable in humans.

I realize that human medicine has its limitations, but they are not as restrictive as those of veterinary medicine. People generally want to live and be healthy, and in this respect physicians work with their patients rather than against them.
 
SanDiegoSOD said:
I have respect for dentists, but I dont want to be one. They offer a necessary service that people pay for in cash - no b.s. with HMOs or other 3rd party payers. Also, they only have 3 years of grad school, graduate with a degree they can use right away, work reasonable hours, and get paid a boat load of money ($200,000 is a lot for someone who repairs teeth). BUT - they have few options (can only work in the mouth), and have the highest suicide rate as a proffesion in the U.S. I consider dentistry from time to time, only to shoot the idea down.

Two minor corrections, cuz I am anal and don't want peeps to get the wrong idea. 1) Other than Univ. of Pacific, which squeezes 4 years of schooling into 3 (short breaks), dental school is likewise 4 years. 2) The suicide rate thing is an urban myth perpetuated by some aberrant study, and is repeatedly shot down on threads here.

I have to say that dentistry is likewise tempting to me, for the autonomy and instant gratification, but not sure I would love it long term.
 
samurai_lincoln said:
Two minor corrections, cuz I am anal and don't want peeps to get the wrong idea. 1) Other than Univ. of Pacific, which squeezes 4 years of schooling into 3 (short breaks), dental school is likewise 4 years. 2) The suicide rate thing is an urban myth perpetuated by some aberrant study, and is repeatedly shot down on threads here.

I have to say that dentistry is likewise tempting to me, for the autonomy and instant gratification, but not sure I would love it long term.
Thank you. All correct, and you spared me the effort of doing it myself. 😀
 
SanDiegoSOD said:
I have respect for dentists, but I dont want to be one. They offer a necessary service that people pay for in cash - no b.s. with HMOs or other 3rd party payers. Also, they only have 3 years of grad school, graduate with a degree they can use right away, work reasonable hours, and get paid a boat load of money ($200,000 is a lot for someone who repairs teeth). BUT - they have few options (can only work in the mouth), and have the highest suicide rate as a proffesion in the U.S. I consider dentistry from time to time, only to shoot the idea down.
"repair teeth"? A lot of people would say $150,000 a year is a lot for a PCP, who spends a typical day writing Motrin scripts and referral slips.

Of course, that'd also be grossly oversimplified and completely inaccurate...not unlike your description of dentistry here. 😉
 
Being a doctor enables you to offer medical help on a personal basis
 
Top