What’s Practicing in AZ vs FL like?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Where would you rather practice psychiatry?

  • Arizona

    Votes: 11 78.6%
  • Florida

    Votes: 3 21.4%

  • Total voters
    14

TerraceHouse

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2017
Messages
68
Reaction score
49
I live in a colder climate and now that spring is bringing warmer weather I’m thinking of just moving the family somewhere warm all year round but I know it comes w the summer that’s more brutal. Wondering for psychiatrists if they’ve ever practiced in either AZ or FL and which state one prefers between the two.

PS can we leave politics out of this one? Truly asking about the weather, psychiatry culture, etc
 
Desert dry heat > humidity and mosquitoes
True, and for the 3-6 summer months agree that the dry heat is way more tolerable. Conversely, the one word I’d use to describe Arizona is “brown”. I had family in the Tempe/Mesa suburbs of Phoenix and it’s probably the most bland and drab place I've ever been, even with the mountains.
 
AZ or NM gave more open prescribing to Psychologists. Forgot which one.

FL has no income tax?
AZ has access to Rocky Mountains a drive away? And beach in CA?
FL has hills in the state of GA.
 
Malpractice: If not working for the government, Florida is a much less friendly state from a legal perspective compared to Arizona.

Arizona is more desert, fewer allergies, and dry skin.

Florida is beaches, minor league baseball, theme parks, humidity, hurricanes, and mosquitos.

Florida is an older population with more Medicare and higher homeless population.

Florida has “Florida Man” but Arizona has a much higher violent crime rate and is adjacent to some of the states with the highest crime rates.
 
If you have kids, Florida has a surprising amount of funding for education. Pre-school is covered for 4 year olds, you get a voucher that you can take to any school that accepts it (which is the vast majority). For K-12, if you send your kids to private school, you get about 8k/kid/year (up to double that for kids with specific disabilities) to offset the cost. Dual-enrollment at University of Florida is free for any public high school student in Florida. If you're a semi-decent student, you can get a full ride to any public Florida university (it's a GPA of 3.5 and ACT of 29) or a 75% ride (3.0 and 25). All in all, I'm not sure there's any other state with that amount of money that an individual student can get for education.

Not sure that's reflected in how educated the populace is though...
 
All in all, I'm not sure there's any other state with that amount of money that an individual student can get for education.

Not sure that's reflected in how educated the populace is though...

New Mexico has instituted free college for residents. Most qualify. That said, NM has the highest violent crime rate, and intelligent people often leave the state.
 
Just got back from a trip to Arizona and I loved it. Growing tired of Midwest winters but how bad is the heat to deal with?
 
It’s hot. But the dry heat does make a big difference, cliche aside. Mostly, summers are long - 100’s from mid-May through mid-September, sometimes later. But shaded areas are bearable even during the hottest hours - nothing a swimming pool and a beer/margarita doesn’t fix. Visit mid-July to get a real sense of it.

The heat is relevant to Phoenix, Tucson and the southwestern part of the state. Prescott north is much more temperate.
 
It’s hot. But the dry heat does make a big difference, cliche aside. Mostly, summers are long - 100’s from mid-May through mid-September, sometimes later. But shaded areas are bearable even during the hottest hours - nothing a swimming pool and a beer/margarita doesn’t fix. Visit mid-July to get a real sense of it.

The heat is relevant to Phoenix, Tucson and the southwestern part of the state. Prescott north is much more temperate.
I think I would actually like it but my husband and kids love winter so it would be a hard sell for my family. Good to know it’s a good market for psychiatry.
 
I think I would actually like it but my husband and kids love winter so it would be a hard sell for my family. Good to know it’s a good market for psychiatry.
I mean Prescott and Flagstaff are about 2 hours from Phoenix and there's usually snow in the winter there. Sedona is one of my favorite places to hike and camp!
 
I have resident friends that work in both.
Florida - older pop in general, no state income tax, probably the best state to live in right now. Performing well. Just gave money back to fed govt. Hurricanes, humidity,
Arizona - dry heat, more diverse, might need to speak Spanish depending where you live.
 
One thing about Florida: it really matters what part of Florida you’re talking about.

North Florida/Panhandle: basically feels like the Deep South. Pensacola, for instance, feels like Alabama. Deep red politics, things are not especially expensive vs the rest of Florida, poverty, rural, Medicaid, etc etc. “Southern” way of life and beliefs dominate. On the other hand, if you want a beachfront house, it’s fairly attainable.

South Florida: hotter; more elderly population, and definitely more affluent; politics get much more blue the closer you get to Miami and other bigger cities. Bigger cities in south Florida are incredibly diverse (esp Miami), which is definitely not the case in the rest of the state. Things are a lot more expensive. When most people think “Florida”, south Florida is what they’re thinking of.

“Florida man”, alligators, hurricanes, etc etc are phenomenons throughout the state. Florida is a weird place. I have in-laws in the panhandle, and “weird people doing weird stuff” is just a recurring theme whenever I visit. (I was once in a drive thru line at a Whataburger, and all six people in the van in front of us just got out together and peed on the sidewalk randomly. Stuff like that is not at all unusual.) While there may be more violent crime by demographic data in places like AZ, I assure you that FL is not far behind in that regard.

Also, Florida is relatively oversaturated with doctors (and some would say, with people in general esp since the pandemic where the population increased by 1/5 or something). Florida is one of the states where it takes longer to get a medical license. AZ is very easy in comparison.

The people who live in Florida seem to really like it, but it’s not for everyone. It’s not a place I’d personally choose to live. But ymmv.
 
Last edited:
I mean Prescott and Flagstaff are about 2 hours from Phoenix and there's usually snow in the winter there. Sedona is one of my favorite places to hike and camp!
Just was in Sedona and flagstaff and loved them both. Flagstaff home prices were very high. I’m guessing home prices went up during Covid.
 
What are inpatient jobs in Tucson like?
Similar to elsewhere in terms of expectations and compensation. Pretty easy to find a position. Four major inpatient facilities and 2 or 3 smaller ones. AHCCCS (AZ Medicaid) recipients for mental health services have to be seen at one of the community mental health centers and they (CMHCs) are always short of psychiatrists.
 
Florida has a 6 week abortion ban if that matters to you. This is a deal breaker for me personally and professionally.
 
If you love the beach and sun and beautiful oceans, Florida is definitely for you
 
Top