What's your number?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
depends on what specialty i choose (or am forced) to go into


ER docs save plenty more lives than 50 in their career
 
0 and 0.

Pathology FTW.
 
At this point most of my classmates have adjusted their expectations. We are just hoping not to harm anybody. If you subtract the people we didn't help from the ones we did and the number comes up positive then I am happy.
 
At this point most of my classmates have adjusted their expectations. We are just hoping not to harm anybody. If you subtract the people we didn't help from the ones we did and the number comes up positive then I am happy.

After talking with a couple medical students this is the feeling I got. I think to many people watch House and think that they will be saving the world.
 
Speaking of House whats with the random "soap" direction its taking.. now its random obscure diseases for 10% of the show and then the rest is soap stuff.. thats not how they got so many viewers!!!!!!
 
at least it's better than last season

i just got started on Greys Anatomy...on the surface it looks like a stupid medical drama but after watching it for 4 hours i know it's a stupid drama (that has some occasional entertainment value)
 
Number of lives you want to save in your career as a doctor.

I want to save about 50 - 60 I think... And then maybe heal another 200 - 300 people.

Do numbers really matter that much? You do what you can do, and don't try to do what you can't do; in the end, that's all that matters. Hopefully, in the process, you'll come out on top, but there will be many times when you don't.
 
Or maybe just naive?

Thats not much of a troll post.. no need to call every bad post a troll =p
 
At this point most of my classmates have adjusted their expectations. We are just hoping not to harm anybody. If you subtract the people we didn't help from the ones we did and the number comes up positive then I am happy.

That's a good way of looking at it.

And I was just curious what the number would be. I haven't seen much scientific research on the topic.
 
I heard somewhere that General Eisenhower saved the most people in terms of health service by demanding the Japanese Constitution to guarantee health care to all it's citizens.

You're not going to save the most lives by being a doctor. 👍
 
the world

make it a better place
for u and for me and the entire human race 🙂
 
I won't be satisfied until I have saved at least 500 people's lives. Bare minimum.
 
Im just hoping to shoot over par in med school/internship
 
In my view, the goal of medicine (at least today) is not simply to save lives, but to make miserable ones better.
 
0 and 0.

Pathology FTW.

Fail. Pathologist play just as big of a roll in the treatment and saving of lives as any other doctor.

As it is, if you go into medicine thinking about "saving lives" you will lose, every time. Everyone eventually dies and there will be a time when there is nothing you, as a doc, can do about it. The goal, in my opinion, is to help better the lives of those who are here. Yes, resuscitation is part of that, but by all means, not all encompassing. Providing patients with what they need to help themselves lead better lives is the our job. But that's just my $0.02.
 
Not if say, you identify the COD as something is, say a public health risk. Once you ID it, then you can warn the appropriate authorities who take precautions and bam, you've saved lives. Even as a forensic pathologist.
 
This is getting surprisingly cantankerous.

"You will save lives as a doctor!"
"No, I won't. You can't make me!"
"By god, boy, I'll make you if it's the last thing I do!"
(Homer starts choking a white-coated Bart.)

Wait... How did that turn into a weird episode of the Simpsons?
 
Okay I may have phrased my original question a bit non-serious. But good answers for the most part anyways.
 
This is getting surprisingly cantankerous.

"You will save lives as a doctor!"
"No, I won't. You can't make me!"
"By god, boy, I'll make you if it's the last thing I do!"
(Homer starts choking a white-coated Bart.)

Wait... How did that turn into a weird episode of the Simpsons?

Meh, I was just trying to save someone else the butt-chewing I got for saying "I want to save lives," when I was a younger, more naïve, pre-med. That's all.
 
Some day i want to be an interviewer for medschool and ask people absurd questions like this
 
50-60? Depending on what you do you could be done w/ that in a month
 
so are you a holy pally or resto (op)
 
I don't care how many people i "save". I'm just hoping that I don't (severely) hurt someone while I'm still learning wtf I'm doing
 
Some day i want to be an interviewer for medschool and ask people absurd questions like this

And who would you admit if you had to admit based solely on the answer to this absurd question? The "As long as I do more good than harm" or "I plan to save 9,000"?
 
Become an army doc so you can balance that kill/save ratio, pretty sure you at least get a sidearm
 
This thread is dumb.

Who honestly has a goal for how many lives they want to save or how many they want to heal?

Just do your job and what you can for what comes your way.

Cya.
 
You wouldn't be able to count accurately at all. How will you tell what would have happened without treatment? Does giving a vaccine save someone's life? That kid might have caught meningitis and died, or they might not have. You'll never know. And really, was it you saving the life, or was it the researchers that developed and tested the vaccine? The nurse that administered it? The parent that signed the consent form? The PSA that told them to vaccinate?

Most of medicine is not pulling people back from the brink of death. Even in the ER. And you are never working alone. You are working with a huge team. So say you you have a patient with chest pain so you order an EKG and the EKG tech does the test and you interpret it you ask the nurse to draw troponins and the nurse draws the troponins and the lab tech runs the test and the pathologist interprets it and comes back positive and you send to the cath lab and the cath lab doc does a cath and the cath lab techs run the imaging machines and pull out the catheter and the post op nurses recover the patient and their wife stops them from getting out of bed and bleeding out afterward. Who really saved the life there? Even in my simplified scenario you can really only say you saved 1/10 of a life. And who knows whether it will give the patient another 30 years or if they will get hit by a bus tomorrow when they walk out the door, and if you hadn't cathed them they would have left at a different time? No one knows that kind of thing. No point counting, just do your job.

And I worked four years in a hospital, attended daily codes, and never saw a doctor do compressions. It was always nurses or RT's, because they would get there first. So you will probably not be doing much actual literal lifesaving either.

And really I hope you "heal" more than 300 people in your career. That's like ten a year.
 
Okay, I have heard what you all said and am therefore raising my goal from 500 lives saved to 750.


Maybe 800.
 
Sarcasm's a rare thing among pre-meds. This thread is meant to evoke tears, not laughter
 
Number of lives you want to save in your career as a doctor.

I want to save about 50 - 60 I think... And then maybe heal another 200 - 300 people.

All of them. A specific number implies a percent failure rate - which is unacceptable.

They will die. When they do, at your earliest convenience, cry. Then you save the next 10. In your career, 50 is a tiny number. There will be thousands.
 
Top