why is it so hard to get into dermatology?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
titanlord1

titanlord1

Membership Revoked
Removed
10+ Year Member
Joined
May 15, 2013
Messages
125
Reaction score
3
i know that its difficult but my question is how/why is it so difficult. i know many people want to get into it ( which makes it difficult) but why is there such a drive to enter dermatology?
Members don't see this ad.
 
titanlord1 said:
i know that its difficult but my question is how/why is it so difficult. i know many people want to get into it ( which makes it difficult) but why is there such a drive to enter dermatology?
Click to expand...

1) Completely outpatient based specialty
2) Ability to go into private practice and set your own hours -- see #1
3) Patients are relatively healthy
4) Patients are thankful for curing their skin problem vs. managing their HTN/DM2
5) Ability to sub-specialize or do it all: pathology, surgery, cosmetics, pediatrics, adult patients
6) Predictable family time in the evenings, not typically interrupted by emergencies.
7) Action-oriented - biopsy, cryo, laser, etc. to solve a patient's problem.
8) High autonomy, you do everything, none of this "team-based" care/PCMH stuff.
 
Last edited:
Members don't see this ad :)
DermViser said:
1) Completely outpatient based specialty
2) Ability to go into private practice and set your own hours -- see #1
3) Patients are relatively healthy
4) Patients are thankful for curing their skin problem vs. treating their HTN/DM2
5) Ability to sub-specialize or do it all: pathology, surgery, cosmetics, pediatrics, adult patients
6) Predictable family time in the evenings not typically interrupted by emergencies.
7) Action-oriented - biopsy, cryo, laser, etc.
Click to expand...

2 and 6 only above really apply. + money
 
Medicine is an altruistic-driven profession, there lies the competition to get into a derm residency. I would like to see the personal statement of these derm residents when they were applying to med school.
 
BestDoctorEver said:
Medicine is an altruistic-driven profession, there lies the competition to get into a derm residency. I would like to see the personal statement of these derm residents when they were applying to med school.
Click to expand...

I'd like to see their personal statements for the match. Mainly to see what I have to write to get an interview.
 
One reason people forgot: someone has a chokehold on the number of residency spots, just like in plastics. And then the chair of dermatology tells us we have a shortage of dermatologists, with their favorite extrapolated AAMC data.
 
BestDoctorEver said:
Medicine is an altruistic-driven profession, there lies the competition to get into a derm residency. I would like to see the personal statement of these derm residents when they were applying to med school.
Click to expand...

You do know a personal statement for medical school is on medicine as a profession, not a specific specialty, right?
 
BurghStudent said:
One reason people forgot: someone has a chokehold on the number of residency spots, just like in plastics. And then the chair of dermatology tells us we have a shortage of dermatologists, with their favorite extrapolated AAMC data.
Click to expand...

That someone is hospital administrators who are less likely to fund a derm spot (which is non-hospital based) vs. an inpatient hospital: IM, Ortho, etc.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
DermViser said:
1) Completely outpatient based specialty
2) Ability to go into private practice and set your own hours -- see #1
3) Patients are relatively healthy
4) Patients are thankful for curing their skin problem vs. managing their HTN/DM2
5) Ability to sub-specialize or do it all: pathology, surgery, cosmetics, pediatrics, adult patients
6) Predictable family time in the evenings, not typically interrupted by emergencies.
7) Action-oriented - biopsy, cryo, laser, etc. to solve a patient's problem.
Click to expand...

8) No-show patients are rare
9) For most conditions, results are immediate or fairly quick
10) Patients tend to be fairly compliant with medications and treatment plans
 
Last edited:
DermViser said:
You do know a personal statement for medical school is on medicine as a profession, not a specific specialty, right?
Click to expand...
I just went thru the process, but that did not stop me from tilting my PS theme toward primary care specialties. After hearing so many drawbacks about being a PCP, it's becoming less and less appealing to me... Now let me get off my high horse and raise my Step1 target score to 240+... Lol
 
BestDoctorEver said:
Medicine is an altruistic-driven profession, there lies the competition to get into a derm residency. I would like to see the personal statement of these derm residents when they were applying to med school.
Click to expand...

I never understood the urge to feign interest in primary care in your personal statement. Seems risky to me, bc it's so easy to come across as insincere, cliche, or both.

Also, there's a million ways to express a mature, level-headed interest in the medical profession without pandering to the admission committee's primary care docs.
 
Derm daily routine: take byopsy & send to pathology. Rinse and repeat.





(relaximonlykidding)
 
I think many folks enjoy how tangible disease and treatment results are. What you see is what you treat and you can see it/feel it with your senses vs. having to trend labs and believe you are being a good doctor when you CHF pts BNP comes down 100 points. Derm is similar to surgery in my opinion with obviously less cutting and less demanding hours, its for folks who like to physically sense the product of their work. Unfortunately, because Derm is so competitive, those who get in are often pretty pompous and constantly feel like they need to "prove the worth of Derm" similar to Derm Viser. Relax man, you made it, you are going to make good money working decent hours, go enjoy some of that cash and time not in front of a computer screen bickering about what derm does or doesn't have
 
BarcaBest23 said:
I think many folks enjoy how tangible disease and treatment results are. What you see is what you treat and you can see it/feel it with your senses vs. having to trend labs and believe you are being a good doctor when you CHF pts BNP comes down 100 points. Derm is similar to surgery in my opinion with obviously less cutting and less demanding hours, its for folks who like to physically sense the product of their work. Unfortunately, because Derm is so competitive, those who get in are often pretty pompous and constantly feel like they need to "prove the worth of Derm" similar to Derm Viser. Relax man, you made it, you are going to make good money working decent hours, go enjoy some of that cash and time not in front of a computer screen bickering about what derm does or doesn't have
Click to expand...
well said brother.
 
BarcaBest23 said:
I think many folks enjoy how tangible disease and treatment results are. What you see is what you treat and you can see it/feel it with your senses vs. having to trend labs and believe you are being a good doctor when you CHF pts BNP comes down 100 points. Derm is similar to surgery in my opinion with obviously less cutting and less demanding hours, its for folks who like to physically sense the product of their work. Unfortunately, because Derm is so competitive, those who get in are often pretty pompous and constantly feel like they need to "prove the worth of Derm" similar to Derm Viser. Relax man, you made it, you are going to make good money working decent hours, go enjoy some of that cash and time not in front of a computer screen bickering about what derm does or doesn't have
Click to expand...

I don't feel the need to "prove the worth" of Derm. Pt demand for derm services and happiness for those services speaks for itself. Those who reflexively put down Derm, are displaying their own insecurities.
 
Last edited:
BarcaBest23 said:
Unfortunately, because Derm is so competitive, those who get in are often pretty pompous and constantly feel like they need to "prove the worth of Derm" similar to Derm Viser. Relax man, you made it, you are going to make good money working decent hours, go enjoy some of that cash and time not in front of a computer screen bickering about what derm does or doesn't have
Click to expand...

I haven't really worked with any dermatologists in real life, so I can't comment on that. But if you're referring to people doing this on SDN, I can understand why. Think about it: every time derm is brought up, people attack those who pick that field as being un-altruistic and motivated primarily by money/cush hours. Look at this thread, for example. Repeat these kinds of posts ad nauseum and you can see why some people might get defensive. They're forced to defend their choice because of how commonly they're attacked. And then, we bitch at them about them feeling like they "need to prove the worth of derm." 🙄

Dermviser gave a pretty reasonable list of reasons why people might choose derm and the next poster quoted it and subtracted everything except cush hours and money. If I was going into derm, I'd be kinda annoyed about that too. Is it any wonder why they get defensive, considering we keep giving them so much flak for it?
 
I agree.

I've worked with some fantastic dermatologists who are very intelligent and care about their patients.

I think the internet makes them easy targets ($/lifestyle). But let's be honest, those are great things to have.

Saying they aren't contributing to healthcare is a bad argument though. Each physician does what they can.

I don't see everyone going into general surgery because they want to help people so desperately.
 
@JackShephard said:
I don't get it, why is that funny?
Click to expand...

Double-alaskan-rainbow.jpg
 
@JackShephard said:
I still don't get it.

Everyone is making a contribution and most everyone is doing the best they can.
Click to expand...
I guess you have more confidence in our future colleagues than I do. I think you are being ridiculously optimistic about the competence of many physicians.
 
JP2740 said:
I guess you have more confidence in our future colleagues than I do. I think you are being ridiculously optimistic about the competence of many physicians.
Click to expand...

Well, fair enough. I have a lot of faith in our colleagues. I lack the same optimism in our government.

The vast majority of physicians I've worked with have been hard working and competent.
 
JP2740 said:
I guess you have more confidence in our future colleagues than I do. I think you are being ridiculously optimistic about the competence of many physicians.
Click to expand...

While I may not have confidence in my future colleagues (as in my med school classmates) yet, I trust that residency training will make them into serviceable physicians.
 
DermViser said:
I don't feel the need to "prove the worth" of Derm. Pt demand for services and happiness for those services speaks for itself. Those who put down Derm, are displaying their own insecurities.
Click to expand...

What does it speak to... patient vanity?
 
krafty934 said:
Dermviser gave a pretty reasonable list of reasons why people might choose derm and the next poster quoted it and subtracted everything except cush hours and money. If I was going into derm, I'd be kinda annoyed about that too. Is it any wonder why they get defensive, considering we keep giving them so much flak for it?
Click to expand...

If you took out the good work hours, derm would be about as competitive as surgery. If you took out the good money it would be as competitive as PM&R. Derm is not popular because it is derm. It is popular because it pays well for relatively little work. There's not necessarily anything wrong with that (other than needing to sell your soul). but let's call a spade a spade. Skin is not very interesting... but $450,000 for 40 hours a week makes it interesting...
 
Instatewaiter said:
If you took out the good work hours, derm would be about as competitive as surgery. If you took out the good money it would be as competitive as PM&R.
Click to expand...

And if my aunt had balls, she'd be my uncle.

You've made it abundantly clear that you have disdain for dermatologists. You posted that scrubs clip several times as well, I believe.

You're the kind of person others are referring to when they talk about specialties trying to cut other specialties down, instead of trying to improve the entire profession as a whole. Grow up.
 
Instatewaiter said:
If you took out the good work hours, derm would be about as competitive as surgery. If you took out the good money it would be as competitive as PM&R. Derm is not popular because it is derm. It is popular because it pays well for relatively little work. There's not necessarily anything wrong with that (other than needing to sell your soul). but let's call a spade a spade. Skin is not very interesting... but $450,000 for 40 hours a week makes it interesting...
Click to expand...

The average dermatologist doesn't make $450,000 except maybe the ones in NY or LA that are doing cosmetic (cash only) practices. In Derm, we actually CURE many of the things our patients come to see us for and our patients are overall quite happy that we are able to do so, in which the results are visible, unlike say IM and its subspecialties. If you're a visually oriented type of person, then skin disease is very interesting. We get it, you're angry that the rest of us don't have as bad work hours as Cardiology, even though you're in one of the highest subspecialty salaries in IM, besides GI or Heme-Onc. Just goes to show that salary doesn't lead to happiness. You have to enjoy the material.
 
BestDoctorEver said:
Medicine is an altruistic-driven profession, there lies the competition to get into a derm residency. I would like to see the personal statement of these derm residents when they were applying to med school.
Click to expand...
I've trolled on derm before, but truthfully derm is an extremely important specialty for those that need it. You'll realize this very quickly the first time you or a loved one has a mole that's gone wonky and you can't get an appointment with a dermatologist for 4 months, an event you will likely experience or have someone close to you experience in their lifetime. Aside from the deadly stuff, derm deals with a lot of disfiguring and unsightly conditions that can significantly impact a patient's quality of life. Medicine isn't just about saving lives, it is (ideally) about improving our patient's lives through medical intervention, thus making them more worth living in the first place.
 
GuyWhoDoesStuff said:
And if my aunt had balls, she'd be my uncle.

You've made it abundantly clear that you have disdain for dermatologists. You posted that scrubs clip several times as well, I believe.

You're the kind of person others are referring to when they talk about specialties trying to cut other specialties down, instead of trying to improve the entire profession as a whole. Grow up.
Click to expand...

I believe part of that stems from hating the specialty he's chosen - due to the ridiculous hours at expense of sleep, etc. That being said Cards is very well compensated (the other being GI), so something tells me he regrets using that as his barometer for his specialty choice.
 
Last edited:
I'll never understand why derm alone elicits this "oh, must've done it for the money HUR DUR" response from most med students, and worst of all, practicing physicians.

If someone chooses cardiology (Medscape average = $357k/yr), it's obviously because they love the heart pathology. Someone choosing ortho (Medscape average = $401k/yr <--the highest paid specialty on the list), those osteochondromas must've really spoken to them, huh?

But if someone chooses derm (Medscape average = $305k/yr, behind ortho, cardio, GI, uro, and radiology), it's probably SOLELY because of the money. I just don't get it. If you distill every specialty down to its worst elements, they all sound ****ty. Why derm suffers this more than anyone else is beyond me.

Instate, what's the matter? You didn't like ID or rheum? Throwing stents in fatties all day was your true calling? Probably had nothing to do with the hefty salary and the relative level of "prestige" afforded cardiologists both within and outside medicine, did it?

See? I can generalize too. 😉
 
Every field should be like derm, I don't know why there's so much hate. Props to them for keeping a good wage with reasonable hours.
 
Instatewaiter said:
If you took out the good work hours, derm would be about as competitive as surgery. If you took out the good money it would be as competitive as PM&R. Derm is not popular because it is derm. It is popular because it pays well for relatively little work. There's not necessarily anything wrong with that (other than needing to sell your soul). but let's call a spade a spade. Skin is not very interesting... but $450,000 for 40 hours a week makes it interesting...
Click to expand...

I find it hilarious that a so-called cards-fellow has so much free-time to come on to sdn to bash derm for not being "real docs".
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

C
Why is the NBME test taking software so ****ty?
Replies
2
Views
449
voxveritatisetlucis
V
T
MD & DO Why is neurology residency considered so tough?
Replies
9
Views
2K
mrbreakfast
M
M
Dermatology Match
Replies
8
Views
1K
Dral
Dral
T
Why is USMLE S3 scored if all we need to do is pass?
Replies
3
Views
759
TakotsuboOkazaki
TakotsuboOkazaki
D
What is the future of Dermatology?
Replies
12
Views
4K
voxveritatisetlucis
V
Top