- Joined
- Nov 22, 2002
- Messages
- 13
- Reaction score
- 0
goodeats said:I'd say just give it more time. I know I started freaking out a little when I hit a big lull between my first wave of invites (first week in Aug) and the second wave (first week in Oct).
MoosePilot said:No, you'll be one of those "neurotic applicants" with fewer interviews than desired at an early stage in the process.
There's no telling, yet. Give it time. Some of the schools I've got the best shot at don't even start moving until later, so no interviews from them this early, no matter how much they like me. Same may be true for you.
Wahina said:That's true too, you need to look at each school individually. Are the schools you applied to already offering interviews to other people or have they just not started interviewing yet?
Dr.PK said:This is my first post or maybe my second post. I'm not sure -- I may have written a post a while ago. So...I realize it is still fairly early in this med school admissions game, but I am starting to become a bit worried about my number of interviews. I've applied to 8 schools (I know that is not a crazy amount like a lot of people, but in all honesty should be plenty). The schools are Jeff, Penn, Sinai, Einstein, NYU, Columbia, Cornell, and Yale. I know these schools are skewed toward the more competitive institutions, but I felt fairly confident (not cocky -- there is a difference) about my chances. I have been complete at most schools since the last week of August. I have received one interview invite from Cornell, but the silence from every other school is becoming unnerving.
Why, you may ask, is this bothering me? Well, let me give you my profile. I am a non-traditional applicant (I'm 26 now so I'm not that 'non-traditional'). I went to a respectable liberal arts college (not incredibly prestigious, but top 50 USNews -as if that means anything - but you know what I'm saying). I then took a year off and worked in a crappy job for a year before starting my post-bac. I completed it in one year with a 4.0 GPA. My BCPM GPA is 3.87, which I would think is fairly competitive. My MCAT is 10/13/13 S, which I would also think is fairly competitive. After my post-bac, I spent 1 1/2 years working in an Ivy league research lab where I contributed to 2 publications and traveled to a national research conference where I gave an oral presentation. I now live in Europe where I work as an associate scientist for a major pharmaceutical company. I have 2+ years volunteer work, shadowing, leadership roles, involvement in the community, etc.... I even sing in the resident chorus for a major international orchestra.
I really want to communicate strongly that I am not writing this to brag. I simply want to show that I think I am a strong candidate for med school. Please don't berate me as a egotistical and arrogant a$$hole, because I truly am not.
At any rate, why why why have I only gotten one interview??? I am so excited that I got an interview at Cornell...it is probably my top choice, but as everyone knows, an interview doesn't mean acceptance. Compared to Cornell, a lot of the other schools to which I have applied are less competitive. Why haven't I heard from Jeff or Sinai or Einstein? Am I overreacting? Should I just be more patient? Does anyone see any glaring weaknesses in my application?
Any help would be appreciated...
airflare said:I'm pretty sure Columbia, Cornell, and Yale have been interviewing. And according to one of the posters, Penn is at least starting to interview. When was the OP complete at those schools?
I also get the feeling that no one has heard from NYU.
Dr.PK said:This is my first post or maybe my second post. I'm not sure -- I may have written a post a while ago. So...I realize it is still fairly early in this med school admissions game, but I am starting to become a bit worried about my number of interviews. I've applied to 8 schools (I know that is not a crazy amount like a lot of people, but in all honesty should be plenty). The schools are Jeff, Penn, Sinai, Einstein, NYU, Columbia, Cornell, and Yale. I know these schools are skewed toward the more competitive institutions, but I felt fairly confident (not cocky -- there is a difference) about my chances. I have been complete at most schools since the last week of August. I have received one interview invite from Cornell, but the silence from every other school is becoming unnerving.
Why, you may ask, is this bothering me? Well, let me give you my profile. I am a non-traditional applicant (I'm 26 now so I'm not that 'non-traditional'). I went to a respectable liberal arts college (not incredibly prestigious, but top 50 USNews -as if that means anything - but you know what I'm saying). I then took a year off and worked in a crappy job for a year before starting my post-bac. I completed it in one year with a 4.0 GPA. My BCPM GPA is 3.87, which I would think is fairly competitive. My MCAT is 10/13/13 S, which I would also think is fairly competitive. After my post-bac, I spent 1 1/2 years working in an Ivy league research lab where I contributed to 2 publications and traveled to a national research conference where I gave an oral presentation. I now live in Europe where I work as an associate scientist for a major pharmaceutical company. I have 2+ years volunteer work, shadowing, leadership roles, involvement in the community, etc.... I even sing in the resident chorus for a major international orchestra.
I really want to communicate strongly that I am not writing this to brag. I simply want to show that I think I am a strong candidate for med school. Please don't berate me as a egotistical and arrogant a$$hole, because I truly am not.
At any rate, why why why have I only gotten one interview??? I am so excited that I got an interview at Cornell...it is probably my top choice, but as everyone knows, an interview doesn't mean acceptance. Compared to Cornell, a lot of the other schools to which I have applied are less competitive. Why haven't I heard from Jeff or Sinai or Einstein? Am I overreacting? Should I just be more patient? Does anyone see any glaring weaknesses in my application?
Any help would be appreciated...
dmtang said:i think you're over reacting a lot. i don't want to be mean, but there are a lot of students that come to this board who have much lower stats, GPA, and MCAT than you, but aren't complaining.
i think those are the real students who really need to hear the encouragment and support.
but just to give you confidence, you have an above avg mcat. your gpa is very high. if you applied to more than 15 schools, you have more than a 96% chance of going to medical school.
Dr.PK said:Does anyone see any glaring weaknesses in my application?
Dr.PK said:So, how exactly do you call the dean of admissions? Do you just call and ask to speak to her or him? Is this a good idea after already having sent an email describing my situation?
no, don't call after already writing an e-mail. You're making the assumption that you WILL be interviewed. While your atats are really great, never come across as if you expect an interview. If you don't want to fly to the states more often, postpone your first interview until you hear from others. Anyway you waste plenty of money thru the app process, so expect it...and this enables you to see your wife/gf (sorry i forgot who it was) more often and i'd look at that as a real positive. Best of luck!Dr.PK said:Thanks again for all the replies...
I have sent emails to the other medical schools describing my travel situation and very politely asking if it would be possible to schedule an interview while I was in town (paraphrase obviously). I got a response back from one that simply read "We'll keep you in mind." What does that mean? Another wrote that if I would be called for an interview, they would schedule it for a time convenient to both me and X medical school. The other ones haven't replied.
So, how exactly do you call the dean of admissions? Do you just call and ask to speak to her or him? Is this a good idea after already having sent an email describing my situation?
efex101 said:Not to be a pessimist or trying to rain on your parade but I think that you might have applied to too few schools. Schools gets THOUSANDS of applications with many applicants having stellar stats just like yours so they DO have a good number to choose from. It is never too late to add schools but if you are not applying to other schools based on your spouse work situation I understand...just do not "assume" that due to your stellar stats that you are a shoe-in because you just never know. This is why most applicants regardless of how competitive they are apply to at least 15 schools or more.
LizzyM said:Part of the problem is that there are so many good applicants and applying to more schools is not the solution, particularly if the applicant doesn't really want to attend. In the Spring, you'll see twits writing to say, "I got into Asswipe Medical College but I dont' want to go there. Should I decline and reapply in the next cycle?"
If all 24,000 applicants limited themselves to 5-10 schools that they really want to attend and where they have a prayer of being admitted (gpa within 0.2 of the school's mean, MCAT within 3 points of the school's mean) then admissions committees would have a whole lot less work to do and this whole system would be quicker and more efficient.
I must be nuts.
dmtang said:i think you're over reacting a lot. i don't want to be mean, but there are a lot of students that come to this board who have much lower stats, GPA, and MCAT than you, but aren't complaining.
i think those are the real students who really need to hear the encouragment and support.
but just to give you confidence, you have an above avg mcat. your gpa is very high. if you applied to more than 15 schools, you have more than a 96% chance of going to medical school.
compared to somenoe with a 3.5 and just say a 27, who applied to the same amount of schools, this applicant only has a 43% chance. so please, be patient.
MoosePilot said:GPA within .2 of a school's mean? I got an interview at a school where my GPA was a little over .5 from their mean. QUOTE]
Anything over the mean is fine -- but applying with a 3.15 26M to a school with a 3.6 33 average is lunacy.
Schools are inundated with thousands of applications in a relatively short time period. The people who read the applications are "volunteers" so to speak: faculty and sometimes students who do it as a "good citizenship" committee assignment (about as thankless as being on the IRB or the tenure and promotions committee). They get the applicaitons in batches and are given a week or two to read, comment and make a recommendation. The deadline for applications is October 15 but there will be applications still being read in January with invitations to interview in February! Be patient.
LizzyM said:MoosePilot said:GPA within .2 of a school's mean? I got an interview at a school where my GPA was a little over .5 from their mean. QUOTE]
Anything over the mean is fine -- but applying with a 3.15 26M to a school with a 3.6 33 average is lunacy.
Schools are inundated with thousands of applications in a relatively short time period. The people who read the applications are "volunteers" so to speak: faculty and sometimes students who do it as a "good citizenship" committee assignment (about as thankless as being on the IRB or the tenure and promotions committee). They get the applicaitons in batches and are given a week or two to read, comment and make a recommendation. The deadline for applications is October 15 but there will be applications still being read in January with invitations to interview in February! Be patient.
Dr.PK said:Thanks again for all the replies...
I have sent emails to the other medical schools describing my travel situation and very politely asking if it would be possible to schedule an interview while I was in town (paraphrase obviously). I got a response back from one that simply read "We'll keep you in mind." What does that mean? Another wrote that if I would be called for an interview, they would schedule it for a time convenient to both me and X medical school. The other ones haven't replied.
So, how exactly do you call the dean of admissions? Do you just call and ask to speak to her or him? Is this a good idea after already having sent an email describing my situation?
LizzyM said:Anything over the mean is fine -- but applying with a 3.15 26M to a school with a 3.6 33 average is lunacy.
Dr.PK said:also, who performed the meta-experiment finding a statistically significant positive correlation between the number of medical schools applied to and the chances of admission? Where could I find this report? Also, at what point does the correlation diminish? Obviously, someone who applies to 4 is better off than one who applies to 1, but is someone who applies to 40 necessarily better off than someone who applies to 20? Also, aren't there more variables including the competitiveness of the schools, the competitiveness of the applicant, etc.... I would think that a 3.9/36 would have to apply to less schools than a 3.4/30 would have to in order to have exactly the same chances of admission. This idea that keeps on reappearing about more schools = higher chance of admission just doesn't seem very well thought out. Show me the numbers and I'll believe you.
Dr.PK said:Unlike what some people on this site think, not every American medical school is a good medical school...some are sub-par...some educate their students better...some are more centered on improving the field of medicine rather than just pumping out doctors.
Dr.PK said:1) My undergrad GPA is lower than my post-bac, but it is well within the averages of these schools. 2) The three schools I am surprised about not hearing from -- especially Jefferson -- are not incredibly selective schools. I'm sorry, but I refuse to not be surprised that I haven't received an interview when my MCAT is 5.5 points higher than their average and my GPA is many 10ths of a point higher too + I'd be legacy 3) When I was deciding on the schools to which to apply I spoke to many of my profs who told me not to apply to certain schools because academically I would hate it. So, I suppose I am not one of those people who would go to any medical school.
Dr.PK said:Unlike what some people on this site think, not every American medical school is a good medical school...some are sub-par...some educate their students better...some are more centered on improving the field of medicine rather than just pumping out doctors. So, I really kind of resent the fact that everyone thinks I should have applied to medical schools that would not be a good fit for me.
Dr.PK said:I am just dumbfounded because I really don't think I could improve upon my app that much. Obviously, people who would seem to be less competitive than me (I'm sorry if that sounds pompous or whatever) have been getting interviews according to MDapplicants so I'm just wondering wtf is going on.