- Joined
- Feb 27, 2011
- Messages
- 607
- Reaction score
- 354
I personally just had a wonderful experience with army "Healthcare" that would defy the belief of a normal person but has become the sad status quo for AD and veterans.
My wife (also a physician) made an appointment to be seen at one of the small soldier family clinics on post. The NP who saw her not only was accommodating to my wife's schedule (we know what they say about the cobbler and his shoes), but also was a good clinician who handled everything like a pro. Kudos to her.
Prior to her appointment, my wife had to obtain labs within 24h. I called the lab at the clinic and asked their hours, and they told me 0700-1600. I told my wife and she re-arranged her patients and schedule to be at the lab for the draw. She arrives at the lab at 1230 to find they were closed for "training". There is only a sign hanging on the door of a shuttered lab, advising those seeking labs to go to the main hospital. The hospital is a 20 minute drive, plus going through the check point, plus parking, plus waiting in line for the labs to be drawn, then driving back. Going to main hospital would have added 60-90 minutes to this ordeal, easily. This was not feasible, as my wife had to get back to her own patients and doesn't have an hour to kill in the afternoon. Her confidence in the military healthcare system was hanging by a thread at that point, and after this it was gone completely.
Naturally, I was upset. The Army can abuse me and waste my time all it wants, but I won't accept this treatment of my family. I filed an ICE complaint and expected a response within 24h. Of course that didn't happen. I pushed it up the COC and eventually I got some traction. I got a call from the highest ranking GS employee (because there was no OIC), and he was ready to apologize to my wife for wasting her time, which was one of my ICE complaint demands. I asked why the lab was closed, especially as I had called earlier in the week to confirm the lab hours. He said that right after I called the order came down from on high to close the lab for "training", and what could he as a lowly GS employee do about that? I asked how the lab plans on pushing out information to people as hours change, and he suggested a second call to confirm my earlier confirmation call. The poor guy was trying to make things right, and that was the best he could come up with: that patient's should make a second confirmation call to confirm the first confirmation call. It was at this point that my soul broke a little bit, and I thanked him for his time and efforts, and that we as a family will simply seek healthcare elsewhere. He was upset that the Army had failed its soldiers and his family, but in the end he knew I was right: the system is broken to its core and there is nothing to do to fix it except go elsewhere.
I feel this anecdote sums up everything that is wrong about healthcare delivery in the Army. Healthcare is 24/7/365. You don't close critical ancillary services like the lab or radiology on a whim for "training". If the machine is broken/on fire/aliens have invaded then yes, there will be a delay or perhaps you need to go elsewhere. This was not the case. More likely is that whoever gave the order to close the lab, which if I had to guess would have been some O5 that doesn't even work in the clinic, is more interested in 100% SHARP compliance for their OER than actually delivering healthcare.
The inmates have taken over the asylum. Whether its keeping services open, or booking OR time, or working more people into the clinic, the emphasis is not on the patient, but rather in keep the GS employees happy and helping some desk jockey officer get promoted. Doing what is best for the patient or behaving in a way that inspires trust is far, far down the list. If this was Kaiser, or Mayo, or even Our Lady of Sorrows hospital, what do you think would happen to the head of the lab if they decided to just close down lab and turn patients away? They would be out on their butt. In the Army, that same person will probably get promoted.
My wife (also a physician) made an appointment to be seen at one of the small soldier family clinics on post. The NP who saw her not only was accommodating to my wife's schedule (we know what they say about the cobbler and his shoes), but also was a good clinician who handled everything like a pro. Kudos to her.
Prior to her appointment, my wife had to obtain labs within 24h. I called the lab at the clinic and asked their hours, and they told me 0700-1600. I told my wife and she re-arranged her patients and schedule to be at the lab for the draw. She arrives at the lab at 1230 to find they were closed for "training". There is only a sign hanging on the door of a shuttered lab, advising those seeking labs to go to the main hospital. The hospital is a 20 minute drive, plus going through the check point, plus parking, plus waiting in line for the labs to be drawn, then driving back. Going to main hospital would have added 60-90 minutes to this ordeal, easily. This was not feasible, as my wife had to get back to her own patients and doesn't have an hour to kill in the afternoon. Her confidence in the military healthcare system was hanging by a thread at that point, and after this it was gone completely.
Naturally, I was upset. The Army can abuse me and waste my time all it wants, but I won't accept this treatment of my family. I filed an ICE complaint and expected a response within 24h. Of course that didn't happen. I pushed it up the COC and eventually I got some traction. I got a call from the highest ranking GS employee (because there was no OIC), and he was ready to apologize to my wife for wasting her time, which was one of my ICE complaint demands. I asked why the lab was closed, especially as I had called earlier in the week to confirm the lab hours. He said that right after I called the order came down from on high to close the lab for "training", and what could he as a lowly GS employee do about that? I asked how the lab plans on pushing out information to people as hours change, and he suggested a second call to confirm my earlier confirmation call. The poor guy was trying to make things right, and that was the best he could come up with: that patient's should make a second confirmation call to confirm the first confirmation call. It was at this point that my soul broke a little bit, and I thanked him for his time and efforts, and that we as a family will simply seek healthcare elsewhere. He was upset that the Army had failed its soldiers and his family, but in the end he knew I was right: the system is broken to its core and there is nothing to do to fix it except go elsewhere.
I feel this anecdote sums up everything that is wrong about healthcare delivery in the Army. Healthcare is 24/7/365. You don't close critical ancillary services like the lab or radiology on a whim for "training". If the machine is broken/on fire/aliens have invaded then yes, there will be a delay or perhaps you need to go elsewhere. This was not the case. More likely is that whoever gave the order to close the lab, which if I had to guess would have been some O5 that doesn't even work in the clinic, is more interested in 100% SHARP compliance for their OER than actually delivering healthcare.
The inmates have taken over the asylum. Whether its keeping services open, or booking OR time, or working more people into the clinic, the emphasis is not on the patient, but rather in keep the GS employees happy and helping some desk jockey officer get promoted. Doing what is best for the patient or behaving in a way that inspires trust is far, far down the list. If this was Kaiser, or Mayo, or even Our Lady of Sorrows hospital, what do you think would happen to the head of the lab if they decided to just close down lab and turn patients away? They would be out on their butt. In the Army, that same person will probably get promoted.