- Joined
- Jan 23, 2010
- Messages
- 458
- Reaction score
- 80
I wanted to highlight what I consider is an erroneous argument commonly made by the ophthos here against ODs.
The following statement was recently made in a current thread in the ophtho forum:
Without going into generalizations (e.g. commonly known statistics such as half of medical residents during their residency regret going into medicine), I'd like to bring up a specific.
There is a classmate of Eyefixer's (I won't mention his name to protect this person's anonymity) whose story is well known. This person grew up wanting to be an eye doctor and decided early on, he was going to attend medical school in order to become one. All his family and friends encouraged and supported his decision.
This person subsequently went through grade school and high school with stellar grades, eventually attending university as well as medical school - all the while working hard and keeping an eye on his dream - to become an eye doctor. Unfortunately, this person got tripped up on the USLMEs, and didn't interview particularly well. As such, though he got his MD, he didn't match into ophthalmology. He now spends his days being coughed on by AIDS patients and sticking his finger up men's rectums as a family physician.
He's an MD, but his dream of being an eye doctor was never fulfilled.
In fact, this story is common among a number of MDs who fail to match into the medical specialty of their choice. This is a matter of considerable heartbreak. Imagine growing up and spending all your life wanting to be a pediatrician. But what if you don't match? There are MDs who don't end up matching. And there isn't a lot that works as a particularly effective surrogate career, if your goal was to practice medicine for children. Or for that matter, ophthalmology.
In a subtle comparison, students who go into OD school end up as the optometrists they wanted to become.
The following statement was recently made in a current thread in the ophtho forum:
We are in the best profession available with an MD degree and that's awesome.
Without going into generalizations (e.g. commonly known statistics such as half of medical residents during their residency regret going into medicine), I'd like to bring up a specific.
There is a classmate of Eyefixer's (I won't mention his name to protect this person's anonymity) whose story is well known. This person grew up wanting to be an eye doctor and decided early on, he was going to attend medical school in order to become one. All his family and friends encouraged and supported his decision.
This person subsequently went through grade school and high school with stellar grades, eventually attending university as well as medical school - all the while working hard and keeping an eye on his dream - to become an eye doctor. Unfortunately, this person got tripped up on the USLMEs, and didn't interview particularly well. As such, though he got his MD, he didn't match into ophthalmology. He now spends his days being coughed on by AIDS patients and sticking his finger up men's rectums as a family physician.
He's an MD, but his dream of being an eye doctor was never fulfilled.
In fact, this story is common among a number of MDs who fail to match into the medical specialty of their choice. This is a matter of considerable heartbreak. Imagine growing up and spending all your life wanting to be a pediatrician. But what if you don't match? There are MDs who don't end up matching. And there isn't a lot that works as a particularly effective surrogate career, if your goal was to practice medicine for children. Or for that matter, ophthalmology.
In a subtle comparison, students who go into OD school end up as the optometrists they wanted to become.