Confusion over when to include Departmental Chair letter in application

[zebrafisher]

-

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[gutonc]

If you have it, include it.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

 

[Raryn]

Yes.

 

[Please_Stand_By]

How much weight does the Chair letter have? Only in relation to your school classmates also going into IM?

 

[zebrafisher]

Yes.

So, a program asks for 3 letters, without specifying a chair letter. My chair letter comes from someone I have met once and frankly didn't seem to like me very much. It is likely the weakest of my 4 letters. So do I submit my 2 strongest letters plus the chair? 3 strong letters without the chair? Or just stop ****ing overthinking it and just submit all 4 letters to all the programs that ask for 3 without specifying a chair?

 

[gutonc]

Or just stop ****ing overthinking it and just submit all 4 letters to all the programs that ask for 3 without specifying a chair?

This

 

[Raryn]

So, a program asks for 3 letters, without specifying a chair letter. My chair letter comes from someone I have met once and frankly didn't seem to like me very much. It is likely the weakest of my 4 letters. So do I submit my 2 strongest letters plus the chair? 3 strong letters without the chair? Or just stop ****ing overthinking it and just submit all 4 letters to all the programs that ask for 3 without specifying a chair?

3 letters is a minimum. Just send 4 to everyone.

 

[MS42017]

I have 5 letters total, including my department letter. I am assuming my department letter is the weakest overall because I did not work with the clerkship director directly, but I did do really well on the IM clerkship. For the programs that do not specify if they want a department letter, should I still send it or should I send my 4 other letters that are stronger? I don't see my department letter adding anything to my application since my clerkship comments are already in the MSPE, unless there is something else included in that letter that I am not aware of. I appreciate any advice, thanks!!