f'=f(V+- Vd)/V-+Vs)
think of it this way, when you hear a siren from a firetruck, the closer they get, the louder they are. So based on that it means their frequency is increasing.
so this means f' > f. In order for that to happen, (V+-Vd)/(V-+Vs) has to be greater than 1, and only the top signs will guarntee that.
Sorry, that's the best I can do.
you can try this equation that may be easier to remember
(delta f)/f =-v/c where's c is the speed of the wave and v is the delta v between detector and source.