repair of a transsphenoidal CSF leak today, not a great case but it got me thinking about this thread.
90% of the time I've tried to prevent bucking by giving propofol-narcotic-lidocaine. I was turned off of deep extubations by the 20 minute wake-ups of an attending who thought deep extubations needed like ~ 2.5 MAC.
Anyway, today I went with the extubate 'deep' at 0.4 MAC, or just enough that I was confident that I was not in stage 2. It worked out perfectly, she woke up like she'd been napping on the couch not having metal shoved up her nose, and it was pretty much as fast as my typical wake up.
Not the most interesting story I know, but I thought I'd share and maybe change my vote from IV meds to extubate deep.