That's the awesome thing about kinematics - most equations are derived from conservation of energy (for example, v = sqrt(2gh)). So if you plug in the proper terms, you should always get the same answer.
The AAMC in particular really likes conservation of energy, though (which makes sense). So lots of problems can be solved faster that way than by scrambling to not only remember, but also choose the relevant one of the big 5 equations you mentioned. No matter what you do, though, always keep in mind what component (vertical or horizontal) you're dealing with. This question isn't too bad because the ball was kicked vertically, but if it were kicked at an angle, you'd have to keep in mind that it still has horizontal velocity at the top.
Anyway, good question!