- Joined
- Oct 30, 2004
- Messages
- 130
- Reaction score
- 0
what do you think will happen to ortho the new unnacredited programs (jacksonville, colorado) graduating 20 each a year. where else are they due to open up.
marmoreus said:Jax, CO, UNLV and now UMKC.
The benefits of being an orthodontist will be diluted, more dentists will be drawn away from more urgently needed areas (general, pedo etc), a two-tier system will develop in orthodontics (those that trained at real programs and those that trained at OEC programs), the integrity of the profession will diminish, the practice of corporate sponsorship/control of dental education will spread to other areas of dentistry.....and on and on.
marmoreus said:Jax, CO, UNLV and now UMKC.
The benefits of being an orthodontist will be diluted, more dentists will be drawn away from more urgently needed areas (general, pedo etc), a two-tier system will develop in orthodontics (those that trained at real programs and those that trained at OEC programs), the integrity of the profession will diminish, the practice of corporate sponsorship/control of dental education will spread to other areas of dentistry.....and on and on.
It's ridiculous this is going on and that a few members of the dental profession are actively participating in it. I have no respect for anyone who is involved with OEC--including residents, faculty, deans, university presidents etc.
marmoreus said:Jax, CO, UNLV and now UMKC.
The benefits of being an orthodontist will be diluted, more dentists will be drawn away from more urgently needed areas (general, pedo etc), a two-tier system will develop in orthodontics (those that trained at real programs and those that trained at OEC programs), the integrity of the profession will diminish, the practice of corporate sponsorship/control of dental education will spread to other areas of dentistry.....and on and on.
It's ridiculous this is going on and that a few members of the dental profession are actively participating in it. I have no respect for anyone who is involved with OEC--including residents, faculty, deans, university presidents etc.
GQ1 said:do you think it will make a difference in income.
i agree with you aphistis on the ethical issues but this is america and the second question after "whats your name?" is "what do you do for a living?" ie how much do you earn. and if your profession earns you less your status and your profffessions status is reduced. so if orthos earn less their status will go down. i think we all know that if we re talking about true atatus theOMFS guys deserve it, but you here ppl saying theyre idiots for not taking the easy moneyaphistis said:I salute you, sir, for cutting through all the worthless crap--stupid, insignificant issues like "professional autonomy," "quality of care," and all the rest of that garbage--and getting to the only issue that should matter to us as professionals, the paralyzing fear of "what if we don't make as much money?"
GQ1 said:i agree with you aphistis on the ethical issues but this is america and the second question after "whats your name?" is "what do you do for a living?" ie how much do you earn. and if your profession earns you less your status and your profffessions status is reduced. so if orthos earn less their status will go down. i think we all know that if we re talking about true atatus theOMFS guys deserve it, but you here ppl saying theyre idiots for not taking the easy money
dort-ort said:Yes this is a loooonnng winded response. Sometimes however subject of this matter because of its insidious content requires longer explanations to allow people to see its true nature.
TrojanDDS said:I've asked faculty and residents at interviews what they think about OEC graduates and they say that they won't worry too much--they will ultimately inherit the cases that the OEC grads will screw up (which they will). I'm still waiting for the match in Dec. but if I don't get in this year, I will apply for a GPR and re-apply again. I will never sell my soul!!!!!!!!!!!
TrojanDDS said:I know I'm not an orthodontist yet, but I just have to vent on this subject.. what is your opinion of denturists [people with little (if any), informal training with removable prostheses] treating the cases that you learned to do in dental school w/ your teeth set-up, clinical remounts, concepts of occlusion, anatomy, etc.?
I've heard of 4+ more potential programs that may be taken over by OEC in the near future. I won't disclose their names until they become official.
GQ1 said:But a denturist doesnt even have a Bachelors, DDS or MS prostho
TrojanDDS said:I never said a denturist was a pros specialist. Like you said, they receive inferior training. Where are the OEC residents going to learn surgical cases if there is no OMFS department associated with the school??
GQ1 said:I agree with you on the point of the surgical training but unlv is planning to open departments in all specialties.
toothcaries said:...but the using "quality of care" as an arguement is weak at best.
General dentists never see a big perio/prostho case in dental school but they think they can manage and dont refer. I think someone who has gone to an OEC program will manage or at least develop in practice. Face it your only a dentists like the OEC guyTrojanDDS said:Let me make this clear, we are all colleagues and I believe that every one of us has the ability to do anything in dentistry. My point about the below standards training is that if you've never seen an orthognathic case in residency, how can you properly diagnose one in practice? Something tells me that a complete education is not one of OEC's objectives when they will not wait for the other specialty departments to open before starting their ortho program. That is my point.
UICD2: "you're a *****"? What a mature response. I guess I can excuse your immaturity given that you're only a D2. I'll give you a couple more years to grow up. The faculty at Jax, UNLV, CO all had to leave their jobs to go work for an OEC operation--pathetic. The UMKC faculty are apparently in a different position and it's not their fault. Still, I would quit before working for an OEC program and I would quit b/c my bosses would let my program be "hijacked" by OEC. Why would you want to work in such an environment? It's actually pretty easy to find another job in ortho, either in private practice or academics. But yes I do feel for them and their situation. I guess I am a *****.......please forgive me please....I can hardly see the computer screen through my tears of remorse.
We haven't even begun to talk about all of the adverse consequences of OEC.
I think we need to be informed and do what we can to protect our profession.
marmoreus said:So there is the ADA, AAO and me on one side and GavinC and J Lazarra on the other.....hmmmmm, I think I feel pretty comfortable over here.
ItsGavinC said:Nice spin. The ADA has accredited the programs (although they are and will continue to look into issues regarding that).
dort-ort said:Regarding the above comments and opinions:
It really disappoints and saddens me that someone in the dental community would have such a near-sighted and naive view of this situation with OEC.
dort-ort said:Bottom line is that when you sign on with outfits like OCA you (having invested 10 years of school and god knows how much money) will not have autonomy or independence in a career you've invested so much in and you will be immersed in self pitty when you know your orthodontic or dental colleagues down the road not contractually obligated are doing so well and are free from binding agreements governing how, when, and where they work.
dort-ort said:This is how a recent ortho grad from a traditional ortho program feels -- catch my drift Mr GAVINC. So again you should think a little more before commenting on this subject in such a naive way.
antidentite said:Two other schools were mentioned... San Antonio and I can't remember
the other one.
OCA must be stopped!!
antidentite said:www.dentist-forum.net/ dentistry/OEC_and_UMKC_224951.html
Funky_K
Subject: Re: OEC and UMKC
I am an ortho resident at Saint Louis University, and I too heard some
disturbing rumors this weekend from separate credible sources.
From what I understand, the deal at UMKC has already gone through. It
was a shock to everyone there, including the program chair, who had
know idea what was going on until it was too late. Lazzarra went
above the department to school deans and chancellors, who are
motivated by money, and probably don't fully understand the
implications of what they did.
The rumors:
Saint Louis University will soon be making an announcement that from
now on, 4 of its 14 orthodontic residencies will be taken from the OCA
(OEC) list.
Southern Illinois University is rumored to be in negotiations with
Lazzarra to start another OCA funded orthodontic residency program
(like Colorado and Jacksonville)
Two other schools were mentioned... San Antonio and I can't remember
the other one.
OCA must be stopped!!
Date: 22 Oct 2004 17:43:30
From: Joel M. Eichen
Subject: OCA rumors overheard in the hall ......
The info about SLU and San Antonio are NOT
true... Lets not spread any nasty rumors about two perfectly good
programs. SIU does not have an ortho program, but it is in the
boonies... where would they get their patients?
antidentite said:Posted by someone on another site:
www.dentist-forum.net/ dentistry/OEC_and_UMKC_224951.html
Funky_K
Subject: Re: OEC and UMKC
I am an ortho resident at Saint Louis University, and I too heard some
disturbing rumors this weekend from separate credible sources.
From what I understand, the deal at UMKC has already gone through. It
was a shock to everyone there, including the program chair, who had
know idea what was going on until it was too late. Lazzarra went
above the department to school deans and chancellors, who are
motivated by money, and probably don't fully understand the
implications of what they did.
The rumors:
Saint Louis University will soon be making an announcement that from
now on, 4 of its 14 orthodontic residencies will be taken from the OCA
(OEC) list.
Southern Illinois University is rumored to be in negotiations with
Lazzarra to start another OCA funded orthodontic residency program
(like Colorado and Jacksonville)
Two other schools were mentioned... San Antonio and I can't remember
the other one.
OCA must be stopped!!
GQ1 said:Why do you want them stopped. wire bending isnt like medicine theyre not going to kill anyone. i think we should all agree the more specialists we have the better for patient access
Dr.SpongeBobDDS said:I don't think anybody has a problem with increasing the number of ortho grads (except for those people who are in it for the money).
ItsGavinC said:Actually, it seems that IS the root problem for lots of people.
antidentite said:According to marathondoc in another thread UMKC has rejected OEC's offer. This is great news for both the specialty and the dental profession in my oppinion. If the UMKC news is accurate, this could be a turning point in the advancement of this type of educational model. Any specifics on why the deal fell through. From people I have talked to it seemed as though the deal was all but done. Perhaps did they see a withdrawel or diminished amount of quality applicants after the news was announced?
dort-ort said:Regarding the above comments and opinions:
It really disappoints and saddens me that someone in the dental community would have such a near-sighted and naive view of this situation with OEC. Next time, before you post a brash and uninformed comment just for the sake of voicing a differing opinion anecdotally, you should look into the subject matter more closely.
OCA and now OEC will eventually make a farse of orthodontist such that they will be on the same level as optometrist or pharmacists who are in every corner Walgreens or Wal-mart or CVS stores. How sad for the orthodontic profession. Worse than this is how people in the dental community see that OEC is good for the profession. how very sad. Anyways I am digressing --- getting back to my point :
Of course Lazarra being a swine that he is got out of the picture with OCA but believe you me I'm sure he still has some interest or connection with OCA whether he is public about it or not. So here's the crux of the point I am trying to make. Lazzara with all his cash is now BUYING recent grads through this orthodontic education company (OEC) of which he is CEO, such that he can place them into all the old OCA practices that are going out of business because they can't find orthodontist who will volunteerily join. So here are the OEC programs whose residents will sign a contract, once accepted stating they have to work for an OEC (really just OCA) office for seven years. Again how sad.
QUOTE]
I realize that this is an old posting, but I just have to clear something up. OEC is not and never has been affiliated with OCA. It may be the same person who started, but it's not the same company. The practices you work in are built from scratch. They aren't old OCA offices. I have a friend who is doing the program, and from what I understand, the working conditions are set by the doctor. They may have to work for them for seven years, but the doctor sets the hours, days, and staff. They have a lot of freedom...a heck of a lot more than at Western Dental type places.
texas_dds said:from a UMKC grad who is an ortho resident at another school:
the alumni at UMKC threatened to cut their support and the faculty threatened to walk - tons of letters were written from all over to stop this BS and IT WORKED! this gives me tremendous hope that established programs can be salvaged from this blight.
GQ1 said:are the oec residencies 2 or 3 years and are they paid?