What would you recommend?
I’m driving an old Mazda. All my friends out of residency (non psychiatrists) are going with the German brands. I’m strongly inclined to just go with another Mazda.
What do you like and not like about your Mazda? Are the things you like in the car you want and are the things you don't want not in them?
They are still relatively more ZoomZoom than their competition (Toyota/Honda/Hyundai/Kia), but each model has pluses and minuses compared to their equivalents.
Miata would still be the most affordable tiny roadster if you want a 2 seater convertible and don't want too many speeding tickets.
CX-5, CX-7 still perfectly fine options for their class. Some competitors are faster, have nicer interiors, or are more economical. Overall still quite fine.
Their sedans are still perfectly fine.
For me: seat comfort, fuel economy, and at least some hint of driving dynamics were most important. So I sat in every model I wanted and anything that didn't feel great was immediately axed. Then I drove all the ones that were comfortable to make sure they were still comfortable while moving. Then I axed all the ones that I didn't like the feel of the steering wheel. Then all the ones that didn't feel fast enough. Then I priced out purchase price, insurance costs, and estimated fuel and maintenance costs. I was left with the Honda Civic EX-L as the frontrunner. So I bought it and now have very minimal desire to buy something else for a long time.
The process is all specific to what you want and what's out there. If I wanted a faster car I would have spent more. If I wanted higher ride height (the thing I like least about the civic - can't see the stoplight if an SUV is in front of me), I would have chosen something else. I know that my friend who drives an R8 is at times jealous of me for being economical, probably similar to my momentary jealousy when I think of how his car has better road feel and is faster. But then I remember that I bought a house and he plans to rent for another 5 years.