Bobodr,
You're welcome to doubt whatever you want, of course 🙂
All I am doing is reporting what was told to me by ex-SMP's that were accepted this past year.
To me, it makes eminent sense that the interview would become the determining factor. All old GPA and MCAT's are, is a way to determine, objectively, whether someone can handle the med school courseload. Once you have established a 3.5 in the SMP you have *proven* that you can handle the work. At that point, the old info becomes far less relevant. At that point, it is more of a matter of "are you a good fit for Georgetown philosophically?" or "do you want to be here?" or, "do we want you here?"
Yes, GU runs the risk of lowering its numbers if it takes someone like me, who has a 2.95 in my undergrad work. But the fact is, if they were that concerned about that, I wouldn't have gained admittance to the program in the first place. If I can demonstrate I can handle the workload, and perform better than the average student they admitted this year, then I will only make GU look better in the future (match-lists, Board Scores, etc) and I would think they would be FAR more concerned about that.
And also, I should point out that I'm not saying that GU won't consider those past numbers, just that they become much less important. You are probably right: if you have two students who are identical in their performance in the SMP and in their performance in their interview, old numbers will likely be looked at more heavily. My original point was simply that a 3.8 in the SMP could not be said to give an "automatic acceptance" - the interview is VERY important in our case to determine who will or will not get in.
But that's just my opinion...