I think it's almost scarier that you can't see how this could happen. Of course, with the information presented to you in the way it was, it was clear to see that it was a stupid decision. And making the decisions isn't the hard part it's all- it's trying to make sure you have the proper information to make the decision. That's the difference between step 2 and real life.
Well, could you offer me a scenario about how such a thing could occur? Because it seems to me that, prior to ordering Tylenol, the intern would need to go through a couple of steps:
1) Not look at the chart/EMR
2) Not realize they are covering Heme/Onc, or not realize the patient is on Heme/Onc
3) Not look at the sign-out list
4) Not see the patient
5) Not question the RN further about the patient
6) Not consider the differential of fever in a hospitalized patient
Look, obviously I've been around a little bit, and yes I've heard these stories. Usually it involves waking up the intern from a deep sleep, the intern refusing to get out of bed, and the RN not pushing him/her to do their job. If this is what happened (my bet, anyway), it represents a gross dereliction of duty, and I have second-hand knowledge of two different interns being fired for exactly this scenario.
What I don't understand is why people make this choice.
I've taken more than a little call the last two years, and I have a lot more coming up. No matter how f-ing tired I get, I can't imagine snapping out a half-asleep verbal order before I even take the time to consider which patient we're talking about. I get it, people make mistakes, but most don't make this mistake. That's why I don't get it.