Go easy guys... In a process so driven by numbers, it is sometimes hard to figure out how an applicant that just looks standard (or, in his own words, "regular guy without amazing stats") would get an invite, not only to one top school -- but to Hopkins, Stanford and Harvard plus more.
Let's be real, those schools are not interested in "regular guys without amazing stats"... if they were, each of them would be all over me 😀
Obviously there is something outstanding about this individual, something that isn't noted blatantly in his mdapps. Perhaps he is overly modest or, hell, perhaps he doesn't even realize what is outstanding about himself.
Not knowing what that "thing" is and pondering the possibility that perhaps that "thing" really doesn't exist [and this individual really is just as "regular" as he claims] can certainly leave one confused as to how this process/game works.
...I imagine that is what was going through Nymphicus' mind.