From the 2011 NRMP Advanced Tables, there were 3 categorical and 7 advanced neurology programs that were unfilled. Which ones were they?
Yikes, it does indeed look like a "prestigious" manhattan program did not fill. Also it looks like 2 los angeles programs did not fill - lower tier for sure both of them but still very attractive programs to many many people just based on location. I would never have expected any of these 3 to go unfilled. It was notable for me especially because all three of these programs were ones that I would have considered highly but for which I didn't get an interview. I wonder if they had to scramble for IMG's (not to disparage IMG's).
The norcal program on probation filled, although that wasn't surprising since the probation seemed overblown and the program was actually decent.
On the other hand, there was one program that I really expected to go unfilled... filled.
Strange match year?
The LA programs probably had very stringent interview requirements and were too selective!
You can log into the nrmp site, go to my reports, and see a list of all the programs and all specialties numbers.
Are you referring to the California-or-bust lists? Or perhaps the Must-go-to-Miami lists? I agree that location becomes a huge factor in the residency choice (in contrast to the medical school choice) for many legitimate reasons. And the sunny states win that battle.
However, when it comes to arrogance, I think there's plenty of it in the northeast as well - certainly no less (and even greater imo) than the west coast bias. I've noticed quite a lot of california-bashing in the northeast, most of it coming from people who have not spent signficant time out there or none at all. There is less Miami bashing, I think, because so many more northeast snowbirds spend their winters in Florida/Carolinas and so they are more familiar with the southeast. The californians... well they generally don't think much of the east - not in the sense that they think down on the east, but rather that they don't think of the east at all for 99.9% of the time.
Yeah... when a Manhattan neuro resident told me that she was taking out loans during residency (married with kids) it made me drop Manhattan down to the bottom of my list. Still a cool city, but I guess you can't really enjoy it on ~50K/yr.