A Bunch of Really Stupid Questions...

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Campy Lobacter

You cheat, Dr. Jones!
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2007
Messages
19
Reaction score
0
I suppose I'd rather be throwing out stupid questions than stupid answers, but since I'm adept at both... Here goes... 😀

1. How freakin' awesome does this personal statement thing have to be? It's driving me crazy writing it over and over only to throw it away and start another one. Did any of you ever have anyone comment on your PS? Did it even matter? Do they even read it?
 
I actually had 2 or three places comment on my PS. I turned my work history into a fun little story that some evidently found interesting. Additionally, we were supposed to put three "interesting" things about ourselves on there (our program asked us for this). Two of my three were so off the wall that they prompted explanation, some laughing was involved, and thus the tone of the interview changed from stress to a friendly interaction. I wouldn't develop a brain cramp over it, b/c honestly, every program is getting a billion apps and don't have time to read everyones PS, etc...But if you have ANYTHING interesting, embarrassing or thought-provoking about yourself, find a way to mention it so that you will stand out from everyone else.
 
I actually had 2 or three places comment on my PS. I turned my work history into a fun little story that some evidently found interesting. Additionally, we were supposed to put three "interesting" things about ourselves on there (our program asked us for this). Two of my three were so off the wall that they prompted explanation, some laughing was involved, and thus the tone of the interview changed from stress to a friendly interaction. I wouldn't develop a brain cramp over it, b/c honestly, every program is getting a billion apps and don't have time to read everyones PS, etc...But if you have ANYTHING interesting, embarrassing or thought-provoking about yourself, find a way to mention it so that you will stand out from everyone else.

I had some interesting tidbits pulled from my PS during interviews, but I wouldn't stress over it too much.
 
A couple interviewers made positive comments about my PS. I was honest about liking EM for some of the "forbidden" reasons (lifestyle), but I had what I felt to be honest descriptions of why I felt like that was OK. In fact, I just tried to be really candid during the whole interview process. Seemed to work out OK. (Note: do not try this method if you are an @$$hole) 🙂

Side ponytails-- they were OK for Deb in Napoleon Dynamite, so they are OK for the general public.

Also, if you like A Christmas Story enough to have it as your avatar, then you're probably good to go as a person. 🙂
 
If your personal statement isn't awesome, it should at least "not suck". Not sucking involves avoiding:

a) Typos: No joke. If you can't be bothered to proofread your PS for simple misspellings and obvious punctuation errors ("...the thing I like about taking care of patient's is that they all like it when I give them narcotic's...") for the match, what do you think that says about your attention to detail as a resident? Nothing, good, my friends.

b) Rote regurgitation of the stuff in the How to Get Into a Residency Book

c) Things that imply that you are generally scary to be around, including the fact that you have no interests outside of medicine and are unable to relate to people outside of the doctor-patient relationship.
 
i went to the same medschool as kbrown, and i couldnt come up with 3 really interesting things to include. for my year at least, they wanted the 3 things for the dean's letter and they never said put them in your PS. only once did someone comment on those things, and nobody ever commented on my very generic PS.

the following is entirely my opinion, but is advice i've given to medstudents who are as lost with the whole PS thing as I was. many of the sample ones I came across on the internet were from two groups (a) they went through some life-changing traumatic incident and saw the heavenly lights shining down on the awesome ED doctor, or (b) they were former EMT/Paramedic/ED nurse and had eleventy-billion stories to talk about. I had nothing. :laugh: lol

The Personal Statement: I’ll talk about this first because it is probably the most time consuming but least important part of the whole ERAS thing (my opinion of course). When I wrote my PS I went in with the attitude that this is a way for people who have done something awesome to shine and create small talk in the opening of most interviews. However, I am apparently really boring because the only cool stuff I could think of was about my brother flying the President or things my friends had done lol. So, I looked up the basic pieces of what a PD wants to see in a PS and found these (in various forms) on tons of websites.
a. Why are you interested in this specialty?
b. What are you looking for in a program?
c. What are your future goals in this field?
Which is very basic, and some of you are probably saying “duhhhh” right now, but until I saw it written down like that I was lost. So you can very quickly have 3 sections to write on and tie together with your experiences, witticisms, or whatever you want to use. On ERAS you can make as many PS as you want, and you get to choose which program gets what PS and what LOR’s. I ended up with 4 statements; 1 each for the 2 programs I rotated at, 1 general East Coast PS since that's where I applied to the most programs, and 1 general rest of the country PS and assigned them as needed to the places I applied.
My take home message is that as long as you spell and grammar check and don’t raise any red flags with things you say, that this should not be a big stressor. I seriously doubt a PD has ever read a personal statement and been so floored they hung it on the refrigerator and promptly offered a position at their program. Keep it to 1 page, answer the 3 important questions, and spell check!

good luck
 
Antiveggies has some good advice. I agree.

Don't worry about writing a ton of personal statements either. I wrote one and sent it to everyone. Also in the what you want in a program stuff....don't get too specific and make sure the programs you apply to have that stuff (otherwise you look really dumb). Also, don't look like a needy person who wants everything.

I find that drinking a few beers (or whatever neurointoxicant you like) and writing a bunch of random ideas down can help get things started.

Also, spell check misses a lot of crap. Think of the best writer you know (like old english proff you were friends with in undergrad who maybe looked at your med school app) and ask them to review your PS, it helps. EM attendings who review it are typically not good at reviewing stuff like this, they get bored quick, and skim lots. Plus, if you can keep someone out of medicine interested in your PS likely it will work for people in EM.
 
A couple interviewers made positive comments about my PS. I was honest about liking EM for some of the "forbidden" reasons (lifestyle), but I had what I felt to be honest descriptions of why I felt like that was OK. In fact, I just tried to be really candid during the whole interview process. Seemed to work out OK. (Note: do not try this method if you are an @$$hole) 🙂

Side ponytails-- they were OK for Deb in Napoleon Dynamite, so they are OK for the general public.

Also, if you like A Christmas Story enough to have it as your avatar, then you're probably good to go as a person. 🙂

Oh, note to self then. I will suppress my inner @$$hole. I will beat it down like a baby harp seal. 😀
 
Top