She could already be pregnant. Therefore, the massive dose of contraceptive would destroy that pregnancy.
Fair enough. I guess then you would have to check whether she has already ovulated and offer her EC if she hasn't.
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
She could already be pregnant. Therefore, the massive dose of contraceptive would destroy that pregnancy.
She could already be pregnant. Therefore, the massive dose of contraceptive would destroy that pregnancy.
The mechanism of action of emergency contraception is incompletely understood. It does not interfere with an established, postimplantation pregnancy. The use of emergency contraception can delay ovulation and decrease the probability of fertilization after ovulation47; at least some of its effect appears to occur after ovulation.48
From a recent review in the New England Journal of Medicine:
The author doesn't cite a source for the statement that Plan B does not interfere with postimplantation pregnancy, so take it for what its worth. The statement did survive the peer review process, if nothing else.
But your statement insinuating that Plan B is an abortion pill is completely unfounded. The consensus is that it does NOT work in this manner.
She could already be pregnant. Therefore, the massive dose of contraceptive would destroy that pregnancy.
Problem is that many people believe that pregnancy as well as conception begin at fertilization, so preventing implantation post-fertilization would constitute intentionally impeding the embryo's growth and thus make EC an "abortifacient" intervention. If you consider pregnancy to begin at implantation, then there are no such implications.
...If a woman gets raped, give her the damn pill, send her to someone who will, or step away from the job and rethink your loyalties, for if they are to something beyond reason and and patients best interest, then the two letters after your name are no better than the lack care you would provide...
Look, doctors should have a strong sense of morality if they are to practice medicine. Practically every med school has a course on ethics just for this reason. Morals often conflict with one another, which is why discussions like these occur. That's a fact of life. If you feel that morality doesn't belong in medicine, then go into a research position instead.
For those who believe that pregnancy begins at conception (which of course is not the medical definition), do you believe that test tubes are pregnant when holding human zygotes during IVF?
Before implantation, there's no real interplay between woman and zygote/blastula/morula/blastocyst. How can you claim it's a pregnancy? Even if you believe the splitting cell is a "life," they're floating around with no attachment for five days. That's not a pregnancy.
I hope that wasn't directed at me, since I totally believe morality belongs in medicine which is why I would not allow my decisions and practices to conflict with my sense of morality and integrity.
There are three sets of values that come into this; the patient's, the physician's and the society's. None of them are absolutely determinate over the others. A compromise between them has to be struck, and that is true even when a physician has an absolute moral objection to a given course of treatment.
The rights of the patient include medical care consistent with their values, not the physician's values. The physician may believe, for example, that the human soul resides in a human being's right leg, and refuse to amputate on that account. (What does it profit a man to be rid of Clostridium perfringens if he lose his own soul?) In a situation where time is not critical, a referral is a good solution, one that 82% of physicians apparently support (if only 18% say they would not refer). But withholding treatment choices is not an option, because the contract between the physician and the patient requires the patient to rely on the physician's medical judgment. Hence, if they agree to treat the patient but refuse to inform the patient of treatments consistent with their (the patient's) values, they have substituted their values for the patients, and this is neither legal or moral (a cabdriver may refuse to take an army recruit to the airport, or, indeed, anybody anywhere, but a laywer may not withold legal options from his client because he thinks his client belongs in jail.)
In situations in which there isn't time to seek help elsewhere, or it isn't practical to do so, the physician must perform to the standard of care according to the patient's values, not their own values. Denying, say, EC in this context is similar to forcing blood on a competent, refusing Jehovah's Witness. Whether in action or in refusing to act, we serve the patients in respect for their autonomy, subject to constraints laid down, usually, in law.
It may be that a person feels they absolutely cannot be a part of some such act. That is honorable; we should respect people of conviction. They should not be physicians working in those roles, however. Their belief system disqualifies them, as often happens. You do not see Mennonites qualifying as navy SEALs; you find few Hasidim managing Red Lobster franchises. You have an absolute right to your beliefs, but not to your job, if you can't carry out your responsibilities.
In my opinion, you are far more morally guilty if you deny a rape victim emergency contraception that she desperately needs than if you prescribe it. Everyone is entitled to their own belief, but you cannot force your patients to believe the same things you do. By denying them care or a referral, you're grossly abusing your power as a physician to propagate your own belief system. 👎thumbdown👎
Your patients are more than able to go to a different doctor on their own if you don't tie them down. You are denying nothing. Maybe the problem is in a law that requires someone to be an intermediary. The patient's desire shouldn't force anyone to act antithetically to his moral code.
It wasn't meant towards you. I try to criticize ideas, not individuals. I'm glad that you have a strong sense of morality when you practice. As I'm sure you are well are of, we will at some point have to make a moral decision that will influence what treatment a patient will receive. My comment was simply meant towards those with the notion that a doctor's morals shouldn't interefere with what they will or will not do with a patient.
For example, a firefighter may not refuse to work an assigned shift, even if that shift falls on the sabbath or another holiday where their religion prohibits work.
- H
actually i don't know if that's true. most places of employment allow you to follow the "rules" and beliefs of your religious affiliation and faith, as long as it's somethinh you always standby and not just use it out of convenience.
No cardiologist would refuse to do a heart transplant otherwise he would not have become a cardiologist, no doctor would refuse women patients, and no doctor will refuse to do a abortion if the situation is life threatning. Otherwise they would not have become doctors. However, this case is different as its a emergency contraceptive.
Our mission is to provide students with free, unbiased information, resources, and advising for careers in the health professions. We believe every student deserves access to trustworthy guidance, regardless of background or ability to pay.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.