Didn't read the post in its entirety. sorry. just the meat of it. I'd say re-evaluate the rest of your application package (GPA, ECs, ECs in optometry) and what school you want to get in. If package > OAT scores, then maybe these scores will be fine. If package < OAT, then retake OAT. sounds reasonable. I'd bet definite interviews if GPA is 3.5 at least; and 70% likely to lead to interviews if GPA is 3.1 at least [GPA referring to pre-req GPA]