acceptance notifications

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Mimidoc^2

Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2004
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
So,
Do you guys think it's possible that there are programs out there which have not made all their acceptance notifications yet? I've been "on hold" at a certain school school since Jan, and their claim on Mar. 18 was that final decisions haven't been made yet...I feel put off, and I hope its not because they're deciding now who to continue waitlisting vs. who to reject. Thkx in advance for feedback.
 
Mimidoc^2 said:
So,
Do you guys think it's possible that there are programs out there which have not made all their acceptance notifications yet? I've been "on hold" at a certain school school since Jan, and their claim on Mar. 18 was that final decisions haven't been made yet...I feel put off, and I hope its not because they're deciding now who to continue waitlisting vs. who to reject. Thkx in advance for feedback.


It's definitely possible. But I'm sure more people could help you if you were willing to mention the school.
 
abeanatrice said:
It's definitely possible. But I'm sure more people could help you if you were willing to mention the school.

I know of many people with the same concerns. Personally, I am waiting on MUSC; i know of exactly one person who got in, but 5 others who have been on hold since December.
 
Mimidoc^2 said:
So,
Do you guys think it's possible that there are programs out there which have not made all their acceptance notifications yet? I've been "on hold" at a certain school school since Jan, and their claim on Mar. 18 was that final decisions haven't been made yet...I feel put off, and I hope its not because they're deciding now who to continue waitlisting vs. who to reject. Thkx in advance for feedback.

AAMC's guidelines stipulate that schools are supposed to have made a number of offers equal to the size of their incoming class by March 30. Whether they all do this or not is beyond me, but you're probably going to have to wait for some of the people that they accepted up front to drop first. I know the feeling, though. I had to call a couple of schools to get them to tell me they had made offers and had me floating around their acceptable pile/wait list months after my interviews. Check out the dates for the school's second look if they have one; I would expect a little bit of movement after that and then some more right after May 15.
 
I am in a similar situation and have been repeated told that I am still under consideration and that I should "be optimistic." It's a very cryptic language they speak, and I am really not sure how to deal with it. I know that OHSU (the school in question) does not always fill their MSTP class (last year they only filled 3 of 5 spots). They claim this is because 1) they do not offer more positions than they can fill, so the class is filled one person at a time and the "hold" list is a legitimate place to be; and 2) they are really concerned about whether a given student is a good fit.

Personally, I find this rather annoying. It's nice to know that they are taking their time and being thorough, but the runaround is a little tiring, especially in light of all of the hoops that we have jumped through already. So, in response to your question-yes, there are schools that have not made their decisions yet.
 
honeygrits said:
I know of many people with the same concerns. Personally, I am waiting on MUSC; i know of exactly one person who got in, but 5 others who have been on hold since December.

Oh wow! MUSC is the school I'm waiting on too.
 
OHSU & MUSC are fairly small programs and small programs have a particularly challenging task in managing their accepted list. They do not want to oversubscribe because they may not have the money to fund any extra students. Another reason could be that their medical school strictly limits the number of MD-PhD students they can have in the entering class. My guess would be that these schools have made some offers and that you are on a waitlist. They cannot make additional offers until some declines come in.

This is why it is important that individuals do not take overly long to make decisions. (Of course, you could say that it is hypocritical to ask applicants to make a decision in a matter of a couple of weeks when some programs do not make decisions until 3 or 4 months after the interview.) One of the applicants our program has accepted is holding acceptances at 9, count 'em 9, medical schools. I do not know if they are all MD-PhD acceptances, but i would guess that most are. I am pretty sure that this individual could discern enough differences among these 9 programs to decline at least half of the acceptances. As it is, this person is holding a number spots that other applicants are waiting to grab. I believe that 2 or 3 choices is about all anyone needs to have at this point in the game. I am sure that there are some circumstances where holding more acceptances might be justified (for example, needing to coordinate location with a significant other), but those should be the exception rather than the rule. So, if you are killing time on a waitlist, don't place all of the blame on the programs that waitlisted you; they would love to accept you as soon as some other guys act on their admissions offer. And if you are the applicant who is sitting on 9 acceptances, help a fella or gal out and jettison some of those acceptances. Decline our offer now so that we can go to the waitlist to accept someone who wants to be in our program.
 
Maebea said:
Decline our offer now so that we can go to the waitlist to accept someone who wants to be in our program.

👍 👍 👍
 
mdpdgirl said:
Are there many programs that take more than 5? All but one of the programs I was looking at take 5-6 and that last program only takes 2 people.

Yes, there are. Just about all of the programs I applied to take at least 7 per year. Penn and WashU are the largest, taking 20+ per year; Hopkins takes 12, Rochester 8, Duke 7 (I think...maybe it's 12...memory's fading), Wisconsin I can't remember but 7 sounds right. I believe Tri-I also takes over 10 per year. I'm sorry my memory's not better.

Best of luck Mimidoc, bluegrass, and the rest. :luck:
 
I know one person who got in the MSTP at MUSC, and I have been on the waiting list since december as well. I really thought that my chances were pretty good because from looking at their stats from previous years they end up accepting nearly 50% of those they interview. Oh well. add me to the list of waitlistees at MUSC. we have 7 of us now that we know about on this forum?

Good luck all
 
Top