Accepting Acceptances

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

EquestriAnn

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2008
Messages
196
Reaction score
0
Ok so I'm still really confused about how this works, I'm sure people have asked it before and I found some stuff about dental school, but I can't seem to find a straight answer for psych. This April 15th date, is that for all PhD programs or just clinical? I applied to behavioral neuroscience and so far I've gotten 2 acceptances. So do I have until April 15th to tell them yes/no? And then if I tell one of them no on April 15th, do they then go and offer the spot to someone else after that date? And then what if that person had accepted another offer, couldn't this thing go on for a long time so that everyone gets a student? So I could accept one of my offers and then get an offer from one of the schools I didn't get accepted to, which I might have to take sight unseen if I wanted it? I would feel really badly leaving someone hanging, but if I got into one of the schools that didn't interview me, I would be really torn because they were my top choices. This is all really stressful!!
 
First of all, congratulations! 2 acceptances are terrific! I have to say that I'm not sure about the April 15th deadline for non-clinical students, but I'm guessing it is around there, given what I hear talked about at my school. So, I'm not much help there. But in terms of what to do next, I would take 2 steps. First, over the next week or so, try to figure out which of those 2 schools you like more, and then turn down one of the acceptances, so you're not holding two for that long. Especially as you're waiting to get into other schools, you know how important it is for people to reject the offers they're not taking!

Secondly, I'd email the professors you want to work with at your top schools and check in about their admissions process and if it's possible for you to get in. Since non-clinical programs often don't interview, you're right that it's possible to get in sight unseen. Clearly, asking would show you're interested. And, if you hear that no more offers will be made, or you're out of the running, you can accept at the school you're in and be on your merry way! If they say it's still a possibility for you to get in and you really want it, I'd hold on to your top acceptance and wait it out. BUT, you'll have to keep checking in. Rejection letters often don't come until May, way after all decisions have been made, so there's no way to know unless you've checked with the program.
 
Rules for Acceptance of Offers for Admission and Financial Aid
Fall Admissions
Most graduate programs in psychology and associated fields accept students only for fall admission. However, if you are interested in winter, spring, or summer admission, you should check the application information for the department to which you are applying.

You may make as many applications as you wish, but do not apply for an appointment that you would not consider accepting. Informal notification is often sent by the department, or by an individual who has funds for a research assistant. If you receive and accept such an offer, you may relax, confident that you will eventually receive formal notification of your admission to the graduate school and, if applicable, of your appointment as an assistant. Scholarships, fellowships, assistantships, traineeships, and other stipends for the following academic year are normally offered before April 1.

You may get more than one offer before April 15 and may receive a few statements that you are listed as an alternate. In fairness to the graduate programs, as well as the other applicants seeking admission, you are strongly urged not to hold more than one offer pending at a time. To protect a candidate against premature decisions, graduate schools currently have agreed to allow the applicant until April 15 for a final decision. This is in accordance with a resolution adopted by the Council of Graduate Schools in the United States in 1965 and further modified by the Council of Graduate Departments of Psychology (COGDOP) in 1981. The 1965 resolution of the Council of Graduate Schools in the United States was supported by 317 universities and colleges and by the directors of four granting agencies, both public and private. It reads as follows:

Acceptance of an offer of financial aid (such as graduate scholarship,
fellowship, traineeship, or assistantship) for the next academic year
by an actual or prospective graduate student completes an agreement
which both student and graduate school expect to honor. In those
instances in which the student accepts the offer before April 15,
and subsequently desires to withdraw, the student may submit in
writing a resignation of the appointment at any time through April 15.
However, an acceptance given or left in force after April 15 commits
the student not to accept another offer without first obtaining a
written release from the institution to which a commitment has been
made. Similarly, an offer by an institution after April 15 is conditional
on presentation by the student of the written release from any
previously accepted offer. It is further agreed by the institution and
organizations subscribing to the above Resolution that a copy of
this Resolution should accompany every scholarship, fellowship,
traineeship, and assistantship offer.

In 1981, COGDOP modified the resolution regarding offering and accepting financial aid after April 15:

An acceptance given or left in force after April 15 commits the
student not to solicit or accept another offer. Offers made after
April 15 must include the proviso that the offer is void if acceptance
of a previous offer from a department accepting this resolution is in
force on that date. These rules are binding on all persons acting on
behalf of the offering institution.

In November 1988, the Board of Directors of COGDOP passed the following motion:

That the currently prevailing procedures dealing with the offering and
Acceptance of financial aid are intended to cover graduate admissions
As well as offers of financial aid. To protect candidates against the
Need to make premature decisions, graduate programs should allow
Applicants until April 15 to make final decisions.


Accepting an Offer


We suggest the following procedures in helping you to make a decision:

1. As soon as you have two offers, decide which is the better one for you and politely refuse the other.
2. Repeat this comparison and decision as you receive each new offer.
3. Terminate the process as soon as you get a satisfactory offer from the school you prefer. Accept that offer verbally and in writing and advise the other schools of your decision. They will appreciate your thoughtfulness in opening the way for another student.
4. On occasion you may be pressured to accept an offer before April 15. In the event that you have accepted such an offer, you should be fully aware that you have the right to resign the original acceptance before April 15 to take an alternative offer.
5. When you have voluntarily accepted an appointment, even prior to the April 15 date, do not take your obligation lightly. You are committed to that acceptance. Attempts to be released from an agreement may spoil your reputation with all of the institutions involved and with your sponsors.

6. If you receive no offers by April 15, there is still a possibility that you may be admitted at a later time. Vacancies occasionally occur as grants are announced. The APA Education Directorate publishes a list of remaining openings in May. You may write to the Directorate to receive a copy of this list. Information on graduate openings will be posted on the APA Web site (http://www.apa.org) by early May.



 
I think at some point, it becomes a logjam, since many people get accepted at multiple programs, and many people probably get waitlisted at many programs. The longer the multiple-acceptance people take to bow out of the schools they won't be attending, the crazier the middle of April becomes for everyone.

My philosophy would be to create a hierarchy of all your programs. If you apply to nine programs and get into number 5, withdraw from 6 through 9 even if you're still waiting on 1 through 4. You don't have to accept number five just yet, but you'll make life that much easier for the applicants and waitlisters on 6 through 9.
 
Top