Youre correct to question the numbers. I have no doubt that the match rate is 100% for eligible match participants. The fact is, however, that if you never pass the boards, then youll never be eligible to match and, therefore, you never factor into match statistics.
Personally, getting my medical education in Ireland was the best decision I ever made. I received an excellent education (if not different from the US), was afforded the opportunity to explore Europe, and met some of the best friends in my life. That said, in order to garner my current American post-graduate position, I needed to score in the top 99% on the USMLEs.
I believe the Irish offer an excellent medical education for their system. Its differences, however, can be devastating to the mediocre student who feels they can get their MD (actually MB, BCh, BAO) abroad and come to the US unaffected. For success, introspection is mandatory.
I would be happy to discuss this offline to folks with serious concerns about their decisions.
Best,
Mick
UCD 2003