Baylor (Houston) vs. Jackson/Miami vs. Boston U

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

radapplicant920

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2013
Messages
21
Reaction score
13
I got good vibes from all three of these programs. The geographic differences are obvious but let's suppose I'd be reasonably happy in any of these locations and have no clue where I want to live 10 years down the road. What do you think has the best prospects for fellowship/private practice/academics? I'm particularly interested (but obviously not limited to) IR. Any constructive insight would be very much appreciated!

Members don't see this ad.
 
I can only speak for Miami. It was my home program, so I may be a little biased. It is a great program. 11 residents per year, huge faculty size, Jackson Memorial Hospital is a public hospital with plenty of international patients.... leads to very diverse pathology. Gary Danton is a great program director and mentor. IR would be a great experience. I did research with one of the IR guys there. It was one of my top choices on my rank list. Will be pursuing fellowship in the future there.
 
I can only speak for Baylor but it was one of my favorite programs hands down. Baylor's radiology residency is similar to its other residencies in that it's on the busier side. There's generally a work hard, play hard vibe; it's not for everyone. I can speak volumes for the program's PD who is 100% on the resident's side. Residents have a large amount of autonomy (and responsibility) at the county hospital and are the primary operator for most of the IR. I would say the residents certainly have a stronger IR experience at Ben Taub General Hospital than at MD Anderson across the street where things are more attending run. BCM is opening up a new hospital soon which is meant to replace its big private hospital affiliation with The Methodist Hospital.

I've never felt like fellowship placement was a good indicator of the strength of a residency program. It seems that every radiology residency places their residents in big name fellowships. You should probably do your fellowship in the region that you want to practice in. I don't think either of these programs will give you an advantage towards breaking into a specific region.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I can only speak for Baylor but it was one of my favorite programs hands down. Baylor's radiology residency is similar to its other residencies in that it's on the busier side. There's generally a work hard, play hard vibe; it's not for everyone. I can speak volumes for the program's PD who is 100% on the resident's side. Residents have a large amount of autonomy (and responsibility) at the county hospital and are the primary operator for most of the IR. I would say the residents certainly have a stronger IR experience at Ben Taub General Hospital than at MD Anderson across the street where things are more attending run. BCM is opening up a new hospital soon which is meant to replace its big private hospital affiliation with The Methodist Hospital.

I've never felt like fellowship placement was a good indicator of the strength of a residency program. It seems that every radiology residency places their residents in big name fellowships. You should probably do your fellowship in the region that you want to practice in. I don't think either of these programs will give you an advantage towards breaking into a specific region.

Can you comment on the readout / teaching at Baylor. It is one of the programs I am strongly considering, but I am concerned about how much the faculty cares about residents learning as opposed to being dictation slaves. It seemed like residents were confined to their rooms in BT and rarely saw an attending.
 
Miami is the only one I can comment on. I didn't rank it as high for a couple of reasons. One is simply that I'm not that crazy about south Florida. I also think there are a lot of question marks on the financial end with the hospital. I also found it weird how the number one comment about the program was, "It is in Miami!"

The pathology is hard to beat. The medical campus as a whole is beautiful. (The radiology department not so much) The PD really is a nice guy and I probably would've had great opportunities to fulfill my interests in RIS/Informatics there. It is a big city with lots to do, if you have the cash for it. IR seemed strong there. Residents seemed happy overall. Many of the faculty seemed to train there and stick around.

I didn't get quite the warm fuzzy feeling some other places gave me and my interests in strength training/strongman would lead to fairly long drives to the places I'd want to train at routinely. (I hate the chromed out fitness centers, although I do enjoy cardio bunnies)
 
Can you comment on the readout / teaching at Baylor. It is one of the programs I am strongly considering, but I am concerned about how much the faculty cares about residents learning as opposed to being dictation slaves. It seemed like residents were confined to their rooms in BT and rarely saw an attending.

On the tour there were attendings reading with the residents so I didn't get that feeling at all. Think you'll have to talk to a resident to find out more about this.
 
Top