- Joined
- Oct 11, 2006
- Messages
- 236
- Reaction score
- 1
What do you guys think?
you don't need to take step 1 to graduate at all. Just if you want to practice.Just to be clear... I thought Vandy allowed Step 1 to be taken any time before graduation. Is that not the case?
Baylor!!! ...but some of my reasons are kind of personal.
Houston is never cold like TN is for three full months of the year (I'll take Houston's heat over the freezing cold any day).
Personally, I don't like the accent of the people from TN; I find it intolerable! Native Houstonians have a 'flat' accent--not at all twangy or sing-songy like people think Texans should sound. BTW, I grew up in a state adjacent to TN, so I am quite familiar with TN, and I made it a point to get the hell out of there and lose that hideous accent as soon as I (legally) could.
The food in Houston is the best in the world.
Houston is a very INexpensive city...low cost of living. Also, TX has no state tax, in case you later decide to stay here and work.
The TMC (where I have worked for several years) cannot be beat. Nuf said about that.
Baylor tuition is CHEAP CHEAP CHEAP!!
You'd be CRAZY to go to Vanderbilt!
Thanks for the replies! I'm just trying to get a sense of all the factors people are considering. So far I've got:
Curriculum
Hospital System
City
Weather
Accents (come on, really?)
Money
Personally, I'm considering factors outside of money b/c i'm MSTP [so I likely won't be giving up a spot for you guys =)]. I know everyone says research should be the biggest deciding factor, but one can only have one PI and both places have national academy members/howard hughes investigators in my fields of interest.
Anyway, as an MSTP, I will be spending 7-8 years at whatever place I choose (yikes - I'll be 30 when I graduate!). So, well I've decided having a life during my 20s is a factor - any comments there?
Anyway, as an MSTP, I will be spending 7-8 years at whatever place I choose (yikes - I'll be 30 when I graduate!). So, well I've decided having a life during my 20s is a factor - any comments there?
Thanks for the replies! I'm just trying to get a sense of all the factors people are considering....
Accents (come on, really?)
Houston is never cold like TN is for three full months of the year (I'll take Houston's heat over the freezing cold any day).
Personally, I don't like the accent of the people from TN; I find it intolerable! Native Houstonians have a 'flat' accent--not at all twangy or sing-songy like people think Texans should sound. BTW, I grew up in a state adjacent to TN, so I am quite familiar with TN, and I made it a point to get the hell out of there and lose that hideous accent as soon as I (legally) could.
1) Weather-wise it does get cold in Nashville in the winter, but it's a lot milder than a NE winter, that's for sure.
2) People in Nashville don't have twangy accents.
3) Nashville is also a very inexpensive city (I've lived in DC and in NYC) and there is no state income tax here either.
4) After you get your fin aid package from Vanderbilt, it too can be relatively cheap. So deciding on tuition alone might be something you want to wait on until after you fill out all your fin aid forms.
linguistic fators.
That and I hope you can speak Spanish, b/c I'm fairly sure that's what you'll be hearing the most in county hospitals in South Texas =). The 'less-educated' or the more rural people from most state have accents whether it be Boston, NYC, Alabama or Chicago. You may hate the TN one, but you won't be escaping accents anywhere.
I think being MSTP changes things a little. I would probably go to Vandy in that case [I said go to Baylor before]. The reason is that as a medical scientist in training, you're probably quite frankly not as interested in the slightly better clinical training you'll receive at Baylor. And money is no longer an issue. Nashville's a cool place to be, Vandy has a cool undergrad right there, and I think it would generally be a cooler place to spend that much of your life than Houston.
Also...and this one is HUGE for me...people in KY, TN, NC (tobacco states basically) tend to smoke so so so much more than they do in Houston!! It kills me every time I go up there...you just can't get away from the friggin' smoke!!!
I speak fluent, unaccented, Argentinian Spanish.👍
Then you'll have no problem 😀 ! I almost think Spanish should be a prerequisite to setting foot in a TX hospital. It can make or break your clinical years/experience.
Hmm, interesting. You said you're from TN so I know how you know the 'coolness' factor of Nashville. What's your experience with Houston?
I speak super-crappy border Spanish... that's it 🙁 Maybe I should go buy a book or something.Hahahaha, yes it is practically a pre-req! More importantly, the fact that I speak Spanish makes my super shi**y MCAT look so much better!![]()
If you're talking straight up which place is better to live, I'm going to go with Nashville. Houston is a massive spread out city and while Rice Village/TMC is an interesting area... the rest is boring.My only experience with Baylor is being down there are few days last year while interviewing. Houston is just a HUGE spread out place. I'm also really just judging from what I saw around both campuses. Baylor doesn't have an undergrad right there [although Rice is right there and there are cool places down in that area]. It's just a general impression thing based on the fact that Vandy has all the undergrad stuff right there and would probably be a great place to spend 7-8 years. Also, I'm a guitar player, and Nashville is Nashville. If you like music, it's there.....
Baylor all the way.....although I don't care for Houston much, but whatever....I figure the quality of the education trumps a mediocre city. I'm in the process of learning Spanish so that I can go to Peru for a while, so that won't be a problem.If you're talking straight up which place is better to live, I'm going to go with Nashville. Houston is a massive spread out city and while Rice Village/TMC is an interesting area... the rest is boring.
Now if there was a med school in Austin... 🙂
Then you'll have no problem 😀 ! I almost think Spanish should be a prerequisite to setting foot in a TX hospital. It can make or break your clinical years/experience.
Linguistic Factors: How do you feel about the grammatical construct of "fixing to"? as in "I'm fixing to study for the anatomy exam next week." Also, "ain't" and "done + past partciple." "I ain't heard nothing about that, but she done studied 'till the cows came home." That's classic Texan I've weeded out from my speech. If you can stomach those and ample usage of "y'all", then Texas is definitely for you.
I speak super-crappy border Spanish... that's it 🙁 Maybe I should go buy a book or something.
BTW, your avatar continues to make me smile 🙂
You going to apply to Baylor next year? (You're applying the next cycle right?)Baylor all the way.....although I don't care for Houston much, but whatever....I figure the quality of the education trumps a mediocre city. I'm in the process of learning Spanish so that I can go to Peru for a while, so that won't be a problem.
I NEVER said that they had a twangy accent. I said that TEXANS DON'T. In fact, I wish that TN's accent was *just* twangy. It's not the accent alone; it's also the grammar, the extremely regional lexicon, and other linguistic fators.
That's an good point - I hate smoking too. Anyone know what anti-smoking laws currently are in Nashville/Houston and if they might change in the future?
I wish! I love Austin and would totally go to med school there.Now if there was a med school in Austin... 🙂
being allergic to tobacco smoke, I had no trouble getting around in nashville. plus, i could never live in houston because the pollution there isn't very good for my health.
Here is a link to an article in the Tennessean about it:
http://www.tennessean.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070211/OPINION03/702110368/1007/OPINION
Ok now, in regards to the social scene at Vanderbilt . . .
Both are excellent schools and are hard to distinguish in terms of quality of education, so you have to go with the one that has the best bottom line after financial aid.
Oh, just suck it up and stop whining ya big crybaby!!![]()
But seriously, about the smoke thing...it's a *cultural* difference that I just can't change or get over, so I would never choose to live in TN. Houston's pollution may be the same sort of 'dealbreaker' for you (but really, the air does *seem* completely normal here).
Nope.....two years. 😀You going to apply to Baylor next year? (You're applying the next cycle right?)
HAPPY B-DAY VANDYXGIRL!!!![]()
![]()
P.S. There's nothing to forgive! 🙂
My one qualm about Baylor is its name...they should really change the name so people don't think its associated with uber-crazy conservative Baylor U.
info from US News Rankings:
Peer Assesment score (5=max) ------ BCM=4.0 Vandy=4.1
Residency Directors Assesment score (5=max) ---- BCM=3.8 Vandy=4.1
info from US News Rankings:
Peer Assesment score (5=max) ------ BCM=4.0 Vandy=4.1
Residency Directors Assesment score (5=max) ---- BCM=3.8 Vandy=4.1
Yeah, I noticed the seemingly-lower-than-what-one-would-guess residency score of Baylor too. Anyone have some insight?
Ooooooooooh *snap* someone just got burned. When you are dealing with schools that are ranked 10th and 17th (research by U.S. News) they are definitely on the same level. And these rankings are skewed anyway because who cares how much NIH funding a school gets if you as a student don't get to touch it? They really should change it to NIH funding/student researcher (or something along those lines).
OP, why don't you spend a few days in Nashville and a few in Houston (that is if you can spare the time) and then see where you would rather be? After all, it's going to be you who is going to have to spend your years at wherever.