Being "unique"

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

medguy13

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
112
Reaction score
11
Shouldn't schools focus more on what you've done, rather than looking to see how you are different than everyone else? I think the concept of a "cookie-cutter applicant", which is a term thrown around this forum a lot, is complete BS. So what if other people have done the same things that you have done? Does that de-value the experience at all? I don't think so, but reading this forum, it seems that it does for the ADCOMs.

Any one else have a problem with this?
 
most people are cookie cutter. honestly, very few people have truly unique experiences. ADCOMs have seen it all. it's not about being unqiue vs cookie cutter really, it's about having done worthwhile things with your time, understanding why you want to go into medicine and being able to put that into words
 
Let's put it this way: You have <200 seats to fill from a pool of 10,000 applicants. You're going to need some way to cull the herd. Having unique aspects to your application naturally makes you stand out from the hoi polloi of pre-meds. Being unique does not inherently make you better, it just makes you stand-out and more memorable to adcoms.
 
I think these questions are more about seeing what kind of person you are outside of the common experiences many people list. Once they can check off that you've got that set of activities and things to pseudo-prepare you for medical school, they want to know what else you've got.

I don't think adcoms are de-valuing the cookie cutter aspect, but they're looking beyond it. They want to layer those experiences on to you as an applicant, not replace your cookie cutter experiences. Because even though a huge number of applicants have volunteering, shadowing, research, etc., we are not the same person and I think they're just looking for that distinction.
 
Students learn from one another in small group settings and on the wards where they learn from the students and trainees ahead of them. If everyone were exactly the same with the same experiences, the same summer jobs, and the same family background and the same religious upbringing (or lack of religion), and the same interests and hobbies outside of school/medicine, our medical school would be a very boring place and not the ideal setting for learning.

Having something that is a bit different than most (all) other applicants adds a bit of interest to the tossed salad that is the med school class.
 
This is interesting. I've just recognized that my secondaries sound a lot like, "Look at all these relevant things I've done; I've gained experiences and lessons you value." But they probably want to hear more about you, the medium through which these experiences occurred. But you can't talk about the medium without the actual experience - and you're limited to tiny character limits so, it's a challenge to make it a balanced, compelling piece with nice, internal reflections and crap. Perhaps this is why things come off cookie cutter. This is probably why the interview is so important.

You know what I'm sayin? Cuz I'm not sure what I'm sayin. I need to chew on this a little longer myself.
 
Shouldn't schools focus more on what you've done, rather than looking to see how you are different than everyone else? I think the concept of a "cookie-cutter applicant", which is a term thrown around this forum a lot, is complete BS. So what if other people have done the same things that you have done? Does that de-value the experience at all? I don't think so, but reading this forum, it seems that it does for the ADCOMs.

Any one else have a problem with this?

unique is a bad and overused word. Very few people are unique. No matter how many starving minority aids babies you chewed up and regurgitated food for, and no how many medical missions you took to chew up said food, other people have probably done it more times than you and done it better than you and applied to medical schools with this as an EC, and likely submitted their applications earlier in the cycle than you did.

"cookie-cutter applicant" refers to the applicant with just the very typical (and arguably boring) volunteer/hospital/research trifecta of extracurriculars and nothing else to distinguish themselves from the tens of thousands of other applicants. The applicant that, while he did volunteer in a hospital, in a soup kitchen, with the homeless, and while he did play with test tubes in some fancy lab, almost every other applicant has done the same thing.

But striving to be "unique" is a very SDN thing....don't worry about focus on trying to be "unique," but rather to think outside the box a little and build some valuable (to you, not to others) life experiences instead. Don't just simply check off box after box after box just because you are concerned about fitting within the status quo.
 
unique is a bad and overused word. Very few people are unique. No matter how many starving minority aids babies you chewed up and regurgitated food for, and no how many medical missions you took to chew up said food, other people have probably done it more times than you and done it better than you and applied to medical schools with this as an EC, and likely submitted their applications earlier in the cycle than you did.

"cookie-cutter applicant" refers to the applicant with just the very typical (and arguably boring) volunteer/hospital/research trifecta of extracurriculars and nothing else to distinguish themselves from the tens of thousands of other applicants. The applicant that, while he did volunteer in a hospital, in a soup kitchen, with the homeless, and while he did play with test tubes in some fancy lab, almost every other applicant has done the same thing.

But striving to be "unique" is a very SDN thing....don't worry about focus on trying to be "unique," but rather to think outside the box a little and build some valuable (to you, not to others) life experiences instead. Don't just simply check off box after box after box just because you are concerned about fitting within the status quo.

Everyone is unique. The point is to be memorable. 😉
 
Top