That's not really surprising that CVP, value or trend, is pretty much worthless.
Although I agree with you on the futility of using CVP alone for fluid management, I would say it is not a worthless number. If my starting CVP is 20 and I'm now running at 12, I would be a bit more concerned. Of course, by that time, I would already have picked it up on other patient data such as surgical bleeding in the field, cell saver, BPs, U/O, need for vasopressors, color of the skin, TEE and one of my favorites... finger on the pulse. A CVP of 12 from 20 is just another color in the overall picture. I wouldn't consider it worthless, but others might.
The above 2 pics does show a decrease in both CVP and CO/SV.... but obviously CO/SV are more meaningful. I was just making a comment on observation. I wasn't implying that I use CVP to guide my fluid management. That would be very short minded. Just an observation.
I don't think these patients automatically have to be edematous. Obviously prone will cause some but it's amazing how not-puffy pts look when they don't get a ton of crystalloid.
I 100% agree with you in that patients don't have to wake up edematous. 90% of my patients don't, but I always keep my crystalloids to a minimum and use @ least 500ccs of albumin (usually 1000ccs) and use prbcs when appropriate. This was an 11 hour case with a HUGE incision that had at least 1600 of surgical bleeding despite an amicar infusion (I don't do permissive hypotension in 77 y/o patients with DM as I'm more concerned about hypoperfusion of brain, kidneys, eyeballs, etc).
25% albumin and blood on top of a maintenance NS infusion
I've never thought of 25% albumin for these cases... It is an interesting thought though. We give 250cc's of 25% albumin for our cardiac cases as we try and limit our crystalloids for these cases as well. We find it beneficial when we start wrapping once the aortic cannula is in, then wrap again once the venous line is in... we also use whole blood cardioplegia (also nice to dial in your K+). This cuts down on our hemodilution significantly.
For the spine case, the patient got 1500 of albumin, 4U of prbcs, 1 of platelets, 2.5 of crystalloids, 500 of cell saver + the amicar that was infused. U/O was 700 for the case.
Minimal swealling... eyelids and a little around the lips. Extubated in the pacu after 30 minutes of 45 degress. Good airlieak and following commands.
She had a mild mixed acidosis at the end of the case. Since she was going to be extubated, I didn't want to give bicarb. I gave THAM instead and dropped her off in the ICU with a PH of 7.29.
PACU hgb was 12. The following morning it was 10. POD #2 it was 9.2.
Sounds like there isn't a consensus for colloids here. Albumin vs Voluven isn't quite sorted out, but with the bogus studies for starches, I've been sticking to albumin.
Here we are getting albumin @ $50 per 500cc
HES is $10... but that is dirty.
I don't remember off the top of my head how much Voluven costs..
Addendum:
Just double checked:
Albumin $70
Vouven $50
Hes $10