- Joined
- Nov 17, 2007
- Messages
- 260
- Reaction score
- 3
This is a rant.
I've been a resident for almost 3 years (moonlighting for almost a year), and I have a nemesis, and it is bipolar disorder.
I spend so much time undoing this diagnosis, weening people (cautiously and collaboratively, of course) from an over-simplified understanding of their lives and symptoms. They come to me on amazing amounts of medicine that they've been on for years with a diagnosis of bipolar disorder that I can tear apart after a 30 minute interview (and I am a very careful diagnostician; avoiding assumptions, knowing criteria, obtaining collateral, open to surprise, wanting to make sense of these peoples lives). In fact, I wish they DID have bipolar disorder because then things would be so much simpler (from a treatment perspective, at least). These people are super sick, have terrible mood troubles, but are almost invariably better described as personality disordered or as having anger or substance or relational problems. most probably have good old major depression. but not bipolar disorder.
Now, I have great respect for bipolar type I disorder. It's a nasty disease. It's also terribly EASY to diagnose. I've seen it countless times on inpt units. These patients are truly maniacal for WEEKS (not days) and typically are chronically depressed (though not always).
And after 3 years of residency, I have no idea what bipolar type II disorder is. I've been trained to screen for maniacal tendencies and patterns that meet dsm criteria. And I do, for every patient. I screen for it. And I suppose some people could meet criteria, but again.... they are almost invariably described better by something else. Seems the idea that someone can be a 'little bit' bipolar has translated to diagnoses en masse.
This is not simply a pet peeve. I see this diagnosis everywhere. This is like an epidemic. Drives me nuts. For me it symbolizes lazy thinking on our part, or worse, that we are a field at odds with itself, unable to make sense of the human condition and using well-meaning but poorly constructed disease models to sooth ourselves. I only very rarely find a clinician who is conscientious of these issues. we are not be trained to think with nuance. Very frustrating.
I'm even thinking of doing child/adol training not because I LOVE working with kids but because at least there I might get some explicit experience with attachment issues, family/relational issues, behavioral issues.... adult training hints at these but has largely succumbed to a biological approach... and bipolar disorder.
And I feel lonely when I bring the issue up with other residents or attendings because I'm either anti-psychiatry or I haven't screened carefully enough or I don't understand the criteria or I don't have enough experience, etc. I'm sure some of you will agree with them. ....I hope they're right. I hope as things go on that it will all coalesce, that these hordes actually do have bipolar disorder and psychiatry is not nuts. But I doubt it.
Sigh. Makes me worry about my future in this field that seems so very unaware of itself.
Rant done, folks. Sorry if I've ruined anyone's dinner.
I've been a resident for almost 3 years (moonlighting for almost a year), and I have a nemesis, and it is bipolar disorder.
I spend so much time undoing this diagnosis, weening people (cautiously and collaboratively, of course) from an over-simplified understanding of their lives and symptoms. They come to me on amazing amounts of medicine that they've been on for years with a diagnosis of bipolar disorder that I can tear apart after a 30 minute interview (and I am a very careful diagnostician; avoiding assumptions, knowing criteria, obtaining collateral, open to surprise, wanting to make sense of these peoples lives). In fact, I wish they DID have bipolar disorder because then things would be so much simpler (from a treatment perspective, at least). These people are super sick, have terrible mood troubles, but are almost invariably better described as personality disordered or as having anger or substance or relational problems. most probably have good old major depression. but not bipolar disorder.
Now, I have great respect for bipolar type I disorder. It's a nasty disease. It's also terribly EASY to diagnose. I've seen it countless times on inpt units. These patients are truly maniacal for WEEKS (not days) and typically are chronically depressed (though not always).
And after 3 years of residency, I have no idea what bipolar type II disorder is. I've been trained to screen for maniacal tendencies and patterns that meet dsm criteria. And I do, for every patient. I screen for it. And I suppose some people could meet criteria, but again.... they are almost invariably described better by something else. Seems the idea that someone can be a 'little bit' bipolar has translated to diagnoses en masse.
This is not simply a pet peeve. I see this diagnosis everywhere. This is like an epidemic. Drives me nuts. For me it symbolizes lazy thinking on our part, or worse, that we are a field at odds with itself, unable to make sense of the human condition and using well-meaning but poorly constructed disease models to sooth ourselves. I only very rarely find a clinician who is conscientious of these issues. we are not be trained to think with nuance. Very frustrating.
I'm even thinking of doing child/adol training not because I LOVE working with kids but because at least there I might get some explicit experience with attachment issues, family/relational issues, behavioral issues.... adult training hints at these but has largely succumbed to a biological approach... and bipolar disorder.
And I feel lonely when I bring the issue up with other residents or attendings because I'm either anti-psychiatry or I haven't screened carefully enough or I don't understand the criteria or I don't have enough experience, etc. I'm sure some of you will agree with them. ....I hope they're right. I hope as things go on that it will all coalesce, that these hordes actually do have bipolar disorder and psychiatry is not nuts. But I doubt it.
Sigh. Makes me worry about my future in this field that seems so very unaware of itself.
Rant done, folks. Sorry if I've ruined anyone's dinner.
Last edited: